I want to learn about Germany!

TheLastOne36

Deity
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
14,045
Is there any place that details on Germany from the 1200's(Or earlier?) untill the fall of the HRE?

My knowledge is extremely lacking in German HRE history.
 
If you can get your hands on it, Friedrich Heer wrote a primer on the HRE a long time ago that's fairly decent, if aging and kind of old-school in terms of style. I have heard that Peter Wilson, the author of a recent and very good (especially on Imperial politics and institutions) book on the Thirty Years' War, wrote another book about the HRE in history from the Reichsreform in the 15th and 16th centuries to its demise in 1806, but I haven't read it.

This is kind of a problem in German studies that's been only intermittently addressed over the years: there are very few up to date, in-depth books on the institutions of the Empire and the course of events in it as a whole. Most good books on German history over the last millennium look at the Empire and its politics as sort of peripheral to the main action, whether they are discussing the Hohenzollern monarchy, the Habsburgs, the Wittelsbachs, the Aufklärung, the Reformation, or any number of inter-imperial wars. So for the best discussions on the Empire, you have to go to period books that don't discuss much outside of their bailiwick. The aforementioned book by Wilson, The Thirty Years' War: Europe's Tragedy, does a splendid job of discussing the nature of post-Augsburg Imperial institutions and their response to the Reformation, along with Imperial politics and Imperial law. But they're only one part of the narrative.

tl;dr: read Wilson's book on the Thirty Years' War
 
For the end of the Holy Roman Empire, I recommend The Habsburg Monarchy, 1618-1815 (New Approaches to European History) by Charles W. Ingrao.
 
For the older history one could trawl the internt for info about the successive dynasties:

Ottonian
Salian
Hohenstaufen / vs. Welf — bleeding over into the Guelf (Welf) vs. Ghibelline (Wilflingen=Hohenstaufen) conflicts in Italy.
Habsburg

It will all lead to reading up on the Empire vs. Papacy, Italian medieval politics and the Lombard League in the south, the inheritance by marriage of the kingdoms of Sicily and Jerusalem. Covering the Welf in Saxony will likely require looking at the Hanseatic League in the North, the situation in the Baltic and the North Sea etc. Looking at the Hohenstaufen should eventually bring up the German Order and the push eastwards. Etc., etc. The western parts would seem kind of quite for a long time, comparably less drama in Elsass, Lotharingia and Provence.
 
A decent introduction to the history of the HRE by Geoffrey Barraclough: http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/269851/Holy-Roman-Empire (unfortunately you can't check the links included there unless yoy're a subscriber to Encyclopedia Brittanica)

Barraclough also wrote The Origins of Modern Germany, which covers the history of Germany from 800-1945, with an emphasis on the medieval period, but was indeed originally written in 1946 (http://www.amazon.com/Origins-Moder...=sr_1_9?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1265876300&sr=1-9)

Obviously most works are in German (and these will be more recent), for instance the works mentioned here: http://www.amazon.de/Heilige-Römische-Reich-Deutscher-Nation/dp/3406535992/ref=pd_bxgy_b_text_b

As an additional note: that books on this subject may be "old" (i.e. 20th century) isn't necessarily a bad thing; most, if not all, sources for the Empire have been published and it's highly unlikely that new sources will be found nor "new" views on the Empire be developed. In fact, reading an "old" historian might be interesting from a historical perspective - for instance by "modern" standards the likes of Herodotus and Livy are ancient, but these were the first historians (and in being so provide source material themselves).
 
how about Wikipedia? there's a whole load of information of the HRE there.
 
The Wikipedia article on the HRE is rather awful. I thought about re-writing it myself; though really, everything on the Internet on the early middle ages is nigh-useless.
 
I mostly nitpick factual inaccuracies when I catch them. I've only added significant amounts to a few articles, such as Nicholas II of Russia, and the only one I've entirely rewritten was the one on Thomism. The latter was a lot of work, and that's actually my area of expertise. Therefore, I don't think I know enough about Imperial history to rewrite it in good shape in the same amount of time.
 
Ok, I just realized that finding any book about the HRE in Venezuela is next to nil, and I hate Ebay after my experience with it, so is there any online sites that cover the HRE in detail?
 
I linked to amazon.com, Ebay is better for bargains. (And I can imagine that the Holy Roman Empire isn't a particularly popular subject in Venezuela, but isn't there a university around where you live? They should have a decent library for subjects like these.)
 
The Wikipedia article on the HRE is rather awful. I thought about re-writing it myself; though really, everything on the Internet on the early middle ages is nigh-useless.
The German or the English version? My impression is that if reading German, you might be better served by wikipedia in this department.
 
Got this little animation off the German Wikipedia HRE article:
HRR.gif
 
I linked to amazon.com, Ebay is better for bargains. (And I can imagine that the Holy Roman Empire isn't a particularly popular subject in Venezuela, but isn't there a university around where you live? They should have a decent library for subjects like these.)

Trust me, the only Historical thing here is about Bolivar. Venezuelans are Bolivar fanatics.(Worshippers if you like) It is much worse then the Ataturk obsession of Turks.

If you ever come to venezuela, do not insult Bolivar. That is a warning.
 
The German or the English version? My impression is that if reading German, you might be better served by wikipedia in this department.

Deutsch 102 für der Ausfall. :(
 
Back
Top Bottom