High Society Mafia: Game Thread

[Zack]

Should also mention that my result doesn't explicitly mention a roleblock. It's possible this is some passive ability on BL's end (I tried to watch him last night).

 

[BSmith1068]

Zack; Takhisis. I am willing to give Zack the benefit of the doubt for now, primarily based on his interactions with pizza and the things that pizza said about him.

 

[Takhisis]

If Backwards Logic accuses Zack based on a claimed result, but you don't believe Zack is scum, then why don't you vote for Backwards Logic? Seriously, BSmith, you're even less logical than our probable scum Zack. At least he is spouting nonsense under the pressure of having to save his own life.

 

[Zack]

You're trying to force a black-or-white situation, where either BL or me has to be scum, but that simply isn't the case. There's no reason to automatically assume that BL is lying about the roleblock if I'm town. It's weird to even suggest that.

Takhisis, since you seem to agree that there is in fact one killer, what do you make of Pizza tracking me to KingMorgan Night 1, and insisting I was not the killer, on the same night MartinLuther was killed?

 

[Backwards Logic]

I'd go public with my blocks, except for two small issues:

1) I can only block each player once. Therefore, I cannot block Zack again.
2) The players I block will receive no notification they were blocked.

Therefore, if I make my blocks public, the scum will be able to dance around my block effectively, assuming I've already blocked a scum who hasn't killed. Zack is the first player I blocked where there is explicitly no kill.

Takhisis, I'm very curious as to why you think I'm scum. You mention me as a candidate, yet make no specific case.

 

[Takhisis]

My dear Banker, I have already explained that, if your claims are proven to be untrue, then obviously you're scum and up to no good. *Puffs on cigarette* Is that not how this game is supposed to go?

 

[Zack]

Can you respond to points made in post #224?

 

[Takhisis]

Yes, I certainly can.

 

[Backwards Logic]

...Now, after yesterday's events I've been convinced that either you or Backwards Logic is surely a sick-minded person who has the astonishing bad manners to murder people while a guest of a gentlewoman's...

You mention after yesterday's events, meaning you didn't come to the conclusion I was scum based on my claim today. From this wording, there's (an)other reason(s) at play, and you're not elaborating on what they are.

Yes, I know if Zack flips town I look bad. But ask yourself this: as scum, what exactly do I have to gain by framing Zack in such a way? I expose myself as a liar and go down the next day in exchange for what, one death? Snerk is claiming he self-protected and isn't saying he was attacked, so I don't think that's the reason. Or...

...Snerk - do you get notifications if you block an attack? Because if you don't, that could also explain the lack of a kill.

 

[Zack]

5 Zack (Autolycus, Backwards Logic, johnhughthom, Takhisis, Visorslash)

3 Takhisis (BSmith1068, Snerk, Zack)

Not Voting: classical_hero

2 hours, 45 minutes left.

 

[Zack]

Yes, I certainly can.

Are you going to? Or just keep giving smartass answers that avoid the question?

 

[johnhughthom]

Let's see what this does, unvote; Takhisis

 

[Takhisis]

You mention after yesterday's events, meaning you didn't come to the conclusion I was scum based on my claim today. From this wording, there's (an)other reason(s) at play, and you're not elaborating on what they are.

Not for now, no. It's a free country -although not a gratis one.

Yes, I know if Zack flips town I look bad. But ask yourself this: as scum, what exactly do I have to gain by framing Zack in such a way? I expose myself as a liar and go down the next day in exchange for what, one death? Snerk is claiming he self-protected and isn't saying he was attacked, so I don't think that's the reason. Or...

..Snerk - do you get notifications if you block an attack? Because if you don't, that could also explain the lack of a kill.

If you were one of the murderers, you would be gaining everyone's attention, that's two days before your accomplice is killed… and then, only the Lord knows whether all those pieces such as the one found on poor Mr. Hold'em's body can be collected, destroyed or whatever it is that they are after.

Are you going to? Or just keep giving smartass answers that avoid the question?

Yes.

 

[Zack]

If you were one of the murderers, you would be gaining everyone's attention, that's two days before your accomplice is killed…

I thought you agreed there was only one killer? Why are you assuming a team of two?

Could it be... Perfect Information Syndrome!!

 

[Takhisis]

Backwards Logic asked about hypotheses, Mr. Zack.

 

[Winston Hughes]

Day Five has ended.​

 

[Snerk]

...Snerk - do you get notifications if you block an attack? Because if you don't, that could also explain the lack of a kill.

No I don't receive any notifications either. And yes, that could also be the cause of a lack of kill.

 

[Zack]

Huh, the timer says it doesn't end for another hour.

 

[Snerk]

Huh, the timer says it doesn't end for another hour.

Same. Timer is one hour off for certain time zones or something. Or perhaps a summertime adjustment issue.

 

[Winston Hughes]

That's unfortunate. I'll try to remember to add a note next to future deadlines to say how long from the post until the phase ends.

Nevertheless, this day is over.