I'd like...
Missouri
Pitt
Nebraska
Syracuse
Kansas
Rutgers sucks at football, basketball and baseball, and will NOT deliver this NY/NJ market.
And Rutgers will continue to be bad in the Big 10, but that's not the point of adding them (because someone has to lose!). The rationale behind Rutgers is that they justify the Big 10 getting tier 1 rates in Philadelphia (where it currently gets tier 2 despite Penn State), as Comcast argued that they also served much of New Jersey. In addition, combined with Connecticut they give the Big 10 leverage to get much better rates than before in NYC. I'm not sure if any combination of teams can actually 'deliver' that market, but Connecticut also brings value in the great basketball program (men's and women's to the network) as well as added exposure in the New England/New York market for the Big 10 teams.
These schools also fit the profile of a Big 10 university...a large state flagship university that receives the bulk of the research dollars for that state.
My issue with Pittsburgh is that while it is a great school athletically and academically it doesn't bring much any new market to the table. So I struggle to see how it will pull it's own wait money wise. The Big 10 network is already on tier 1 in Pittsburgh and if Pittsburgh really added that much more to the conference wouldn't they have been added a long time ago?
As for Syracuse, they look nice at a glance, but I feel there are serious issues with them. First, can they rebound as a football school. Let's face it, their facilities are horrible for football. So unless they will agree to build a completely new football stadium, there is no way I could agree with allowing them in. My second big issue with them is that they are a small (at least compared to most big 10 schools), private school. Third, they suck at research, seriously they really do, they recieve less funding than the powerhouse research institutions of the University of Dayton, the Desert Research Institute, and the University of Missouri...Rolla campus. They just don't fit in the Big 10. Honestly, it's a much better fit for the ACC then the big 10.