Ask a Russian

Status
Not open for further replies.
I finished the first episode and think part of the second but it was pretty boring. Does it pick up?
Hard to tell. All episodes are very different, may be 1/3 of them are good and the rest are ok to watch once.
The last one about Siberia is pretty good, WW2 soldiers and equipment look impressively authentic. Not free from usual Western ideological stuff, but nevertheless worth watching IMO.
 
I just realized I mixed up two separate series. I was talking about Better Than Us, the Russian robot show.

I've actually seen about half of Love, Death and Robots and I liked it but I confused it with the other show in this exchange. Apologies
 
4.3 on IMDB... probably not the best of Russian movies.
The Method and Better Than Us both have 7.4

Yeah Married With Children is generally rated high. You couldn't make it these days.

Do you guys do comedies about the Great PatriotIc War?

Just wondering with the different PoV between the former USSR and Western allies
 
Do you guys do comedies about the Great PatriotIc War?
Don't know any.

Just wondering with the different PoV between the former USSR and Western allies
Well, there are may be a dozen of very good Soviet WW2 movies, modern Russian are mostly crappy, but there are few good among them too.

If I were to choose one to recommend, try "Only old men are going to battle"
It's based on real recollections of fighter pilots.
 
Don't know any.


Well, there are may be a dozen of very good Soviet WW2 movies, modern Russian are mostly crappy, but there are few good among them too.

If I were to choose one to recommend, try "Only old men are going to battle"
It's based on real recollections of fighter pilots.

I suspected about comedy. Americans and British shows mock Germans, French etc.

I suspect it's because if the war experiences. French cheese eating surrender monkies stereotypes but they lost more in 6 weeks than the Americans list in 10 years in Vietnam. 27-30 million dead in USSR.
 
French cheese eating surrender monkies stereotypes but they lost more in 6 weeks than the Americans list in 10 years in Vietnam.
Different wars, can't directly compare casualties.
USSR also lost in Afghanistan 4 times less than Americans in Vietnam.

Afghanistan, somewhere in 80-s
 
Different wars, can't directly compare casualties.
USSR also lost in Afghanistan 4 times less than Americans in Vietnam.

Afghanistan, somewhere in 80-s

That's the official figures, might be as high as 25000.

But France fought, they got defeated. If they didn't surrender they still lose. They had no where to really run to, no land to trade for time.

The stereotype isn't really true.
 
Right, US 60,000 is also official.

55k iirc.

Difference in the USA they have published the names individually. And you can get access to government papers.

I can go their and write a book about Vietnam war and get access to source material.

I can't go to Russia and get access to the same materials say for WW2/Great PatriotIc War.

You could in the 90s, historians got to look at Stalins private papers and I don't think you can do that now.

I don't care as it's up to the Russians what they make available to foreigners.

But do you remember what I said about the west being scared of the USSR and vice versa? Kruschev for example claimed they were cranking out nukes like sausages and they took him literally. In reality they had 4 ICBMs.

The USSR and Russia aren't as transparent. That can cause problems. The CIA didn't predict the collapse of the USSR because they didn't have that information and the Soviet regime had closed cities etc. They had to interview tourists as in a lot of cases their information was limited to what they could see out side the window of the embassy in Moscow.

Now I don't expect to rock up to Russia and get a guided tour of a military base.

But if you're to secretive misunderstandings happen. Russia probably needed help in the 90s but in the lead up people didn't know how bad things were.

Leningrad and Moscow for example had the highest priority of goods and that's all the west really got to see except maybe Volga cruises and trips on the trans Siberian railroad.
And tourists only tend to see the good it's.

There's a Russian vlogger who's been to my country on YouTube. She couldn't do that 30 years ago. Soviet ambassadors daughter married and NZer and he went to Russia). Well you could probably do that 30 years ago.

That's better to NIMHO comeZ. Go to Russia have a beer, I hear Baltikas not bad.
 
"9th Company" is an amazing movie !

 
55k iirc.
58k in Vietnam, 14500 in Soviet-Afghanistan war to be precise.

"9th Company" is an amazing movie !
Yes, the movie is pretty good. The "based on true events" remark is not fully correct though.
The real battle on hill 3234 was quite a bit different, Soviet troops successfully defended the hill losing only 6 men KIA
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_for_Hill_3234

In the movie they were "abandoned" by their command and almost all died.
 
Still ... when I've watched the picture I really felt it for these boys. Left alone on the hill , giving their blood and sweat , toil, good and bad moments and when they came back home turns out they were fighting for a country that no longer exists. This is a powerful picture indeed ! ;)
 
I heard people who served in Afghanistan said the military scenes in the movie looked authentic (despite the events were fictional). Apparently the movie makers hired good consultants.
 
I heard people who served in Afghanistan said the military scenes in the movie looked authentic (despite the events were fictional). Apparently the movie makers hired good consultants.

Apocalypse Now is generally regarded as a good Vietnam war film.

I don't watch a lot of war find but gave seen most if the classics.

All Quiet on the Western Front got banned by the Nazis and is decent despite it's age.
 
I heard people who served in Afghanistan said the military scenes in the movie looked authentic (despite the events were fictional). Apparently the movie makers hired good consultants.

I personally liked the way they bonded with each other in the movie. Sure there was vodka - it is how we all bond :D
But in the movie there was something more , the bond that can only be forged on the battlefield. It is what makes man want to sacrifice themselves for other.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom