A New Hope: A Star Wars Mafia Game (Game Thread)

Romanchine I think you're forgetting the point where you told me that Shadowbound was Tarkin, after he turned up innocent combined with my scan of john that said he was an innocent jedi faction scanner (:confused:) I stopped believing you.

I never told you shadowbound was Tarkin. If I said that, it's after you "scanned" shadowbound as mafia, and I believed you. You made up the piece of information that led me to believe shadowbound was Tarkin.
 
The thing important right now: please tell us that the pyro won his victory, and not Jabba. Exceptionally well played to Romanichine, possibly one of the hardest neutral roles and he survived the whole time.

Don't do that again please, you confirmed TLO's not being able to speak to anyone. Which was false, which in turn gave him credibility.
Oh, also, I see it was already discussed - if there's one thing that could have been better from the GMs/some concerns, I feel it's that they replaced TLO rather than replacing others first, or WoGing him. In fact, I specifically PM'd about why they lied on the Innocent QT/made it seem like TLO's lie was somehow truthful. Not that it couldn't have been easier to see through TLO's situation, you all could have followed up better, but I agree confusing situations and a player getting replaced probably helped hell hound a lot.

But still, a great game, and very fitting Star Wars feel all the way through, so great work Zack and choxorn.

Oh, and for anyone wondering to ask anything about me - well besides from getting Innocents together early I died rather fast and I've been spectating a while, but feel free to go ahead. The bounty was placed on myself from credits from me and Renata - turned out to have made some bad assumptions about how bounties worked, also thought the GMs would announce it publicly. And Darth Maul killing Renata, who had a protection ability, hurt that first night.

I think I also said I agree the Galactic Empire wasn't as powerful as the Sith, who if Grievous had lived/they had the ability to convert Anakin later could have been much more powerful than we even saw work out. But the baddies earned this win most at the end.
 
(I See) Dead People: http://www.quicktopic.com/44/H/EeHmQMbsgPhk

I saw more paranoia in the Jedi thread than I have anywhere else on the entire Internet. You guys should give yourself a medal!

Did you see both the quicktopics......?


Rather silly. In the dead qt I bash on Bad Player for being so demanding of us but gave jabba so much.

Also, I don't think the brotherhood was a term anyone else used except for me in a pm to badplayer joking around.

I scanned Bad Player and said "Oh brother, where art thou? wanna chill with the innocents?" and also gave a wikipedia link to the brothers Karamazov in a PM. But other than that, I dunno if my joking propaganda phase actually used the brotherhood....it might have, as I said before, in reference to Invisible Man that I had to recently read.


Secura--don't have too much hate on the "brotherhood." The core group was good for a while. Then I died and RRRaskolnikov disappeared into thin air. And Bad Player took over without...erm...reading our own quicktopic.
 
So bad player lived up to his name!
 
I wasn't allowed to... but I was dead by then, so I already knew hell_hound was Dooku. No point in giving out spoilers.
 
I wonder why no one thought of putting on any of te SW-related avatars.
trek_11.gif
trek_60.gif
trek_51.gif
trek_9.gif
trek_8.gif
 
*sigh* what a disappointing end. I like that Rom TRAPPED ME! I wish you had told me someone overbid me, I had 30 credits.

Oh well, I still got a personal victory for scanning c_h, and I give myself another personal victory for using the word TRAP in every one of my posts, except for my first one.
 
You Rebel scum! You don't get points for roleplaying.

And why didn't anyone recognise my quotes from Army of Darkness and the like?
 
So the game ended? Sign up for my game!
 
Quicktopics:

Sith
Empire
Bounty Hunters
Quicktopic that Earthling and Renata had for about 2 seconds
Innocents #1
Innocents #2
tailless set up this quicktopic and never sent anyone the link
Dead Guys

Okay, yes, the comment on TLO was a bit of a screw-up. Sorry about that, in retrospect I shouldn't have said that, or at least not worded it that way. I may have also made a mistake at the end- TFA gave Romanichine the entirety of his credits (38 in all) the night before he died. Roman, did TFA tell you about this? I sometimes didn't mention credits transfers to the recipients because I figured they'd already know anyway, and there wasn't anything new to say, and I never quoted one player's PM in a PM sent to another player if the other player didn't recieve the original message also. This might have had a bit of an impact if Roman didn't know about TFA's gift and I should have told him about it, and his comments make me think this happened and I didn't figure that out until it was too late to do anything about it. If I screwed up on this, and Roman would have voted classical if I told him about this, then I might have just cost the innocents the game through GM error. :cry:

On the other hand, the Sith between them on the final day had more money than that (39 credits between the 3 of them) and could have bought out his vote if they really wanted to, and TFA did it for the lulz, he never said he was trying to get Roman's vote. I honestly don't know what would have happened, or what should have been done here.

Because of TFA's gift, the final credits totals: Niklas: 78 Romanichine: 114, so Romanichine wins.

As to replacing TLO, we had several people in need of replacements, we actually got to him around the same time we got to Seon and Ras. We REALLY didn't want to replace or WoG a mafia, true, but since we were letting the Sith use each other's abilities when one or more of them wasn't around due to how much they were gone (classical and thomas disappeared at the beginning, john disappeared later and then TLO disappeared). We didn't WoG john when he was gone like Andres did on the org because we knew why we wasn't there, and his lack of night abilities meant his inactivity didn't matter anyway. TLO's would have, though, and after a while, his continued inactivity would have made him less suspicious then a new person replacing him if the Sith kept killing people.

Greivous and Vader could have indeed been powerful. A lot of powerful stuff was never used, like Double A's ability or Winston's ability. Other things were wasted, like CivGeneral's Activity Scans, or Remake's Self-Protection, or Bad Player's Protection ability. Just for how bad he was at protecting people alone accounts for a lot of why the innocents lost- letting Earthling die, letting landlubber die (though, in all fairness, protection didn't work on the Death Star anyway), protecting Niklas every night when he wasn't in any danger of being attacked, the list goes on and on. He was by no means the only innocent who made plenty of bad moves, but he certainly lived up to his name.

It's funny, really- around half-way through the game when the Empire started all dying out, the Sith weren't looking very good either, and the innocents were strong, Zack and I thought there was no way the innocents could lose at this point. Then you went through several days of really bad moves, and the Sith coasted on home.
 
Okay, yes, the comment on TLO was a bit of a screw-up. Sorry about that, in retrospect I shouldn't have said that, or at least not worded it that way. I may have also made a mistake at the end- TFA gave Romanichine the entirety of his credits (38 in all) the night before he died. Roman, did TFA tell you about this? I sometimes didn't mention credits transfers to the recipients because I figured they'd already know anyway, and there wasn't anything new to say, and I never quoted one player's PM in a PM sent to another player if the other player didn't recieve the original message also.

I never knew about TFA transferring me 38 credits, I've read about this for the 1st time tonight in the Dead QT. These transfer notices are one thing I wanted to mention after the game. It would have been nice to receive a confirmation every time, otherwise I had to trust the other party, like it happened on the last day: Palpatine requesting a 18 credits transfer but having only 12 to pay. Who would have thought that the Emperor had a bad credit :)

This might have had a bit of an impact if Roman didn't know about TFA's gift and I should have told him about it, and his comments make me think this happened and I didn't figure that out until it was too late to do anything about it. If I screwed up on this, and Roman would have voted classical if I told him about this, then I might have just cost the innocents the game through GM error. :cry:

Argh, that's a tough spot, but honestly I would never have voted Csargo if I knew about the 38 credits payment. I'm not ready to blame you Choxorn. Maybe TFA could have told me about this before he died.

On the other hand, the Sith between them on the final day had more money than that (39 credits between the 3 of them) and could have bought out his vote if they really wanted to, and TFA did it for the lulz, he never said he was trying to get Roman's vote. I honestly don't know what would have happened, or what should have been done here.

Because of TFA's gift, the final credits totals: Niklas: 78 Romanichine: 114, so Romanichine wins.

I'm not sure I deserve this win, if we remove the 38 credits from TFA, it would be Niklas 78 and me 76. I did nothing to receive TFA's credits, I would have if I had known but I didn't. In the end I was granted 38 credits for a vote that I never made. :(

TFA makes me win, and here I was ranting about how the Rebels never gave me money, and after reading the dead QT I realize that some of you were rooting for me to win. :(:(:( Sorry if I was harsh with you guys.
 
Back
Top Bottom