Niccolo Edwards
Looking busy
That wall of text is actually greatly appreciated (I like walls of text for some reason) and your answer was great.
Obviously sometimes you have to have characters who are on a different moral level from the POV of the story and/or are polarizing characters. I cannot deny that they can be (and often are) important in driving the plot.
Personally though if you're going to have polarizing characters I'd like to see different moral systems (or at least individual morals) forced into conflict, but forced together as mutual goals are the same. i.e. Group A has moral system A that conflicts with Group B's moral system B. Group C's moral system C though is in conflict with both moral system A and B. Thus Groups A and B are forced to work together which brings their moral systems into conflict, despite this moral system C is still the larger conflict between the two. If we consider moral systems A and B to be equal before the audience (both have positives and negatives to the audience's collective morals) then the conflict between the two is present despite the threat of moral system C. Thus, moral system C (the polarizing one) has forced A and B together and into conflict. I think forced conflict, while both sides try to create a solution (even if temporary and only to last as long as mutual goals are present) is far more intriguing then just conflict while both sides seek victory.
Obviously sometimes you have to have characters who are on a different moral level from the POV of the story and/or are polarizing characters. I cannot deny that they can be (and often are) important in driving the plot.
Personally though if you're going to have polarizing characters I'd like to see different moral systems (or at least individual morals) forced into conflict, but forced together as mutual goals are the same. i.e. Group A has moral system A that conflicts with Group B's moral system B. Group C's moral system C though is in conflict with both moral system A and B. Thus Groups A and B are forced to work together which brings their moral systems into conflict, despite this moral system C is still the larger conflict between the two. If we consider moral systems A and B to be equal before the audience (both have positives and negatives to the audience's collective morals) then the conflict between the two is present despite the threat of moral system C. Thus, moral system C (the polarizing one) has forced A and B together and into conflict. I think forced conflict, while both sides try to create a solution (even if temporary and only to last as long as mutual goals are present) is far more intriguing then just conflict while both sides seek victory.