Goodbye sweet penny :(

Should pennies be abolished?

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 58.0%
  • No

    Votes: 22 27.2%
  • undecided / don't care / what's a penny?

    Votes: 12 14.8%

  • Total voters
    81

StittsvilleJame

Warlord
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
252
Location
Ottawa
I heard on the news today that here in Canada they are now debating in the senate abolishing the penny, and will be releasing a commitee report by the end of the year.

I have head that it costs more than a penny to make a penny, and that over 50% of coins minted in Canada are pennies. This doesn't include the cost to businesses who have to roll them, or the bank which must accept and transport them around, and the time people invest in dealing with them. The actual cost is probably pretty high.

Also, the value of a penny is worth 20 times less today than it was in 1908.

New Zealand has abolished their pennies (nickels too apparently) and there was no inflation (apparently it is a misconception that everything would be rounded upwards to the nearest nickel).

The thing is, despite many good reasons to abolish the penny, I will miss it. I pick pennies up when i see them (they are lucky you know). I will miss them, much like I miss Pluto being a planet. Although neither of these things will affect me in any substantial way, it's a nostalgia thing.

I find the whole getting rid of the penny thing to be symptomatic of the problems with our society these days. People no longer value the little things, they only value that which will benefit them alot, not just a little. Even a charity, the Salvation Army, no longer seems to value the penny. A representative has stated that the would prefer pennies be abloished, and have even experimented with debit/credit machines at their Christmas kettles!That bothers me the most. They would turn down money because it isn't enough for them? Wow.

Anyways, what do you think? Is the penny a useless relic of a time long past, or should it occupy a special place, to remind us that sometimes little things can also have value.
 
I don't really care either way. But if they are kept, I want them made of steel to reduce the cost below the face value.
 
I find the whole getting rid of the penny thing to be symptomatic of the problems with our society these days.

I feel the same way.

Too often, people cling to nostalgia and tradition, hampering progress.
 
The only use that the British penny has is allowing supermarkets to make exaggerated claims about value ("Five hundred lower prices", of which 467 are by 1-3p), so I couldn't see myself missing the silly thing very much. Don't know if it gets any more mileage in Canada, but I wouldn't imagine it does.

Even a charity, the Salvation Army, no longer seems to value the penny. A representative has stated that the would prefer pennies be abloished, and have even experimented with debit/credit machines at their Christmas kettles!That bothers me the most. They would turn down money because it isn't enough for them? Wow.
I think it's the inefficiency of the coin, rather than any scorn- it takes so much more effort to transport and count pennies that I can see why they'd prefer to get the same amount wrapped up in slightly smaller material volumes.

Anyways, what do you think? Is the penny a useless relic of a time long past, or should it occupy a special place, to remind us that sometimes little things can also have value.
I would suggest that anyone who needs hard currency to remind them of that lesson will never learn it. ;)
 
Surely if picking up pennies is lucky now, it would be ultra-lucky after they are abolished??....
 
What would we do with all these pointless chunks of metal?
 
Nickels are also expensive, they cost 8 cents each. Congress almost addressed the issue but gave in to the demands of the all powerful laundromat coin machine lobby.
 
Well if they abolished it, its either raise the prices or lower it by a nickel. What do you think theyre gonna do?

Hint: They arent going to lower the prices

Anyways it wouldnt be too good for poor people :(
 
Well if they abolished it, its either raise the prices or lower it by a nickel. What do you think theyre gonna do?

Hint: They arent going to lower the prices

Anyways it wouldnt be too good for poor people :(

Round prices to the nearest $0.05 if you're paying in cash, no difference otherwise.

This isn't going to affect poor people much... if you make 100 cash transactions per month, at worst, this costs you $2 per month. On average, it costs you $0 per month.
 
Well if they abolished it, its either raise the prices or lower it by a nickel. What do you think theyre gonna do?

Hint: They arent going to lower the prices

Anyways it wouldnt be too good for poor people :(

I'm not sure how many people actually save their pennies, maybe if everyone used used larger denomination coins, they would be more careful with them instead of dropping them everywhere.
 
I'm not sure how many people actually save their pennies, maybe if everyone used used larger denomination coins, they would be more careful with them instead of dropping them everywhere.

My dad has a huge box of pennies saved up. Going to put them into a coin machine sometime and get cash!:D
 
We once saved something like $50 in pennies. The look on the bank managers face was hilarious when we came in lugging a giant container on a cart. (Do the math yourself)
 
I hope that they get rid of them, or find a cheaper way to make them in the US.
One penny costs 1.67 cents to make.
 
In Norway our smallest coin is worth 8.5 american cents. The central bank wants to get rid of it very soon, so that our smallest coin will then be worth 17.5 cents. I can't believe you guys still have 1 cents. (this perhaps also shows how incredibly expensive Norway is)
 
Back
Top Bottom