Alright... Ive spent the last 45 minutes or so going through the thread. Unfortunately I need to get back to work here, but my leans are as follows:
Scum lean
Legato dont really know anything about him.
Robbie seems to have a good claim, but that stunt with threatening the town
Arakhor more of a hunch than anything else.
Neutral
Blade was injured, has been late on some wagons, some of which could have been opportunistic
Sprig seems to be supported by visor, could see him as 3rd party
Al Sips no indications either way, he is new to the games and I am unfamiliar with his style
IF/AA likely not a blood mage, but could be something else.
Town
Snerk was injured, have a testable claim for him that wouldnt make sense to make if he were scum.
Visor very town play for visor
Winston getting a town vibe from his open challenging of visor
Overall I am going to vote: Legato for today.