Why is Mongolia in and not Korea

Status
Not open for further replies.
haha true. It's hard to see Mongolia as a "civilization" when they weren't civilized at all. If anyone deserves the title of "barbarian" it's the mongol hordes.


The Mongols are often credited with the first massive scale meritocracy, (rank based on skill/merit) as opposed to old aristocracy and other hereditary systems.

Also check out this under headings like Yassa law code, freedom of religion, Pax Mongolica being good for trade, etc. Sounds relatively civilized to me.
 
The Mongols are often credited with the first massive scale meritocracy, (rank based on skill/merit) as opposed to old aristocracy and other hereditary systems.

Also check out this under headings like Yassa law code, freedom of religion, Pax Mongolica being good for trade, etc. Sounds relatively civilized to me.

Good article. Thanks for that. :)

In a lot of ways, the Mongols were quite ahead of their times. They were the first people to promote globalization and they bridged the gap from West to East.

Here's another good summary of Mongol achievements on .pdf which I think is very informative:

http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/mongols/main/transcript.pdf

The Mongols also built the Forbidden Palace which is one of the Wonders of the World in the game. Pretty good for mere "barbarians".

A few excerpts from the .pdf:
The Mongol Khans also funded advances in medicine and astronomy throughout their domains. And their construction projects – extension of the Grand Canal in the direction of Beijing, the building of a capital city in Daidu (present-day Beijing) and of summer palaces in Shangdu (“Xanadu”) and Takht-i-Sulaiman, and the construction of a sizable network of roads and postal stations throughout their lands – promoted developments in science and engineering [also see The Mongols in China: Civilian Life under Mongol Rule, below].

The Status of Merchants Improved under Mongol Rule
Under Mongol rule, merchants had a higher status than they had in traditional China. During their travels they could rest and secure supplies through a postal-station system that the Mongols had established.
The postal-station system was, of course, originally devised to facilitate the transmission of official mail from one part of the empire to another. Set up approximately every 20 miles along the major trade routes and stocked with supplies of food, horses, and lodging, the stations were an incredible boon to all travelers, whether they were traveling for business or otherwise.
Under the Mongols, merchants also had the benefit of not being faced with confiscatory taxation, as was the case during the rule of the traditional Chinese dynasties.

Written Language. The Mongols were great cultural patrons. They conceived, for example, the idea of a new written language that could be used to transcribe a number of the languages within the Mongol domains. Khubilai Khan commissioned the Tibetan ‘Phags-pa Lama to develop the new script, which came to be known as “the Square Script” or the ‘Phags-pa script. Completed around 1269, the Square Script was a remarkable effort to devise a new written language. The Mongol rulers, however, did not foresee how difficult it would be to impose a written language on the population from the top down. Though they passed numerous edicts, regulations, and laws to persuade the public to use the new script, it never gained much popularity and was limited mainly to official uses – on paper money, official seals, a few porcelains, and the passports that were given by the Mongol rulers.

Interestingly enough, the script that the Mongols commissioned was very likely the one that the Korean people drew their inspiration from when they made their own written script Hangul.

You can look at the script here on omniglot.com:

http://www.omniglot.com/writing/phagspa.htm

Theater. The Mongol rulers were ardent patrons of the theater, and the Yuan Dynasty witnessed a golden age of Chinese theater. The theater at this time was full of spectacles, including acrobats, mimes, and colorful costumes – all of which appealed greatly to the Mongols. The Mongol court set up a special theater within the palace compound in Daidu (Beijing) and supported a number of playwrights.

Finally, the historical impact of the Mongols was immense. They literally ushered in a new age.

The Mongols also expedited and encouraged travel in the sizable section of Asia that was under their rule, permitting European merchants, craftsmen, and envoys to journey as far as China for the first time. Asian goods reached Europe along the caravan trails (earlier known as the “Silk Roads”), and the ensuing European demand for these products eventually inspired the search for a sea route to Asia. Thus, it could be said that the Mongol invasions indirectly led to Europe’s “Age of Exploration” in the 15th century.

From the Mongol period on, then, we can speak about a Eurasian – if not a global – history, in which developments in one part of Europe would have an impact not only in Europe but also in Asia, with the same being true for Asia. And if we remember that Christopher Columbus was actually looking for a new route to Asia when he landed in America – and that one of the few books he had with him was Marco Polo’s account of his travels in Asia – we could even say that global history begins with the Mongols and the bridge they built between the East and the West.
 
I think I will partake in some of the sweet Corean tears in this thread.:rolleyes:
The funny thing is though, considering Korea's long history as an isolated tributary state fought over by its neighbors, it's current implementation as a city state couldn't be more appropriate in gameplay terms.:lol:
As for the Mongols people under-appreciate how rich in every sense Central Asia was in the 13th Century. The oasis cities along the Silk Road in modern Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan were literally the largest in the world. Uniting all these Silk-Road states under one Umbrella brought the biggest flow of goods, ideas (and germs) yet seen across the continent.
But the real legacy of the Mongols is in somehow managing to create the first and last Pan-Asian world order (with a capital in Beijing -- Yes, the Mongols built Beijing; the Chinese just don't want you to know). The Soviets and Japanese tried at similar goals in modern times with all the weapons and transport of industrial civilization, but got nowhere near as far. When you consider that all this sprang up in less than a century from nomadic desert people living in tents, and especially in an empire-building game like Civ, the real question is why on Earth weren't the Mongols included on release?
 
The Mongols are often credited with the first massive scale meritocracy, (rank based on skill/merit) as opposed to old aristocracy and other hereditary systems.

Also check out this under headings like Yassa law code, freedom of religion, Pax Mongolica being good for trade, etc. Sounds relatively civilized to me.
I love when people don't read the things they cite.

"Although the word "peace" might not be the best word to describe the Mongol administration and governance during the brief era,... 'they make a desolation, and call it peace.' "
the peace of the sword!

"In the face of the ethnic, religious and tribal diversity of the civilians and soldiers of the Mongol Empire, which eventually included modern day Persians, Chinese and many Turkic peoples, Genghis Khan insisted on focusing all loyalty on himself as Great Khan and no others. Thus, Genghis Khan had no room for the traditional clan- and kindred-based divisions that were common in central Asian society. Obedience was expected from everyone from the lowest to the highest classes. Any disobedience by a subordinate officer to any order from a superior officer was reason for death."
You can worship any god you want, but anyone who disobeys is executed

"Genghis Khan had a Mongol code of law called the Yassa written down, which was intended to be the legal code throughout his empire. It covered in detail many aspects of nomadic life and the concerns of nomadic people. Stealing livestock was harshly punished, as was urinating or otherwise spoiling a source of fresh water; spying, treason, desertion, theft, and adultery, and persistent bankruptcy in the case of merchants were all punishable by execution.[3] Religious freedom was allowed, as long as one complied with the Yassa."
A code for ranchers that punishes bankruptcy with death... not exactly a breakthrough for human rights.

"Meritocracy

Genghis Khan preferred to rule through existing hierarchies, but where he was resisted he destroyed the existing aristocracy, although among the Mongols he created a rough meritocracy during that time. Positions of honour were given on the basis of bravery in battle or outstanding loyalty, as opposed to the old system of inheritance through families. This was far ahead of any other system in Europe at the time."

Strength through battle! Meanwhile China was administering civil service exams.

"Trade

Having conquered a vast land, Genghis Khan and his successors encouraged trade and exchange.[4] Mongols valued goods that came from other lands and peoples because they themselves produced very little of value."
They produced nothing themselves, and just took it from others... OK.

To summarize, they slaughtered everyone in between China and Europe, and then made the Chinese and Europeans trade with each other so they could reap the rewards.

Thormodr- all the stuff you're talking about was done by Yuan dynasty rulers who were basically Chinese. Claiming it as a Mongolian accomplishment is like claiming that the Roman gods were a Roman invention.
 
Gross exaggeration. North Korea. South Korea. Nukes. Kim Jong Il. US involvement. Samsung. Turtle Ship, Hwacha. Yi Sun-shin. Kimchi. Buddhism. Bulguksa.

And that's just skimming the top of the pinnacle.

In fact most people who know about Genghis Khan know surprisingly little about Mongolia. :)

North Korea. starving
South Korea. trying to get rich
Nukes. did they invent them?
Kim Jong Il. dead? ghost? 3 persons?
US involvement. why not play US then?
Samsung. sony, philips, toshiba, kenwood, siemens, msi, etc.
Turtle Ship, dragonboat
Hwacha. Civ4
Yi Sun-shin. never heard of
Kimchi. starbuck's
Buddhism. Zen
Bulguksa. I beg your pardon?
 
But the real legacy of the Mongols is in somehow managing to create the first and last Pan-Asian world order (with a capital in Beijing -- Yes, the Mongols built Beijing; the Chinese just don't want you to know).

I think you're quite biased as to the point of view of Beijing.
Check out these information quoted from wiki.
Quote:
Early history

The earliest remnants of human habitation in the Beijing municipality are found in the caves of Dragon Bone Hill near the village of Zhoukoudian in Fangshan District, where the Peking Man lived. Homo erectus fossils from the caves date to 230,000 to 250,000 years ago. Paleolithic homo sapiens also lived there about 27,000 years ago.[17] There were cities in the vicinities of Beijing by the 1st millennium BC, and the capital of the State of Yan, one of the powers of the Warring States Period (473-221 BC), Ji (薊/蓟), was established in present-day Beijing.[18]

After the fall of the Yan, the subsequent Qin, Han, and Jin dynasties set up local prefectures in the area.[1] During the fall of the Han, it was the seat of the warlord Gongsun Zan. In Tang Dynasty it became the headquarters for Fanyang jiedushi, the virtual military governor of current northern Hebei area. The An Shi Rebellion was also launched from here in AD 755.

Medieval period

In 936, the Later Jin Dynasty (936-947) of northern China ceded a large part of its northern frontier, including modern Beijing, to the Khitan Liao Dynasty. In 938, the Liao Dynasty set up a secondary capital in what is now Beijing, and called it Nanjing (the "Southern Capital"). In 1125, the Jurchen Jin Dynasty conquered Liao, and in 1153 moved its capital to Liao's Nanjing, calling it Zhongdu (中都), the "central capital."[1] Zhongdu was situated in what is now the area centered around Tianningsi, slightly to the southwest of central Beijing. Some of the oldest existing relics in Beijing, such as the Tianning Temple, date to the Liao.

Mongol forces burned Zhongdu to the ground in 1215 in what is now known as the Battle of Beijing.[19] Later in 1264, in preparation for the conquest of all of China to establish the Yuan Dynasty, Kublai Khan decided to rebuild it slightly north to the center of the Jin capital,[20] and in 1272, he made this city his capital as Dadu (大都, Chinese for "great capital"),[19] or Daidu to the Mongols, otherwise spelled as Cambaluc or Cambuluc in Marco Polo's accounts. Construction of Dadu finished in 1293.[1] The decision of Kublai Khan greatly enhanced the status of a city that had been situated on the northern fringe of China proper. The center of Dadu was situated slightly north of modern central Beijing.
 
I love when people don't read the things they cite.

"Although the word "peace" might not be the best word to describe the Mongol administration and governance during the brief era,... 'they make a desolation, and call it peace.' "
the peace of the sword!

"In the face of the ethnic, religious and tribal diversity of the civilians and soldiers of the Mongol Empire, which eventually included modern day Persians, Chinese and many Turkic peoples, Genghis Khan insisted on focusing all loyalty on himself as Great Khan and no others. Thus, Genghis Khan had no room for the traditional clan- and kindred-based divisions that were common in central Asian society. Obedience was expected from everyone from the lowest to the highest classes. Any disobedience by a subordinate officer to any order from a superior officer was reason for death."
You can worship any god you want, but anyone who disobeys is executed

"Genghis Khan had a Mongol code of law called the Yassa written down, which was intended to be the legal code throughout his empire. It covered in detail many aspects of nomadic life and the concerns of nomadic people. Stealing livestock was harshly punished, as was urinating or otherwise spoiling a source of fresh water; spying, treason, desertion, theft, and adultery, and persistent bankruptcy in the case of merchants were all punishable by execution.[3] Religious freedom was allowed, as long as one complied with the Yassa."
A code for ranchers that punishes bankruptcy with death... not exactly a breakthrough for human rights.

"Meritocracy

Genghis Khan preferred to rule through existing hierarchies, but where he was resisted he destroyed the existing aristocracy, although among the Mongols he created a rough meritocracy during that time. Positions of honour were given on the basis of bravery in battle or outstanding loyalty, as opposed to the old system of inheritance through families. This was far ahead of any other system in Europe at the time."

Strength through battle! Meanwhile China was administering civil service exams.

"Trade

Having conquered a vast land, Genghis Khan and his successors encouraged trade and exchange.[4] Mongols valued goods that came from other lands and peoples because they themselves produced very little of value."
They produced nothing themselves, and just took it from others... OK.

To summarize, they slaughtered everyone in between China and Europe, and then made the Chinese and Europeans trade with each other so they could reap the rewards.

The Mongols were no more brutal than the Romans were and yet no one thinks of them as mere Barbarians. :rolleyes:

The Mongols were pretty well average for the age they lived in. Just look at accounts of the Crusades for example. Quite a few of the accounts of the Mongols were written by foreigners and they tended to greatly exaggerate things. Like greatly exaggerating death totals when cities where conquered.

From the .pdf in my previous post:

The Barbarian Stereotype
Most Westerners accept the stereotype of the 13th-century Mongols as barbaric plunderers intent merely to maim, slaughter, and destroy. This perception, based on Persian, Chinese, Russian, and other accounts of the speed and ruthlessness with which the Mongols carved out the largest contiguous land empire in world history, has shaped both Asian and Western images of the Mongols and of their earliest leader, Chinggis Khan.
Such a view has diverted attention from the considerable contributions the Mongols made to 13th- and 14th-century civilization. Though the brutality of the Mongols’ military campaigns ought not to be downplayed or ignored, neither should their influence on Eurasian culture be overlooked.
 
North Korea. starving
South Korea. trying to get rich
Nukes. did they invent them?
Kim Jong Il. dead? ghost? 3 persons?
US involvement. why not play US then?
Samsung. sony, philips, toshiba, kenwood, siemens, msi, etc.
Turtle Ship, dragonboat
Hwacha. Civ4
Yi Sun-shin. never heard of
Kimchi. starbuck's
Buddhism. Zen
Bulguksa. I beg your pardon?

I'm afraid I have no idea what you're trying to say.
Is this a troll?:)
 
North Korea. starving
South Korea. trying to get rich
Nukes. did they invent them?
Kim Jong Il. dead? ghost? 3 persons?
US involvement. why not play US then?
Samsung. sony, philips, toshiba, kenwood, siemens, msi, etc.
Turtle Ship, dragonboat
Hwacha. Civ4
Yi Sun-shin. never heard of
Kimchi. starbuck's
Buddhism. Zen
Bulguksa. I beg your pardon?

I'm going to have fun with this.

North Korea starving? So was the US several times. Great Depression and now, Great Recession. Doesn't mean they get crossed off the countries in Civ list. The mention of North Korea was to point out that it can only be false, your little statement that "people don't know anything about korea"

Nukes were not invented by Korea, but does that matter? These days all people care about is who HAS nukes.

Kim Jong Il was the North Korean dictator whom people like to make fun of. And you seem to have heard of him, given your little questions afterward. :)

US involvement. Pay or play them? Typo? Korea did pay the US in a way--they have trade rights in Korea and outlets for their commercial branches: Dunkin' Donuts, among them, lol.

Samsung. Sure. But Samsung is a big dog too. That there are other big dogs doesn't mean we should ignore this big dog of business.

Turtle Boat. What the heck is a dragonboat? Do you mean a Viking longship? Lol.

Hwacha. Civ 4. Yes, they were included for a reason. Even you must see that.

Yi Sun-shin. Never heard of? Well Japanese admiral Togo Heihachiro of the Imperial Japanese Navy knew him:
You may compare me with Lord Nelson, but not with Yi Sun-sin. Next to him, I am only a petty officer.

Most naval historians who write books on world naval history have heard of Admiral Yi Sunshin, and include him in their books. British historians are among them:

"It is always difficult for Englishmen to admit that Nelson ever had an equal in his profession, but if any man is entitled to be so regarded, it should be this great naval commander of Asiatic race who never knew defeat and died in the presence of the enemy; of whose movements a track-chart might be compiled from the wrecks of hundreds of Japanese ships lying with their valiant crews at the bottom of the sea, off the coasts of the Korean peninsula... and it seems, in truth, no exaggeration to assert that from first to last he never made a mistake, for his work was so complete under each variety of circumstances as to defy criticism... His whole career might be summarized by saying that, although he had no lessons from past history to serve as a guide, he waged war on the sea as it should be waged if it is to produce definite results, and ended by making the supreme sacrifice of a defender of his country."
This excerpt is from George Alexander Ballard's "The Influence of the Sea on The Political History of Japan" (1921) pp. 66–67.

Several Civfanatics know of the Turtle Ship, whether it be from Age of Empires II, actually reading naval histories, or because they've visited Korean museums and know how much Koreans crow about them. The Turtle Ship, while not invented by Admiral Yi, was used as a weapon in the Imjin Wars and wrecked numerous Japanese ships with its high speed and multiple broadside cannons. it's also reputed to be the first ironclad in history.

Kimchi, you say Starbucks. I say kimchi is cultural, I also say that Starbucks is no more cultural than McDonald's or Dunkin Donuts or any commercialized "global" fast food chain is.

Buddhism. Zen. You do realize Zen Buddhism partly came about because of Koreans spreading Buddhism to Japan right?

Bulguksa is a UNESCO World Heritage site, along with the Seokguram Grotto. That you haven't heard from them makes it no less important for Buddhists in Korea and worldwide. When I visited last year, at the foot of the mountain, I saw many tablets with inscriptions from people all over the world: Australia and Finland among them.

I have pointed out that your ignorance of Korea doesn't mean that "nobody has heard of Korea." On the contrary, many people have, even if only in connection with kimchi, the World Cup (concerning the "Be the Reds" slogan on my T-shirt I was wearing: one Canadian I met hilariously asked if that meant I was Communist), Samsung, North Korea, and the Turtle Ship.
 
I'm going to have fun with this.

North Korea starving? So was the US several times. Great Depression and now, Great Recession. Doesn't mean they get crossed off the countries in Civ list. The mention of North Korea was to point out that it can only be false, your little statement that "people don't know anything about korea"

Nukes were not invented by Korea, but does that matter? These days all people care about is who HAS nukes.

Kim Jong Il was the North Korean dictator whom people like to make fun of. And you seem to have heard of him, given your little questions afterward. :)

US involvement. Pay or play them? Typo? Korea did pay the US in a way--they have trade rights in Korea and outlets for their commercial branches: Dunkin' Donuts, among them, lol.

Samsung. Sure. But Samsung is a big dog too. That there are other big dogs doesn't mean we should ignore this big dog of business.

Turtle Boat. What the heck is a dragonboat? Do you mean a Viking longship? Lol.

Hwacha. Civ 4. Yes, they were included for a reason. Even you must see that.

Yi Sun-shin. Never heard of? Well Japanese admiral Togo Heihachiro of the Imperial Japanese Navy knew him:

Most naval historians who write books on world naval history have heard of Admiral Yi Sunshin, and include him in their books. British historians are among them:

This excerpt is from George Alexander Ballard's "The Influence of the Sea on The Political History of Japan" (1921) pp. 66–67.

Several Civfanatics know of the Turtle Ship, whether it be from Age of Empires II, actually reading naval histories, or because they've visited Korean museums and know how much Koreans crow about them. The Turtle Ship, while not invented by Admiral Yi, was used as a weapon in the Imjin Wars and wrecked numerous Japanese ships with its high speed and multiple broadside cannons. it's also reputed to be the first ironclad in history.

Kimchi, you say Starbucks. I say kimchi is cultural, I also say that Starbucks is no more cultural than McDonald's or Dunkin Donuts or any commercialized "global" fast food chain is.

Buddhism. Zen. You do realize Zen Buddhism partly came about because of Koreans spreading Buddhism to Japan right?

Bulguksa is a UNESCO World Heritage site, along with the Seokguram Grotto. That you haven't heard from them makes it no less important for Buddhists in Korea and worldwide. When I visited last year, at the foot of the mountain, I saw many tablets with inscriptions from people all over the world: Australia and Finland among them.

I have pointed out that your ignorance of Korea doesn't mean that "nobody has heard of Korea." On the contrary, many people have, even if only in connection with kimchi, the World Cup (concerning the "Be the Reds" slogan on my T-shirt I was wearing: one Canadian I met hilariously asked if that meant I was Communist), Samsung, North Korea, and the Turtle Ship.

Some comments:

North Korean starvation was basically self induced. While his people were starving to death, Kim Jong Il was spending $800 million on a huge tomb for his father. :rolleyes:

There is no proof that North Korea has nukes at all actually.

Kim Jong Il is more infamous than famous. Maintaining a system of concentration camps where hundreds of thousands of Koreans are kept to due slave labour until they grow too weak and die is utterly despicable. Why so many South Koreans seem to think he's a good leader is beyond me.

South Korea owes an incredible debt to the USA for saving their country from Communism and then giving them huge sums of aid over the years. For a while in the 1960s, upwards of 1/4 of their GDP was from aid money from the USA.

Samsung is huge in South Korea it's true. It's also amusing to see that 70% of Europeans when polled, thought that Samsung was a Japanese company. Samsung has not actively tried to dispel this notion either because they know that Japanese brands have a much higher reputation for quality. (Much higher brand index per nation.)

Yi Soon Shin was the admiral that was hated in his own country and eventually died in ignominy. His image has been elevated recently though.

The Turtle ship was not the first armoured ship in the world. The Chinese and Japanese had ships similar in design around that time. It's still impressive but hardly a unique invention.

Kim Chi is not that bad. It is definitely an acquired taste though as many foreigners can't stand the smell. I don't like the amount of sodium used though for most brands of Kim Chi. It certainly is the most famous Korean food though.

Buddhism was spread to Japan in part through Korea from China and also directly from China itself. Being the middleman for something isn't that noteworthy.

Finally, I will admit that Bulguksa is pretty impressive. Not as well known to foreigners as structures in other countries but well worth seeing if you are in South Korea.
 
no

america is as important as korea in the game

What a joke:lol:
America is the biggest culture pool in the world. In the now days, even the world most "unique" China has to admit that how spreaded the multifarious America cultures influence.
Besides culture, Techs, Scientists, Movies, Actors, inventions¡:)¡:)which one can be compared by the absurd Korea ?
 
Thormodr, you raise some interesting points. It seems you've taught in Korea at some point. Some responses:

Kim Jong Il is more infamous than famous. Maintaining a system of concentration camps where hundreds of thousands of Koreans are kept to due slave labour until they grow too weak and die is utterly despicable. Why so many South Koreans seem to think he's a good leader is beyond me.
Yes, Kim Jong Il was more infamous than famous--people do certainly know of him though! And that's why he was on my list. I personally think he was a horrible, brutal leader. But, he is well known. More of my friends from my American collegiate days know of him than they know of Roh Moo yung (the S. Korean president who committed suicide yet was hated during his presidency). That said, I suppose the current UN Secretary General was someone I forgot to mention on my list, hehe.

There is no proof that North Korea has nukes at all actually.
True, but most suspect they do. There is reasonable, if scant, evidence to the effect that they are working on developing them. For one thing, they do have nuclear reactors, and have constantly been talking about weaponization.

South Korea owes an incredible debt to the USA for saving their country from Communism and then giving them huge sums of aid over the years. For a while in the 1960s, upwards of 1/4 of their GDP was from aid money from the USA.
It's true Korea owes a lot to the U.S. I think the reasons why many Koreans resent the U.S. though, include:
a) Some Americans/Western historians love pointing out the U.S. aid, without really recognizing that recent innovations were entirely Korea's own. U.S. (and to some extent, even Japanese) infrastructure helped with the initial push, but Koreans were responsible for actual continued growth. I think some Koreans are miffed that people mention U.S. aid more than recent Korean achievements, and they'd rather have it the other way. Both approaches are wrong, of course.

b) American soldiers killed South Korean civilians during the Korean War. Several of the most infamous incidents of this remain in memory, but the incidents in total found so far number over 100: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/10/world/asia/10comission.html

c) Koreans dislike big powers (and some Koreans are very xenophobic for this reason). This was true historically because Koreans kept getting invaded by China and Japan, and usually won by the skin of their teeth, thus preferring to be vassals to China than deal with more invasions. When they were conquered, they always rose up and ousted them eventually, even the Mongols, even the Manchus.

Yi Soon Shin was the admiral that was hated in his own country and eventually died in ignominy. His image has been elevated recently though.
Um....I really have to disagree about this. In his own day and age, the countryside peasants watched Yi Sunshin dragged to the capital to answer for treason, and they protested that he be released. Chen Lin, a Chinese admiral, openly admired Yi Sunshin, and his fellow Korean commanders (even rebellious Won Gyun, for a time) followed his orders. He was the Korean El Cid, and thus when he died, he too, to sustain the morale of Korean soldiers in the final battle of Noryang Point, asked that his death be concealed until the battle was over. He died, basically, at the height of his glory. Dunno where you're getting the ignominy aura from. Yi Sunshin was only unpopular among some factions of the Korean court, which was full of intrigue and backstabbing (and to some extent the Korean government remains that way to this day, unfortunately).

The Turtle ship was not the first armoured ship in the world. The Chinese and Japanese had ships similar in design around that time. It's still impressive but hardly a unique invention.
The Turtle Ship wasn't invented during Admiral Yi's time, if that's where you're getting this from. It was invented much earlier in the Choson Dynasty, and that's where most people get the "it was the first armored ship in world history" bit from. That said, Yi Sunshin is so often tied to the Turtle Ship that people assume he invented it (some South Koreans I met recently thought so, and I corrected them. They didn't believe me, lol).

Kim Chi is not that bad. It is definitely an acquired taste though as many foreigners can't stand the smell. I don't like the amount of sodium used though for most brands of Kim Chi. It certainly is the most famous Korean food though.
Agreed. I don't eat kimchi often myself. Quite a few of my friends, including one from Pakistan, eat it as often as they can and praise its spicy taste. I do like kimchi when it's been cooked though. Can't stand the regular fermented taste. Personal preference though. Nearly all my Korean family members love it to bits.

Buddhism was spread to Japan in part through Korea from China and also directly from China itself. Being the middleman for something isn't that noteworthy.
Yes, but Korea was a major proponent of Buddhism, and its trade with Japan stirred its rise there quite a bit. The first metal type in the world (invented by Koreans) was expressly used to type out Buddhist texts (Tripitaka Koreana). Furthermore, several of Korea's most famous wonders, Hwangnyongsa Pagoda, Bulguksa, Seokugram among them, were centers of Buddhism. They were the Korean equivalent of Christian cathedrals. The Seon Buddhist movement during the Silla period I believe, bears strong similarity in its beliefs and textual emphasis to Zen Buddhist texts. Also, there is proof that Silla had relations with Yamato Japan, and I believe this is around the period where the earliest Japanese texts about Buddhism date to (early ADs). If I were Buddhist I'd probably know more about this than I do. XD

Being the middle man isn't impressive per se, but it does grant you a certain influence and power. During the Ancient Choson days, the Ancient Choson kingdom was able to gain much trade from southern Korea and Japan, blocking the Han Chinese. This is one speculated reason as to why the Han Chinese eventually invaded and toppled the Ancient Choson (until the Korean kingdom of Goguryeo later ousted them and took over huge swathes of land in Manchuria).

Finally, I will admit that Bulguksa is pretty impressive. Not as well known to foreigners as structures in other countries but well worth seeing if you are in South Korea.
My uncle and aunt had their honeymoon there. The blossoms were very impressive in those photos! :)
 
Korea:

unique ability: Gunpowder units deal triple damage to japanese units.
unique unit: Kimchi Master - special worker unit provides +1 food on any tile the worker is standing on.
 
I am quite curious about modern Korean religious beliefs.
Morningcalm have you any idea how religion is treated in Korea(or maybe South Korea to be acturate). Which religion do Koreans follow? Buddhism Taoism Confucism or others?
 
Koreans, especially the OP, lets not create threads like this.

I, also Korean, very much understand your hope for Korea being an independant Civ. However, actually taking a negative stance against other "Civilizations" to promote another is actually spitting in your face. (Many people will probably just wave this thread away, but it will do more harm than good)

Every nation, culture and Civilization have its own unique points. Although it might be possible to make an argument that one is better than another, that kind of stance is exactly what creates Hitler or Hirohito.

And one more thing. People out there defending North Korea, are you serious. What? North Korea is not starving? Loving your country and saying "pants on fire" political statements without facts is self inflicting damage.
 
I'm going to have fun with this.

North Korea starving? So was the US several times. Great Depression and now, Great Recession. Doesn't mean they get crossed off the countries in Civ list. The mention of North Korea was to point out that it can only be false, your little statement that "people don't know anything about korea"

Nukes were not invented by Korea, but does that matter? These days all people care about is who HAS nukes.

Kim Jong Il was the North Korean dictator whom people like to make fun of. And you seem to have heard of him, given your little questions afterward. :)

US involvement. Pay or play them? Typo? Korea did pay the US in a way--they have trade rights in Korea and outlets for their commercial branches: Dunkin' Donuts, among them, lol.

Samsung. Sure. But Samsung is a big dog too. That there are other big dogs doesn't mean we should ignore this big dog of business.

Turtle Boat. What the heck is a dragonboat? Do you mean a Viking longship? Lol.

Hwacha. Civ 4. Yes, they were included for a reason. Even you must see that.

Yi Sun-shin. Never heard of? Well Japanese admiral Togo Heihachiro of the Imperial Japanese Navy knew him:

Most naval historians who write books on world naval history have heard of Admiral Yi Sunshin, and include him in their books. British historians are among them:

This excerpt is from George Alexander Ballard's "The Influence of the Sea on The Political History of Japan" (1921) pp. 66–67.

Several Civfanatics know of the Turtle Ship, whether it be from Age of Empires II, actually reading naval histories, or because they've visited Korean museums and know how much Koreans crow about them. The Turtle Ship, while not invented by Admiral Yi, was used as a weapon in the Imjin Wars and wrecked numerous Japanese ships with its high speed and multiple broadside cannons. it's also reputed to be the first ironclad in history.

Kimchi, you say Starbucks. I say kimchi is cultural, I also say that Starbucks is no more cultural than McDonald's or Dunkin Donuts or any commercialized "global" fast food chain is.

Buddhism. Zen. You do realize Zen Buddhism partly came about because of Koreans spreading Buddhism to Japan right?

Bulguksa is a UNESCO World Heritage site, along with the Seokguram Grotto. That you haven't heard from them makes it no less important for Buddhists in Korea and worldwide. When I visited last year, at the foot of the mountain, I saw many tablets with inscriptions from people all over the world: Australia and Finland among them.

I have pointed out that your ignorance of Korea doesn't mean that "nobody has heard of Korea." On the contrary, many people have, even if only in connection with kimchi, the World Cup (concerning the "Be the Reds" slogan on my T-shirt I was wearing: one Canadian I met hilariously asked if that meant I was Communist), Samsung, North Korea, and the Turtle Ship.

Very entertaining read. Thanks for teaching me so much about Korean history. It's always entertaining to talk to patriotic people. Btw: Was patriotism invented by Koreans too?

===

What I did, btw. is give my first thought to your remarks. What you (successfully) did is pointing out that there are other birds than sparrow, crow and duck. Lots of birds. And I am sure the number of different species even surpasses the number of countries and/or civilizations that COULD be included in a video game.
 
Thormodr, you raise some interesting points. It seems you've taught in Korea at some point. Some responses:


Yes, Kim Jong Il was more infamous than famous--people do certainly know of him though! And that's why he was on my list. I personally think he was a horrible, brutal leader. But, he is well known. More of my friends from my American collegiate days know of him than they know of Roh Moo yung (the S. Korean president who committed suicide yet was hated during his presidency). That said, I suppose the current UN Secretary General was someone I forgot to mention on my list, hehe.


True, but most suspect they do. There is reasonable, if scant, evidence to the effect that they are working on developing them. For one thing, they do have nuclear reactors, and have constantly been talking about weaponization.


It's true Korea owes a lot to the U.S. I think the reasons why many Koreans resent the U.S. though, include:
a) Some Americans/Western historians love pointing out the U.S. aid, without really recognizing that recent innovations were entirely Korea's own. U.S. (and to some extent, even Japanese) infrastructure helped with the initial push, but Koreans were responsible for actual continued growth. I think some Koreans are miffed that people mention U.S. aid more than recent Korean achievements, and they'd rather have it the other way. Both approaches are wrong, of course.

b) American soldiers killed South Korean civilians during the Korean War. Several of the most infamous incidents of this remain in memory, but the incidents in total found so far number over 100: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/10/world/asia/10comission.html

c) Koreans dislike big powers (and some Koreans are very xenophobic for this reason). This was true historically because Koreans kept getting invaded by China and Japan, and usually won by the skin of their teeth, thus preferring to be vassals to China than deal with more invasions. When they were conquered, they always rose up and ousted them eventually, even the Mongols, even the Manchus.


Um....I really have to disagree about this. In his own day and age, the countryside peasants watched Yi Sunshin dragged to the capital to answer for treason, and they protested that he be released. Chen Lin, a Chinese admiral, openly admired Yi Sunshin, and his fellow Korean commanders (even rebellious Won Gyun, for a time) followed his orders. He was the Korean El Cid, and thus when he died, he too, to sustain the morale of Korean soldiers in the final battle of Noryang Point, asked that his death be concealed until the battle was over. He died, basically, at the height of his glory. Dunno where you're getting the ignominy aura from. Yi Sunshin was only unpopular among some factions of the Korean court, which was full of intrigue and backstabbing (and to some extent the Korean government remains that way to this day, unfortunately).


The Turtle Ship wasn't invented during Admiral Yi's time, if that's where you're getting this from. It was invented much earlier in the Choson Dynasty, and that's where most people get the "it was the first armored ship in world history" bit from. That said, Yi Sunshin is so often tied to the Turtle Ship that people assume he invented it (some South Koreans I met recently thought so, and I corrected them. They didn't believe me, lol).


Agreed. I don't eat kimchi often myself. Quite a few of my friends, including one from Pakistan, eat it as often as they can and praise its spicy taste. I do like kimchi when it's been cooked though. Can't stand the regular fermented taste. Personal preference though. Nearly all my Korean family members love it to bits.


Yes, but Korea was a major proponent of Buddhism, and its trade with Japan stirred its rise there quite a bit. The first metal type in the world (invented by Koreans) was expressly used to type out Buddhist texts (Tripitaka Koreana). Furthermore, several of Korea's most famous wonders, Hwangnyongsa Pagoda, Bulguksa, Seokugram among them, were centers of Buddhism. They were the Korean equivalent of Christian cathedrals. The Seon Buddhist movement during the Silla period I believe, bears strong similarity in its beliefs and textual emphasis to Zen Buddhist texts. Also, there is proof that Silla had relations with Yamato Japan, and I believe this is around the period where the earliest Japanese texts about Buddhism date to (early ADs). If I were Buddhist I'd probably know more about this than I do. XD

Being the middle man isn't impressive per se, but it does grant you a certain influence and power. During the Ancient Choson days, the Ancient Choson kingdom was able to gain much trade from southern Korea and Japan, blocking the Han Chinese. This is one speculated reason as to why the Han Chinese eventually invaded and toppled the Ancient Choson (until the Korean kingdom of Goguryeo later ousted them and took over huge swathes of land in Manchuria).


My uncle and aunt had their honeymoon there. The blossoms were very impressive in those photos! :)

Yes, I lived in South Korea for 6 years and am somewhat well versed in the language and history. Certainly not an expert by any means anyway.

Roh Moo Yung was an awful president. He bent over backwards for North Korea.

I never claimed that Yi Soon Shin invented the turtle ships. I merely was saying that the design for armoured ships was being used in China and Japan around that time. There is absolutely no evidence that Korea was first anyway.

As far as metal type goes I wouldn't exactly call it an invention. It was certainly an improvement on existing technology though. I dislike hearing some Koreans saying that Koreans invented the printing press as that is untrue.

As for Americans killing Korean civilians, many Korean civilians were also killed by Koreans. You might also want to look at the war atrocities committed by South Koreans in Vietnam.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom