Happy V Day!

Agree, Lend-Lease helped quite a lot and saved many lives of Soviet people.
USA could save much more if second front was opened earlier, but can't blame them for it - America acted rather pragmatically, war in Europe wasn't their war. USSR acted similarly when it joined war against Japan in 1945.
 
When did you get to Germany? Last time I checked you were from the city of violent Saint.
I've been here since March. I only bothered to update my profile yesterday, though.

USSR massacred their own officers in far greater numbers. That's the main plus of Hitler compared to Stalin -- the former was mostly violent on other nations' expenses. If Nazis had it their way and did not clash with USSR -- there would be no Poland, and Jews would survive only in Russian part of Poland.
That is not a plus. That is a less extreme minus. There was no need, no excuse, for the conquest and annexation of eastern Poland. If Poland had had its way, it would not have been opportunistically invaded by the USSR, its officers wouldn't have been lying in a mass grave at Katyn, and it wouldn't have had a huge amount of land annexed by its "liberator." This was not liberation, but an invasion, conquest, and occupation less terrible than that of the Nazis--and being less terrible than the Nazis isn't exactly grounds for praise.

And there was absolutely no geopolitical imperative for liberators to hand anything to Poland at all. East Germany could have kept Silesia if she stay communist like she was. And after fall of communism -- good luck of getting it back from united democratic Germany, French kept Strasbourg even though West Germany stayed with West.
East Germany did stay communist--stubbornly so, to the point that the regime was rather opposed to glasnost' and perestroika, and preferred to close the border with its former communist allies in Czechoslovakia and Hungary than let more of its people leave. Silesia was never coming back after 1945--East Germany early on recognized the new border and abandoned all claims beyond the Oder and the Neiße, the West did it under Brandt in the 70's, and in any case there was no chance because most of the local Germans had been massacred or expelled.

The USSR's motive for giving eastern Germany to Poland was to weaken an enemy forever and extend the buffer state of Poland. Had the welfare of Poland ever been a consideration, we wouldn't have seen the war of '39, the deliberate inaction at Warsaw, and the annexation of the east.
 
^ Concerning discussion above, you might want to read or page through these two texts (or at least the shorter one):

Piotr Eberhardt, "Political migrations in Poland 1939-1948", 2006 (72 pages):

http://www.igipz.pan.pl/en/zpz/Political_migrations.pdf

P. Eberhardt, "Political migrations on Polish territories 1939-1950", 2011 (228 pages):

http://rcin.org.pl/Content/15652/WA51_13607_r2011-nr12_Monografie.pdf

================================

Also this might be interesting (though I have not read it yet, just noticed it now):

http://www.geographiapolonica.pl/issue/item/88_1.html

Gideon Biger, "Similarities and non-similarities: History, geography and politics of the boundaries of Poland and Israel":

http://www.geographiapolonica.pl/article/item/9927.html
 
June 22 was really late in the year to begin Barbarossa, I think. Luckily for the Soviets (and the world), I feel, the Germans had been distracted in the Balkans. (Unless my memory serves me badly - once again.)
 
An interactive map of Great Patriotic War showing timeline of invasion, description of notable events and memoirs of participants.

http://english.pobediteli.ru/flash.html

This is a really great map, I know it for some time already. It was first published in 2005 on the 60th anniversary of V Day.

But now they have updated the website, on the 70th anniversary:

http://english.pobediteli.ru/

The first version of the project appeared in 2005 – back then, we managed to collect a list of over a million veterans surviving to celebrate the 60th Anniversary of the Victory. Many years have passed since then, and now, sadly, fewer veterans are surviving. But we do not feel we have the right to remove anybody’s names from this site.

:sad: :salute:
 
June 22 was really late in the year to begin Barbarossa, I think. Luckily for the Soviets (and the world), I feel, the Germans had been distracted in the Balkans. (Unless my memory serves me badly - once again.)
Yes, Hitler postponed the date of invasion several times IIRC, because of Balkan campaign.
Funny part is that Stalin was being criticized for ignoring intelligence reports, which allegedly gave him the date of invasion (June 22-nd, 1941) nearly half-year in advance. If that was true, Soviet intelligence knew the date of invasion before Germans knew it.

This is a really great map, I know it for some time already. It was first published in 2005 on the 60th anniversary of V Day.

But now they have updated the website, on the 70th anniversary:

http://english.pobediteli.ru/

:sad: :salute:
Yes, it is the same site which I gave link to. Didn't know they updated it, thank's.
 
Silesia in the Early Middle Ages was inhabited by six Slavic Polish (Lechithic) tribes, their names were recorded in Latin as:

1. Sleenzane - around Wroclaw and at the Sleza river, and Mt. Sleza
2. Dadodesani - in the region around Glogow
3. Opolini - in Upper Silesia, in the region of Opole
4. Golensizi - in the region of Raciborz-Cieszyn-Opawa
5. Poborane - along the lower and middle course of the Bobr river
6. Trebouane - in the region around Legnica

If we believe the so-called Bavarian Geographer, in the 800s the strongest of those tribes were the Opolini (who had 20 civitates according to that report), the Dadodesani (20 civitates) and the Sleenzane (15 civitates). The Golensizi were weaker (5 civitates).

It is not certain what actually were those civitates. According to some scholars, those were boroughs. According to others, those were districts (for example each district inhabited by certain clans, etc.). But it certainly had something to with population size and / or military power (considering that the Bavarian Geographer was a report made by the Holy Roman Empire's spies / intelligence agencies).

According to Ludwik Krzywicki, after Poland accepted Christianity in 966, Polish church administration divided the land along old tribal borders - and so the Archdeaconate of Wroclaw encompassed former territory of the Sleenzane; the Deaconate of Glogow - areas of the Dadodesani; the Archdeaconate of Opole - traditional homeland of the Opolini; the Deaconate of Cieszyn - lands of the Golensizi.

The border between Lower Silesia and Upper Silesia - also between the Sleenzane and the Opolini - was the Silesian Cutting:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silesian_Przesieka

Silesian Przesieka, literally Silesian Cutting (Polish: Przesieka Śląska or Oseg, German: Schlesischer Grenzwald, Hag or Preseka, Latin: Indago) was a densely forested, uninhabited and unpassable strip of land in the middle of Silesia, spreading from Golden Mountains in the south, along the Nysa Klodzka to the Odra, and then along the Stobrawa, reaching the towns of Namyslow and Byczyna in northern Silesia. Originally, the Silesian Cutting was a boundary, separating territories of two Western Slavic tribes, the Slezanie and the Opolanie. In the 12th century, along the Cutting a border of Lower Silesia and Upper Silesia was established.[1][2][3] (...)

Map showing the Silesian Cutting (red line):

Spoiler :
Przesieka_slaka.jpg
 
Phrossack said:
and in any case there was no chance because most of the local Germans had been massacred or expelled.

Most of the local Germans actually escaped westward on their own. Only the remainders were later expelled/deported.

Let's quote Piotr Eberhardt (I already provided links to his publications above) - this is from the 2006 (shorter) publication:

http://www.igipz.pan.pl/en/zpz/Political_migrations.pdf

Page_1.png

Page_2.png

Page_3.png

Page_4.png

Page_5.png

Page_6.png


To summ up:

moreshamefurdispray.png


============================

There is a similar chapter also in Eberhardt's 2011 publication, and it is longer / expanded / updated (compared to the 2006 version):

http://rcin.org.pl/Content/15652/WA51_13607_r2011-nr12_Monografie.pdf

The estimated number of refugees and evacuated persons (i.e. those who had left the area and escaped westward already before any expulsions/deportations started) amounted to around 7,5 million people according to this updated 2011 version:

Refugees.png

Refugees_2.png
 
^ As you can read and see above, East Prussia suffered especially hard. Piotr Eberhardt wrote:

East_Prussia.png


Among those victims and refugees were many Catholic Poles from the region of Warmia (Ermland) and Polish-speaking Lutherans from Masuria:

Ermland.png


Compare the religious map posted above with the distribution of ethnic Polish populations (maroon, red and orange; depending on %). Southern Warmia was inhabited by ethnic Polish population - they were a majority in Kreis Allenstein (south-west) and a large minority in Kreis Roessel (south-east):

Warmia.png


Spoiler :
The_Poles_Map.png

Russian poet Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn in his "Prussian Nights" described the fightings in Polish-inhabited areas around Olsztyn (Allenstein):

Olsztyn has just been taken.
An hour ago, a sudden strike
Of tanks and cavalry overwhelmed it...
Now the night flares. Burning sugar.
It flames with violet-coloured fire
Over the earth. It seems to simmer,
A trmbling blaze, a lilac shimmer...
Knocks. Rings. A tumult. Then we hear
A moment later, the cry of a girl,
Somewhere from behind a wall,
"I'm not German. I'm not a German.
No. I'm Polish, I'm a Pole!"
Grabbing what comes handy, those
Like-minded lads get in and start-
And oh, what heart
Could well oppose?


But - despite all of that - many Polish Warmiaks remained in their homes instead of escaping westward, and survived the Soviet onslaught.

Later - after the end of the war - they were not expelled/deported, but were allowed to stay:

Catholic_Lutheran.png


The region with high percent of pre-war population in 1950 - 65% (25,355) - was the Catholic Polish majority area around Olsztyn.

Lutheran Masurians later mostly emigrated to West Germany, due to their lack of identification with Communist-Atheist and Roman Catholic Poland.

But autochthonous Catholic Warmiaks still live around Olsztyn, each year they celebrate the Miracle in Gietrzwałd (Dietrichswalde):

http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?p=103889465#post103889465

6e99cc4eb3953044d0335814cb7d0065.jpg


Warmiaks in their traditional folk costumes during the 135th anniversary of the Miracle in Gietrzwałd (in 2013):

051ff431e9a1e14a.jpg


These Warmiaks are to a large extent descendants of the Old Prussian (Baltic) tribe of Warmians, who became Polonized over time.

The tribe of the Warmians consisted of several clans / clan districts: Wewa, Plut, Medenowe, Wuntenowe, Lanzania and Drusen.
 
Back
Top Bottom