Late in 2021 I started feeling like my music tastes were getting stale, and that there were a lot of big landmark albums and artist discographies that I had never really delved into, so I started making efforts at compiling a list of albums to listen to. That list and listening through it went through a couple haphazard iterations, before I settled on my current more comprehensive method. Selection criteria is: must have received 4.5 or 5 stars on allmusic, have an actual review, be findable in a streaming app (or compilable as a playlist), cannot be a comedy album or a film/broadway soundtrack, compilation, greatest hits, or ethnographic recording. Beyond that it’s purely qualitative: the criteria typically leave me with 3-500 albums for a year. I go through each one, read the reviews, talk to people, pare down albums that feel skippable, after which I settle on a list of around 70-100 albums that seem historically important, influential, well-regarded, and represent a well-rounded, varied sample of music coming out for that year. I organize it into an approximately chronological order based on album release date, and listen.
Listening is very intentionally not serious. I think one of the major issues with when I tried to do something similar with movies was that I took myself way too seriously. Operating with the knowledge that others might be watching, that I felt like I had to say something serious, interesting, or profound made what was supposed to be a fun process of personal discovery into a slog. Mostly it operates as a list to draw from when I’m working or cooking and I want something novel to listen to, and is mostly experienced impressionistically rather than something more rigorous or, like, hermeneutical I guess??
The list is still ongoing. I’ve now listened to around 850 albums and am currently wrapping up the last 10 or so albums of 1968. It’s been a great exercise, I feel like I’ve learned so much, both from the making of the list, and from the listening. My goals of finding new artists and genres, and doing deeper/more comprehensive dives into artists’ discographies are being achieved. It’s been nice to hear albums in their historical and sonic context rather than in isolation or as part of an individual artist’s discographic development. The intertextualities become revealed: you get to see how Dylan speaks to the Beatles speaks to the Beach Boys speaks to the Byrds and back around again. You get to watch the development of musical subcultures, how they work and collaborate and communicate with others within that subculture, then perhaps “break containment,” affecting other subcultures who then modulate and innovate within their own subculture (e.g. the interplay between the LA, Nashville, New York, SF, and London scenes for rock/folk/country; or Chicago, Memphis, Detroit, and Philadelphia for Soul). Placing the albums in context also makes the exceptional, the novel, and the groundbreaking really shine in a way that is harder to appreciate when you’re listening to 100 earth-shattering records decontextualized and back to back. Elvis and Buddy Holly feel like shotgun shells to the chest when heard after dozens of hours of crooners. You also get to appreciate how influential their work is. Hearing the Byrds’ debut, or Phil Spector enter the scene is affecting, but I feel like I’ve gotten a greater appreciation for their influence when the year following their respective debut features like 60% albums that sound *exactly* like that debut.
So it’s been good fun! At the rate I’m going it would be like at least a decade before I caught up, but I’m mostly fine with that? I’m trying to be mindful of when I’m getting burnt out, or when I’m churning through albums such that they start to meld into one undifferentiated mass, and to listen and be responsive to my brain when it’s telling me it wants to listen to some familiar 70s dad rock or modern pop for a minute or skip ahead and go down a 70s funk/disco rabbit hole. I’d definitely recommend doing it for yourself!