History questions not worth their own thread V

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, Kosciuszko was taking care of peasants - see his Proclamation of Połaniec:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proclamation_of_Połaniec

Already before that - during the reforms of 1788 - 1792 - attempts were made to improve the legal status of peasants. The Constitution of May 3 had a passage about peasants, guaranteeing them legal protection by the state. It also granted personal freedom to peasants - but only ones from Royal lands.

The reason I bring up both the Bar and Targowica Confederations was because of the large influx of Anti-Semitic legislature that the magnates attempted to push through, largely at the behest of Yekaterina Velikaya, and Russian nobles in Poland during the Wars of the Bar Confederation.

Can you tell me more about these examples of Anti-Semitic legislature? It seems that I am not quite aware of this.

BTW - recently Shevah Weiss said something about Anti-Semitic reforms of Poland's Prime Minister in 1920 and 1923 - 1925, Władysław Grabski.

However, Shevah Weiss did not provide any further details regarding what kind of reforms those were.

The main things for which Grabski is well-known in Poland, are his very good economic reforms - including the currency reform, which ended post-WW1 hyperinflation in Poland. Even I was surprised when Weiss said about some Anti-Semitic legislature of Grabski, because I never heard of this before.

Maybe you happen to know something about this Anti-Semitic (supposedly?) legislature of Grabski?

Was the currency reform which ended hyperinflation "anti-Semitic" ??? I thing it must be something else...

.
 
Can you tell me more about these examples of Anti-Semitic legislature? It seems that I am not quite aware of this.

BTW - recently Shevah Weiss said something about Anti-Semitic reforms of Poland's Prime Minister in 1920 and 1923 - 1925, Władysław Grabski.

However, Shevah Weiss did not provide any further details regarding what kind of reforms those were.

The main things for which Grabski is well-known in Poland, are his very good economic reforms - including the currency reform, which brought Poland out of hyperinflation. Even I was surprised when Weiss said about some Anti-Semitic legislature of Grabski, because I never heard of this before.

Maybe you happen to know something about this Anti-Semitic (supposedly?) legislature of Grabski?

The Anti-Semitic legislature as I described is mentioned in detail in Storozynski's Peasant Prince in one of the later chapters. I can recall exactly what page or chapter, I have to dig out the book from my storage that has a lot of my books from when I was at university. The 1920's in Poland is not a period I know too much about except the Sanitation and other stuff involving Pilsudski, so I can't comment on it. Although I assume some antisemitism spilled over into Poland from Russia and Germany during that period, which led to some of Grabski's antisemitism?
 
Oh, this is the exact quote from Shevah Weiss:

"(...) Few dozen thousand Jews emigrated from Poland after the implementation of contra-Jewish reforms of Primer Minister Grabski in 1924 (...)"

My bad - he did not use the words "Anti-Semitic", but "contra-Jewish".

But still - I am wondering why Shevah Weiss is thinking, that Grabski's reforms (Weiss does not specify which ones exactly - so I assume that he is talking about all of his economic reforms) were "contra-Jewish" ??? Were Jews benefiting from hyperinflation, or what ???

============================================

And here I found an article, which is polemizing with Shevah Weiss:

http://niepoprawni.pl/blog/6206/dlaczego-zydzi-nie-wracaja-do-polski

But basically all this article says, is:

"(...) Reforms of Grabski were not aimed at harrasing Jews, but at improving finances of Poland (...)"

So nothing detailed. I still don't know, what aspects of Grabski's reforms are being discussed here...

he 1920's in Poland is not a period I know too much about except the Sanitation and other stuff involving Pilsudski,

Ok. So I suppose that you can't answer my question, because the Sanitation started not before 1926 - few years after Grabski's reforms.

.
 
Although I assume some antisemitism spilled over into Poland from Russia and Germany during that period, which led to some of Grabski's antisemitism?

Grabski was a member of National Democracy right-wing party.

But this alone does not imply that he was antisemitic or "contra-Jewish".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Władysław_Grabski

His economic reforms are generally considered as well-done.

He ended post-WW1 hiperinflation, unified and strengthened currency.

This is what English wikipedia article says about him:

Władysław Grabski was born in 1874, in a family manor in Borów (a part of Gmina Bielawy) near Łowicz, Congress Poland, Russian Empire. He was an educated man, who studied politics at the School of Political Science in Paris and history at the University of Sorbonne. While in Paris, Grabski’s political views changed. He abandoned the socialist ideas and turned more right-wing. He became an outward looking visionary, a man who would be responsible for creating the Bank of Poland and implementing the Polish currency. Grabski’s cabinet became the longest standing cabinet in the interwar Poland, precisely because his contributions in the agricultural and financial sectors in inter-war Poland remain unmatched. At the same time, however, Grabski’s cabinet was severely criticized. Stanisław Głąbiński, for example, criticized Grabski’s inefficiencies in the sphere of international relations, and Wincenty Witos disapproved of Grabski’s deficient agricultural reform, as well as his inability to inform the public of the state’s real financial situation.

The years Władyslaw Grabski had spent in Paris became an impetus behind Grabski’s desire for his involvement in the Polish government. Soon after Grabski’s return from Paris, in 1905, he founded the Agricultural Society in Łowicz, in central Poland. The founding of the Agricultural Society was quite significant. Grabski’s Agricultural Society quickly won the support of many peasants, which in turn led to the creation of the National Labour Union. Due to the growing autonomy and strength of Grabski’s Agricultural Society and the Labour Union, in 1905, Władyslaw Grabski was arrested by the Russian authorities and imprisoned in Warsaw. Grabski’s imprisonment, however, lasted less than a year. In 1905, Władysław Grabski was elected on behalf of National Democracy a member of three successive sessions of the Duma, the legislative assembly of the Russian Empire. He was a deputy in Duma until 1912. It was at that time that he became involved in the work of the budgetary commission with the Russian Ministry of Agriculture. Grabski’s involvement in the budgetary Commission became an impetus for his later desire to become the finance minister in the Polish parliament. When World War I broke out, he organized the Central Citizens' Committee, which was responsible for restoring order into the life of a society devastated by the partitions, and to represent the interests of Polish people before the Russian authorities. He also became a member of the Polish National Committee.

Certainly, Grabski’s influence in the Polish affairs increased when he became Minister of Treasury and Prime Minister in 1920. However his first cabinet lasted for only one month. In December 1923 he was again appointed Prime Minister and served as Treasury Minister in a specialist cabinet (appointed by but not necessarily composed of elected parliamentary representatives). Holding two positions of such importance meant that Grabski's responsibilities were great. Grabski managed to implement reforms which undoubtedly alleviated Poland’s economic situation and managed to preserve his cabinet for twenty three months, a relatively long period for a Polish cabinet in interwar Poland. Until the end of 1924, Grabski’s government enjoyed great popularity among the masses. Many considered Grabski a visionary, and remarks arose from those among the Jewish population that “Grabski was a God [because] he saved the currency".

Currency reform

Grabski’s (and the ministerial cabinet’s) great achievement in those years was the foundation of the Bank of Poland and the creation of the new Polish currency – the gold-based złoty which replaced the Polish mark. The Act of 11 January 1924 on the improvement of the state's treasury and currency reform introduced a new monetary system and established the issuing bank. “The Bank of Poland was founded as a joint stock company, which guaranteed its independence from the government and the state treasury. The Act also abolished the Polish National Savings Union which had acted as an issuing bank. Its functions were taken over by the Bank of Poland.” Stanisław Karpiński became the first president of the Bank of Poland. On 14 January the organizing committee of the Bank of Poland was established, and on 26 January the sale of the bank's shares began. Payments could only be made in foreign currencies and in gold. On 15 April, during the first shareholders' meeting, the Bank of Poland Joint Stock Company was established.

Władysław Grabski went further than establishing the Bank of Poland and the currency. He built a network of state banks and founded the Bank for National Economy. He also initiated far-going changes in the structure of Polish exports and industrial output. He established the Border Defence Corps.

Nevertheless, criticism continued over aspects of Grabski’s reforms. In 1925, Grabski himself commented that he was too optimistic about his economic reforms and that he should have realized that given the circumstances of depression and the recuperation from World War I), a complete recovery of Polish economy was virtually impossible. There were enormous price discrepancies between agricultural and manufactured goods. The Bank of Poland was faced with both a commercial deficit and an increasing national debt. The government made numerous unfavorable investments and in 1925, the Sejm approved a proposal for an excessively high budget, despite frequent warnings from Grabski’s cabinet. On 29 July 1925, the value of the Polish złoty declined significantly, foreshadowing the eventual “tariff war” with Germany. Grabski resigned his post and from active politics in November of that year. He subsequently devoted himself to pedagogic and academic work at the Warsaw Agricultural University (SGGW). In 1926, he became its rector. In 1936 on his motion the Rural Sociology Institute was established, of which he remained the head until his death in 1938.

Władysław Grabski died from cancer on 1 March 1938 in Warsaw. The Holy Mass was led by Cardinal Aleksander Kakowski in the Saint John's Cathedral. His body was interred in the family grave at the Powązki Cemetery.
Legacy

The significance of Grabski's accomplishments remain. In 2004, Poland celebrated the 130th anniversary of Władyslaw Grabski's birthday and the 80th anniversary of the public finance reforms he introduced. In September 2003, the Sejm of the Republic of Poland passed a resolution proclaiming 2004 as Władyslaw Grabski's Year.[1] In 2004 a statue was unveiled in his birthplace village of Borów.[2] The Warsaw Agricultural University labelled him as a "great Pole, great statesman, social activist and a man of great heart and mind, one of the brightest Poles of the interwar period".[3] In July 2006 the newly opened Main Library of the Warsaw Agricultural University was named after Grabski, and in front of the library, the statue of Grabski was placed.
 
It would be hilarious to have a Polish History Questions Not Worth Their Own Thread thread.
 
Regarding analphabetism in Poland after WW1 (mentioned on previous page):

In 1931 in Poland analphabetism was minimal in areas of former Prussian partition.

In areas of former Russian partition and former Austrian partition (in this case especially its eastern part) analphabetism was still high, but minimal among population born in 1912 or later and over 10 years old - i.e. educated in free Poland after WW1 / after 1921.

In other words - Russian and Austrian authorities are to blamed for this analphabetism, not Polish education system after WW1.

Catholicism being remarkably younger than Judaism, not quite.

Indeed, my mistake. :blush:
 
The 1920's in Poland is not a period I know too much about except the Sanitation and other stuff involving Pilsudski, so I can't comment on it. Although I assume some antisemitism spilled over into Poland from Russia and Germany during that period, which led to some of Grabski's antisemitism?

I think it's fair to assume that Poland's antisemitism (like that of most European countries) was homebred. It's not like it was some innovation of the 1920s...

Oh, this is the exact quote from Shevah Weiss:

"(...) Few dozen thousand Jews emigrated from Poland after the implementation of contra-Jewish reforms of Primer Minister Grabski in 1924 (...)"

My bad - he did not use the words "Anti-Semitic", but "contra-Jewish".

But still - I am wondering why Shevah Weiss is thinking, that Grabski's reforms (Weiss does not specify which ones exactly - so I assume that he is talking about all of his economic reforms) were "contra-Jewish" ??? Were Jews benefiting from hyperinflation, or what ???

Since the majority of Jews (not just in Poland) weren't rich that seems highly unlikely.
 
I think it's fair to assume that Poland's antisemitism (like that of most European countries) was homebred. It's not like it was some innovation of the 1920s...

Well you saw that I ended with a question, and I claimed I didn't know too much on the subject. Thanks for the answer though, I imagined as much that was probably the case.
 
It's equally fair to assume that "some antisemitism" spilled over into Poland after September 1939. (Not that it needed much help, but as far as I know no spontaneous pogroms erupted as in the Baltics.)
 
They occurred in Poland as well. Not as widespread, I'll grant you, because Poland didn't collapse into warlordism as much of Ukraine did, but they were significant enough to suggest that anti-Semitism wasn't something imported into Poland after the Great Depression.
 
This may be strange but I thought I'd ask, because I'm wondering. It has two parts.

What British weapons did the Americans use during WWII?
and What American weapons did the Soviets use during WWII?

And thanks guys for the informative reading about Poland :goodjob:
 
The Soviets used a lot of American equipment. We sent them all sorts of things. Less than they wanted, but many types. Curtis P-40 and Bell P-39 fighters were some of the better known machines.

I think the best known British stuff the US used was that they helped us develop improved radars. And the Rolls Royce Merlin airplane engine (built in the US by Packard) is what made the P-51 Mustang one of the most important fighters of the war.
 
This may be strange but I thought I'd ask, because I'm wondering. It has two parts.

What British weapons did the Americans use during WWII?

As Cutlass said, aircraft and radars.

and What American weapons did the Soviets use during WWII?

Tanks, deuce-and-a-halfs, jeeps, and trains were the most common.
 
What British weapons did the Americans use during WWII?

Probably the most significant (as in its role as a core weapon for the US Army) was the M1 57mm anti-tank gun, which was the Ordnance QF 6 pounder.

A large number of others were used as specialized items or used in small numbers or are just htings that are not well known.Items that come to mind include:
The DD Sherman.
The Enfield Rifle (not Lee-Enfield) was used due to a shortage of M1s, however it produced for WWI.
Lewis guns chambered for .30-06 were used on aircraft and ships.
The Spitfire was flown by the Eagle squadrons after they were transferred to the USAAF.
Mosquitos were used as bombers, night fighters and reconaissance planes.
Beaufighters were also used due to the US lack of nightfighters.
The Hedgehog mortar is an interesting weapon.

And like Cutlass said, there was a lot of internal components that were used, such as radars and engines.

THe Soviets used such a wide swathe of US equipment it would be hard to describe. Aircraft, small arms, artillery, tanks, etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom