Asian Colonization (Pure Fantasy) Development thread

Heh, awesome idea. I tried doing this a while ago, but my modding skillz are... minimal.

Suggestions:
-Hasekura Tsunenaga as the colonist leader for Japan. In the 1630's he traveled to Rome via Mexico City. (King is Shougun Tokugawa Ieyasu, or just 'Shougun of Japan'. And yes, it is shougun - it's a long o.)
-The Asians deserve firearms. In fact, before sakoku (the isolationist policy), Japan had the best guns in the world.
-Most of the Asians (excluding the Indians) should probably have Buddhism instead of Confucianism. Buddhism was a lot more widespread, and works better like the Europeans' Christianity, so you can have Buddhist Temples instead of Churches. (And it's actually a religion at all.)
-If you want an Arabian or Muslim nation, go with the Ottomans.
-Most of the Asians (excluding any Arabs) get a plus to diplomacy with Native Americans, since they're not there to convert anybody. (Maybe give the hypothetical Europeans a minus whenever they build a mission.)
-Elephants as a resource for Indians and Southeast Asians
-I like the idea of Vijaynagara
-I think it'd be more interesting if you went with the actual names of the countries (like Ming (for the dynasty) or Zhōngguó instead of China, Nihon/Nippon instead of Japan, Hanguk instead of Korea), but it might get confusing.
-If you want, start it at 1421 or somewhere, even though Gavin Menzies is an idiot. (He cites Washington Irving as evidence that Columbus thought he was in China...)

Civ suggestions:
-Overall
--Peasants instead of Indentured Servants, but maybe keep 'Free Colonist'
-China (Ming, or whatever)
--Treasure Ship replaces Galleon
---1 extra move, 1 extra transport capacity (or just call the galleon 'treasure ship')
--Maybe the Zhuge Nu (Chu Ko Nu is a mistranscription) for the non-veteran colonial soldier, normal musketman for veteran.
--Chinese Noble is a good idea instead of Elder Statesman, maybe Confucianist Scholar
-Japan
--You've gotta have samurai, it's just hard to fit them. Maybe it's just an extra unit choice, in addition to Ashigaru Musketeer and some form of cavalry.
---Here's an idea - you have three military profession choices: musketman, melee infantry, and cavalry. The melee infantry choice creates Samurai from Veteran Soldiers, and Ashigaru Pikemen from regular colonists. You could even replace the 'Veteran Soldier' with 'Veteran Noble' or 'Noble Soldier' or something, or even have both.
-Korea
--Hwacha replaces Cannon
--Turtle Ship replaces Ship of the Line
-Mongols (if they're there)
--Bonus to Seasoned Scouts
--Bonus to Ranchers (or whatever you call them)
--Keshik replaces Dragoon or Dragoon equivalent
-Khmer or Vietnam or whatever's in Southeast Asia
--Jungle defense and movement bonuses

(I don't know much about Korea or anything south of China, so that's all I've got.)

I think it would be fun to have the option to play with Asians and Europeans together, if not as a main game feature. (Maybe add a bunch more Europeans too.)
 
The same could be said about Buddhism, in fact. And Confucianism was pretty prevalent among the elite classes in China, sort of like Mithraism was in the late Roman Empire. While Confucianism isn't an ideal choice, it serves the fuction best, IMO.

It was prevalent, but it was NOT a religion. If you want to see a puzzled face, try asking any Chinese about Confucianism as a religion. And the very fact it was prevalent among the ELITE only, makes it pretty tough to spread among simple folks such us the natives. If you want a religion to be spreadable, it must have a popular appeal, e.g. Taoism (which has all characteristics of a religion) .
 
-China (Ming, or whatever)
--Chinese Noble is a good idea instead of Elder Statesman, maybe Confucianist Scholar
What about Chinese Mandarin or Bureaucrat? China had no hereditary noble class in the Western meaning (except the imperial family), and most of the imperial posts were filled by mandarins. In more remote newly acquired areas, mandarins (serving as governors) were expected to use their own devices, independent from the capital, to maintain the imperial property and support the imperial army stationed there. Very good training for leaders of future independent nations deciding to split from the motherland...
 
It was prevalent, but it was NOT a religion. If you want to see a puzzled face, try asking any Chinese about Confucianism as a religion. And the very fact it was prevalent among the ELITE only, makes it pretty tough to spread among simple folks such us the natives. If you want a religion to be spreadable, it must have a popular appeal, e.g. Taoism (which has all characteristics of a religion) .

Well, Confusianism HAS spread beyond the elite classes of China, so I can't quite agree with that. Of course, it is not a faith (or philosophy) which advocates missionary work, but the Chinese colonists would want conformity within their colonies, so teaching the natives about Confusianism would make sense to a degree. Besides, there is no way to make this completely lifelike. And that's certainly not the point, either.
 
Well, Confusianism HAS spread beyond the elite classes of China, so I can't quite agree with that. Of course, it is not a faith (or philosophy) which advocates missionary work, but the Chinese colonists would want conformity within their colonies, so teaching the natives about Confusianism would make sense to a degree. Besides, there is no way to make this completely lifelike. And that's certainly not the point, either.
At least we agree it is not a faith. But it DEFINITELY IS a philosophical system, and if it spread beyond the educated elite, it did so to a very limited extent (like e.g. Darwinism, though Marxism was much more successful in this respect). How can you imagine teaching natives ethics from philosophical point of view, assuming their background in this is none? And doing this without any priests/monks (do you think scholars would go for this job?), worship practices, and references to supernatural beings and afterlife? And with any serious activity in the temple taking place once a year on an early September morning?
My point is that Confucianism is far too complex to be accepted by uneducated masses (eductaion does not guarantee this acceptance either), and at the same time, there are systems/religions in Chinese civilization that are ideally suited for this job.
 
What about Chinese Mandarin or Bureaucrat? China had no hereditary noble class in the Western meaning (except the imperial family), and most of the imperial posts were filled by mandarins. In more remote newly acquired areas, mandarins (serving as governors) were expected to use their own devices, independent from the capital, to maintain the imperial property and support the imperial army stationed there. Very good training for leaders of future independent nations deciding to split from the motherland...

That makes more sense, yes.

-About the Confucianism thing, like I said, use Buddhism, it fits better and it's more universal (like Japan, Korea, etc were all Buddhist).
 
For Europe, I know that New France would be 'Nouvelle France' and New Spain would be 'Nueva España'. (I know no more of any of the significant languages. And I never thought my suggestion would be followed... *is happy*)
Oh, I also know (well, I'm not sure that's the word they would use, but I have no reason to think it isn't) that in period-correct Japanese 'New Japan' would be 'Atarashiki Nippon'.

And who do we have for colonial leaders so far?
 
Then you could use Zen Buddhism in Japan (Nihon), China (Ming) , Korea (Hanguk) and the Indonesian civ who don't yet have a name. Use Zen as it is the best known word for a part of Buddhism called Chan in China, Seon in Korea and Thien in Vietnam.
Do you mean there should be four different (competitive) schools of Zen, or one with four different names?

Ok, updated empire list:
- Vijayanagar - Southern Indian nation
- Some Indonesian civ
- Ming - China
- Mughal - Northern Indian Nation
- Hanguk - Korea
- Nihon - Japan
I understand the Vijayanagara follow Hinduism, and the Mughal follow Islam. What about the Indonesians? Still Hindu or already Muslim?

By the way, what about the Wheel of Dharma as the logo of Buddhism?
 
I think we some more units like the mandarin

I'm not sure whether you need replacements for statesmen only or for other units as well. If this is the latter case, what about coolies replacing intendured servants? This may apply to both China (so, assumingly, Japan and Korea as well) and India. In fact, the word gained its notoriety because of the New World. Chinese coolies worked not only in the States but also the Hispanic part of America.
 
I find I prefer Malacca as the Indonesian nation. It has the most interesting history, and was quite successful. It should have some sort of improved, or maybe just cheaper, privateer unit as its UU, since the Malacca sultanate used them to great effect for centuries.
 
Just use Zen for all of them, this is the most known name for that part of the Buddhism...

I'd stay with Buddhism. Pure Land (Amitabha) was (and still is) equally strong in China, and both belong to Mahayana anyway. This is an Asian mod, so let's give credit to a broader spectrum of Asian civilization, whenever possible...
 
no those citizen units i mean

As far as the civilizan units are concerned, we might consider a rice farmer. This would be a unit specialized in farming food on marshes. In the early years of South Carolina, fortunes were made on rice, which turned out to grow perfectly on areas that would otherwise be treated as useless, i.e. marshes. This was also a reason for importing more slave manpower - the Africans were much more immune to malaria (since most of them had sickle-cell disease). The Asian nations represented in this mode are mostly rice nations, and most of them are used to working in conditions unacceptable to Europeans (because of high temperatures and humidity). Therefore it would be quite natural for the Asian settlements to flourish in areas resembling their own environment - sub-tropical and tropical (I know this doesn't work with Korea and Japan, but, precisely because of this, they might choose locations different from their southern rivals). I'd suggest the unit, rice farmer working on a marsh square, have a comparable output to the generic farmer unit working on a grassland/plain square. ALSO, I'd suggest introducing rice as a new bonus/resource (with marshes as its natural environment).
 
Back
Top Bottom