Mafia game (August 2019) [concluded]

[JohannaK]

 

[Takhisis]

NIGHT THREE​

JohannaK (an Innocent) has been killed

List of players:

@topsecret
@choxorn
JohannaK Innocent, killed by the mafia N1
pzelda Innocent, lynched D1
Snerk Innocent, killed by the mafia N2
AvatarKhepri Innocent, lynched D3
JohannaK (standing in for GenMarshall), killed by the mafia N3
@pzelda (standing in for robbiecon)
@classical_hero
Montmorency Mafioso, lynched D2

NB: pzelda has replaced robbiecon, JohannaK has replaced GenMarshall

It is now Day Four. There are 48 hours remaining.

 

[classical_hero]

Why would the mafia kill someone who voted for an innocent? It doesn't make sense.

 

[JohannaK]

I join, I get NK'd, I rejoin, I get NK'd again. Someone's out to get me.

 

[classical_hero]

pzelda

I'll keep my theme from last time.

 

[pzelda]

I join, I get NK'd, I rejoin, I get NK'd again. Someone's out to get me.

Yeah, it wasn't even a good kill. The slot didn't have much going for it and made two bad votes. The second kill was either targeted against you or random.
What has choxorn going for him, tho?
Topsecret makes good posts and Hero running rampart is at least active.

 

[topsecret]

pzelda

I'll keep my theme from last time.

OK. My initial question, which I have been asking for a while, still has not been answered: why did you claim to be a cleared townie before? Because I have yet to receive an answer.

Yeah, it wasn't even a good kill. The slot didn't have much going for it and made two bad votes. The second kill was either targeted against you or random.
What has choxorn going for him, tho?
Topsecret makes good posts and Hero running rampart is at least active.

Actually, my vote is going to classical_hero, at least for now. My other lean would be you, but I don't know... does anyone have any info/thoughts on why JohannaK was killed...?

From I remember (from years ago, admittedly), just because Choxorn isn't posting a lot doesn't mean he is mafia. He just plays like that sometimes.

 

[pzelda]

Yeah, Chox staying low might be nothing.
I don't have any info and speculating on night kills creates a narrative only wolves benefit from.

 

[Takhisis]

Two hours remaining!

 

[Takhisis]

The vote is so far tied.

pzelda: classical_hero
classical_hero: topsecret
choxorn: pzelda

Remember, the first vote to break the tie ends the phase.

 

[topsecret]

vote: choxorn

 

[Takhisis]

DAY FOUR​

choxorn (an Innocent) has been lynched

List of players:

@topsecret
choxorn Innocent, lynched D4
JohannaK Innocent, killed by the mafia N1
pzelda Innocent, lynched D1
Snerk Innocent, killed by the mafia N2
AvatarKhepri Innocent, lynched D3
JohannaK (standing in for GenMarshall), killed by the mafia N3
@pzelda (standing in for robbiecon)
@classical_hero
Montmorency Mafioso, lynched D2

NB: pzelda has replaced robbiecon, JohannaK has replaced GenMarshall

It is now Night Four. There are 22½ hours remaining.

 

[JohannaK]

RIP

 

[Takhisis]

NIGHT FOUR​

pzelda (an Innocent) has been killed

List of players:

topsecret mafioso, survived,
choxorn Innocent, lynched D4
JohannaK Innocent, killed by the mafia N1
pzelda Innocent, lynched D1
Snerk Innocent, killed by the mafia N2
AvatarKhepri Innocent, lynched D3
JohannaK (standing in for GenMarshall), killed by the mafia N3
pzelda, killed N4 (standing in for robbiecon)
classical_hero innocent, survived
Montmorency Mafioso, lynched D2

The game has ended. The MAFIA has won.

Notes on the game: the original draw was GenMarshall-robbiecon as mafia, with the other eight as vanilla townies. When I screwed up and lynched classical_hero I had to restart; as a side-effect, at least you got a mafia who showed up and killed people.
I gave topsecret a one-off 45-minute extension (or a warning, really, as I had not much of a definite deadline in practice due to RL and lack of a Modbot) last Sunday to send in a kill order or else there would have been no kill (Monty wasn't allowed to puppet his slot), and he sent in an order one minute before the extended deadline. So when on the next day there was a grand total of one vote apiece for two players and everybody away I thought it only fair to try and give the town an extension. Which still resulted in a lynch, but one with information and a bit of discussion at least.

Well, I think that's all.

 

[Snerk]

Thanks for hosting a game, Tak! Was about time we had one.

Gratz to ze scums for ze win! I though Chox was the other mafioso, so well done TS. However town should have finished the job with a little more activity.

There was scum QT?

 

[Takhisis]

No, we used the ‘Conversations’ feature. The mafia were allowed any private communications at all times, but they weren't that active.

 

[AvatarKhepri]

Every cloud has its silver lining.

 

[topsecret]

My main "problem" in activity was that I am getting my Master's degree. I was buried under homework and forgot about that game completely.

This may be my first win as mafia. I can't remember. Thanks for hosting, Tak!!

 

[classical_hero]

As soon as an innocent was lynched the mafia had won. Well done.

 

[Montmorency]

Oh yeah, this. Good work top secret, you made it!