classical_hero
In whom I trust
lurker's comment: So you are voting for youself?
NOTW XLIII - The Walkingdead!
- Thread starter Takhisis
- Start date
Bad Player
Deity
mayor
Heart & Mind
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
Visorslash
Earthling
Me (Weapons Master, remember? Kinda need a weapon.)
Me
That is all.
My vote on Visorslash is a placeholder until there is more discussion.
And stay here.
Earthling
Me (Weapons Master, remember? Kinda need a weapon.)
Me
That is all.
My vote on Visorslash is a placeholder until there is more discussion.
And stay here.
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
me in reds
verarde the other
visorslash, I don't care if you followed backwards logic's orders or not. You're excompany (but coloured as a survivor) as far as I know, you have a weapon and ammo which I don't think anyone should have unless cleared by a scan (which does not mean "lol excompany"), and backwards logic was wrong about plenty.
for instance, he was willing to vig verarde in those PMs (if real). As well as kill frozen just because bad player claimed stuff about him (which did happen). Those weren't solid reasons.
edit- I bolded votes (color code probably good enough though)
verarde the other
visorslash, I don't care if you followed backwards logic's orders or not. You're excompany (but coloured as a survivor) as far as I know, you have a weapon and ammo which I don't think anyone should have unless cleared by a scan (which does not mean "lol excompany"), and backwards logic was wrong about plenty.
for instance, he was willing to vig verarde in those PMs (if real). As well as kill frozen just because bad player claimed stuff about him (which did happen). Those weren't solid reasons.
edit- I bolded votes (color code probably good enough though)
Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
Kennigit, probably should bold those votes.
Backwards Logic
Emperor Palpatine
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
Earthling Earthling Verarde Verarde
Visorslash, because I don't want anyone associated with BL left. I really don't care if he was town or working another angle at this point, but he's dead, BP's dead, and your the only one left of that crew.
Verarde can have the coffee; I don't actually see a problem with either him or choxorn getting the rifle, but doesn't he also have that chainsaw? Assumedly it would have been useful for fighting zombies but is there anything we ever expect to do more there?
I'm assuming stay here is still valid and it stil looks necessary to send the Radio message, and we don't have any other particular priorites.
Visorslash, my concern for what's missing is that we don't know about you, we already know what Backwards Logic said about some of things he did, but that doesn't prove anything about you. Arguing with Bad Player, misguided strategies, the reasons for those kills, we were aware of all of that. You haven't demonstrated anything with what you posted about yourself except that you were willing to kill people.
Consider two cases:
A townie gives a gun to a townie and says "hey, go kill some people"
A townie gives a gun to a mafia and says "hey, go kill some people"
You were the recipient of a gun here, some time ago. Would the mafia, like, actually NOT kill people? How is everyone else supposed to tell the difference? Regardless of debate before about Backward Logic's choices with guns, the end result now, in the present, is that we've seen several kills that weren't supposed to happen and did from giving guns to certain people. There's nothing else ruling you out as a suspect, as far as I know. The people you killed were not scum so "following those orders" isn't a defense.
Secondly, again, we don't have any other suspects for who killed Backwards Logic. Is it possible that a random mystery person was given a gun and nobody was told they had it, well, sure, but you're the only known person with the means and opportunity to have done that kill too. If you really expect you can defend yourself you need to clarify quite a few things and it would really help if you have a good explanation for who else could have killed Backwards Logic.
I'm assuming stay here is still valid and it stil looks necessary to send the Radio message, and we don't have any other particular priorites.
Visorslash, my concern for what's missing is that we don't know about you, we already know what Backwards Logic said about some of things he did, but that doesn't prove anything about you. Arguing with Bad Player, misguided strategies, the reasons for those kills, we were aware of all of that. You haven't demonstrated anything with what you posted about yourself except that you were willing to kill people.
Consider two cases:
A townie gives a gun to a townie and says "hey, go kill some people"
A townie gives a gun to a mafia and says "hey, go kill some people"
You were the recipient of a gun here, some time ago. Would the mafia, like, actually NOT kill people? How is everyone else supposed to tell the difference? Regardless of debate before about Backward Logic's choices with guns, the end result now, in the present, is that we've seen several kills that weren't supposed to happen and did from giving guns to certain people. There's nothing else ruling you out as a suspect, as far as I know. The people you killed were not scum so "following those orders" isn't a defense.
Secondly, again, we don't have any other suspects for who killed Backwards Logic. Is it possible that a random mystery person was given a gun and nobody was told they had it, well, sure, but you're the only known person with the means and opportunity to have done that kill too. If you really expect you can defend yourself you need to clarify quite a few things and it would really help if you have a good explanation for who else could have killed Backwards Logic.
Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
I'm pretty sure I gave BL the chainsaw, and he supposedly passed it on. If he didn't then he should have dropped it. He didn't drop it, so I either still have it or BL passed it on.
Takhisis, do I still have the chainsaw? If I do, it has not been used yet.
Takhisis, do I still have the chainsaw? If I do, it has not been used yet.
Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
Double post. No, I do not have the chainsaw.
So, BL gave it away.
I do not know to whom. He was playing the middleman, and didn't reveal any names.
I've been out of it the past week, so if someone has told me that they have it, or said something about it, I've missed it.
Someone has it.
So, BL gave it away.
I do not know to whom. He was playing the middleman, and didn't reveal any names.
I've been out of it the past week, so if someone has told me that they have it, or said something about it, I've missed it.
Someone has it.
So you don't have the chainsaw. I believe you, but great. I'd have no clue where it got to either, nobody else even wanted to go fight zombies except classical, though I am still disturbed by the lack of classical's items up to vote.
If you really need this gun I agree that could work. Choxorn do you have anything more to talk about though, I don't know what you specifically have in mind except being someone we can trust the gun with. I don't personally want to see another vigilante attempt tonight or anything like that so probably doesn't matter either way.
If you really need this gun I agree that could work. Choxorn do you have anything more to talk about though, I don't know what you specifically have in mind except being someone we can trust the gun with. I don't personally want to see another vigilante attempt tonight or anything like that so probably doesn't matter either way.
Visorslash
Deity
I'd say Mat93/Buddhafish are worth taking a look at. They were on BL's list to check out.
Vote: Mat93
Vote: Mat93
Visorslash
Deity
Verarde gave the chainsaw back to BL, as he told me, but I have no idea where it got to. Maybe he handed it out to someone. It needs fuel though.
Buddhafish
Abbey Road
Votes
Visorslash-5
Mat93-1
Just thought I'd put that out there.
Visorslash-5
Mat93-1
Just thought I'd put that out there.
I'm kind of clueless, and don't have anything more to say. I didn't even know anything about the chainsaw until now.
I'd prefer the gun, but I'd also be fine with Verarde having it.
Mat93
Emperor
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2012
- Messages
- 1,104
At my own request.
Visorslash
Earthling Earthling Verarde Verarde
I.e. I agree with whats said by everyone else.
On the point of the chainsaw, as people are dieing of gunshots wounds, either the person with it isn't using it, can't use it, or has a gun also. I wouldn't say it is the biggest thing to guide how we act, just something to be aware of.
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
the person probably doesn't have fuel, or is hesitant as it seems townies/visorslash have been doing all the killing.
No need for townies to kill other townies.
No need for townies to kill other townies.
