pboily
fingerlickinmathematickin
If only torture, persecution and death had never occured because of "the truth"...Micaelis Rex said:That's funny, I find torture, persecution, and death to be far worse than the truth.
If only torture, persecution and death had never occured because of "the truth"...Micaelis Rex said:That's funny, I find torture, persecution, and death to be far worse than the truth.
cgannon64 said:Can't you see that Original Sin is just a way of pointing out that everyone inherits the original sin in that each one of us has an inevitable disposition towards sinfulness?
Micaelis Rex said:Well, let me assure you, you have sinned at some point in your life. What Adam did caused a "sinful nature" to take over mankind, and that sinful nature passed from generation to generation. That nature in essence causes man to sin, and the only thing that stops man from sinning is God.
Micaelis Rex said:That's funny, I find torture, persecution, and death to be far worse than the truth.
Wait... Isn't God all powerful? Why not just make us good again? Why go through all the pain a suffering because we (not even us, Adam and Eve) screwed up once?cgannon64 said:Don't you know the Genesis story? God made us good, we screwed it up, now we have a dispositions to do bad...
cgannon64 said:Predisposed has nothing to do with what you do the majority of the time, just what you do in general.
shortguy said:Well, if that disposition to sin wasn't there before the original sin, the can we pawn our sin off on Adam and Eve?
One question has always bothered me. Christians seem to take it as a given that the punishment for sin must be Hell. While that is the case Biblically, I see no logical reason that God must necessarily punish sinners with Hell. Why couldn't he give sinners a temporary, reforming punishment? Why does he necessarily have to punish at all?
Wait... Isn't God all powerful? Why not just make us good again? Why go through all the pain a suffering because we (not even us, Adam and Eve) screwed up once?
ironduck said:Yes, and like I said, in general I do good, not bad. In other words, I'm NOT predisposed to do bad.
I don't really see how that works. Adam and Eve had free will, did they not? Before the apple they had free will and no disposition towards sin. Why can't God just make us like Adam and Eve were before the apple?cgannon64 said:If God "made us good again", that would mean eliminating our free will - do you want that? (And, no, the omniscience of God doesn't necessarily negate free will...)
Xeven the God said:I don't really see how that works. Adam and Eve had free will, did they not? Before the apple they had free will and no disposition towards sin. Why can't God just make us like Adam and Eve were before the apple?
Then how did he create Adam and Eve with free will? Why didn't he make it so I was born with a non-sinful nature?cgannon64 said:Because, for God to turn you, an impefect being, into a perfect one, he would have to destroy your free will. If he changed your nature, he would be overriding the free will that made your nature.
cgannon64 said:Because, for God to turn you, an impefect being, into a perfect one, he would have to destroy your free will. If he changed your nature, he would be overriding the free will that made your nature.
cgannon64 said:Because, for God to turn you, an impefect being, into a perfect one, he would have to destroy your free will. If he changed your nature, he would be overriding the free will that made your nature.
cgannon64 said:You can be predisposed to good and bad. I'm merely saying that, no matter how much good you commit, you were clearly predisposed to bad as well.
FredLC said:Than God, as a perfect being, lack free will, since the two things are mutually excluded, huh?
Regards .
Genetics was unknown when christianity developed its dogma and cosmology. It has had a hard time adapting to modern science. I've been told on CFC that free will only involves moral decisons and god gave humans reason so that they could override any baser instincts that might lead us astray.Hotpoint said:Well I really hate making the same unaddressed point three times in a single thread but how does the concept of our accountability through Free-Will cope with Genetic Factors beyond the individuals control?
Birdjaguar said:Genetics was unknown when christianity developed its dogma and cosmology. It has had a hard time adapting to modern science. I've been told on CFC that free will only involves moral decisons and god gave humans reason so that they could override any baser instincts that might lead us astray.