Civilization Unique Building Elimination Thread

[black213]

Bazaar : 18
Floating Gardens: 13 +1
Paper Maker: 13
Burial Tomb: 7
Mughal Fort: 1
Longhouse: 14
Satrap's Court: 10 -2
Krepost: 12
Wat: 11
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 12

 

[Kraydak]

Bazaar : 18
Floating Gardens: 14 +1
Paper Maker: 13
Burial Tomb: 7
Mughal Fort: 0 -2
Longhouse: 14
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 12
Wat: 11
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 12

The Mughal Fort is so pathetic I feel bad taking its points.

 

[Hasire]

Bazaar : 18
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 13
Burial Tomb: 5
Longhouse: 14
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 12
Wat: 12
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 12
Four free universities? Thank you.

 

[Man vs Civ AI]

Bazaar : 18
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 13
Burial Tomb: 5
Longhouse: 12
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 12
Wat: 12
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 13

 

[Sylexz]

Bazaar : 18
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 13
Burial Tomb: 3 (-2)
Longhouse: 12
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 13 (+1)
Wat: 12
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 13

 

[Bungle]

Bazaar : 18
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 14
Burial Tomb: 1
Longhouse: 12
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 13
Wat: 12
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 13

 

[The_Quasar]

Bazaar : 18
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 14
Burial Tomb: 0
Longhouse: 12
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 14
Wat: 12
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 13

 

[MadDjinn]

oh the humanity!

The Burial Tomb goes down to a double shot by the Krepost. Who would do such a thing???

(lol... the BT is actually a better building than the Krepost, after all of the patches are considered)

 

[Lyoncet]

(lol... the BT is actually a better building than the Krepost, after all of the patches are considered)

Well, sorta. You always want culture, and you always want happiness, but culture buildings should be good at producing culture - especially since it's a victory condition. Because of the Burial Tomb, Egyptian cities produce between one and four(?) fewer culture per turn than any other civ. If you take Mandate of Heaven it gets narrowed by one - assuming you're in positive happy. But you're also losing your early GA generation, which is critical.

So I can see why it got knocked out, since it's the only UB that is actually much worse in some situations (those being the situations you'd want to use it the most) than the base building.

 

[SirSaab]

Bazaar : 18
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 14
Longhouse: 10
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 15
Wat: 12
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 13

 

[Save_Ferris]

Bazaar : 18
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 14
Longhouse: 8
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 15
Wat: 12
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 14

Unlike the burial tomb, the mud pyramid mosque is a cultural cultural building, and if you time your SPs right you can get up to +20 culture in the classical era.

 

[bryanw1995]

Bazaar : 19
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 14
Longhouse: 8
Satrap's Court: 10
[/b]Krepost: 13[/b]
Wat: 12
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 14

Bazaar is best building in the game by far. none of the others are bad, but Krepost is the one I'm lease likely to build.

 

[Save_Ferris]

I won't argue against the Krepost because it's a replacement for the Barracks, will I usually build anyway while going for domination, and it's great for the small cities where I like making units. If it were a replacement for the Armory, that would be a different story.

 

[MadDjinn]

Bazaar : 20 +1
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 14
Longhouse: 8
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 11 -2
Wat: 12
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 14

Print money beats 'tradition SP' replacement.

 

[IgnatiusTBarfat]

Bazaar : 20
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 15 (+1)
Longhouse: 8
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 11
Wat: 10 (-2)
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 14

 

[Sparthage]

Bazaar : 21
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 15
Longhouse: 6
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 11
Wat: 10
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 14

 

[Kevin J]

Bazaar : 22
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 15
Longhouse: 6
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 9
Wat: 10
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 14

 

[Celevin]

All the hate for the Burial Tomb shows just how good the other UBs are... I'd still rather the Burial Tomb as a unique than 90% of the UU's out there.

 

[Tabarnak]

What happened to my favourite building? The BURIAL TOMB!!!!!


....................
...........
....
Bazaar : 22
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 16 +1
Longhouse: 6
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 7 -2
Wat: 10
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 14

 

[Ciek]

Bazaar : 22
Floating Gardens: 14
Paper Maker: 17
Longhouse: 6
Satrap's Court: 10
Krepost: 5
Wat: 10
Mud Pyramid Mosque: 14

Ugh, a quick death for the Burial Tomb, I find that building just plain exceptional, Extra happiness = extra citizens but meh... it was a toss up between paper maker and satrap's court, but I find kreposts somewhat more situational than most. I don't think people know how to use a longhouse it seems.