Returning Civs - Elimination Thread

[679x]

Babylon - 16 (15 + 1) Not my first choice on the list, but the most underrated based on current scores

Moderator Action: Removed the comment concerning another member's choice. Does not belong in this thread, please concern yourself with your choice(s). Post answering the comment deleted. leif

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 13
Byzantium - 19
Ethiopia - 27 (26 + 1) - I admit that I don't know too much about Ethiopia. But that doesn't mean that other people haven't effectively communicated how deserving it is of a spot in the game. So, here's an upvote!
Hittites - 25
Iroquois - 24
Mayan - 28
Morocco - 25
Portugal - 27
Shoshone - 8
Siam - 20
Sioux - 23
Songhai - 11 (14 - 3) - This one looks to be the last one left of the arguably redundant civilizations, so I'll help it along. Mali replaced it. I don't think anyone is gonna argue that we should have Songhai too, when civ slots are as tight as they are. I would love to have more African civs in the game but this isn't really what we need anymore.

 

[Alexander's Hetaroi]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 13+1=14 As much as I think Assyria might work better, Babylon shouldn't be eliminated this early.
Byzantium - 19
Ethiopia - 27
Hittites - 25
Iroquois - 24
Mayan - 28
Morocco - 25
Portugal - 27
Shoshone - 8
Siam - 20
Sioux - 23
Songhai - 11-3=8 Too much overlap with Mali especially with the major city names.

 

[Kimiimaro]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 14
Byzantium - 19
Ethiopia - 27
Hittites - 25
Iroquois - 24
Mayan - 28
Morocco - 25
Portugal - 27+1=28 - Portugal would be a great empire focused on exploration, maybe trade, and if it becomes a mechanic, colonisation. Manuel I as its leader, with the Manueline architecture as his ability or agenda would be a nice choice.
Shoshone - 8
Siam - 20
Sioux - 23
Songhai - 8-3=5 - Agreed here - I feel little need for Songhai with Mali in game.

 

[Naktis]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 14
Byzantium - 19
Ethiopia - 27
Hittites - 25
Iroquois - 24
Mayan - 29 (28+1) Lady Six Sky , cmon firaxis dont miss this oportunity.
Morocco - 25
Portugal - 28
Shoshone - 5 (8-5) Well Russia took they're settling ability with extra tiles , so Im fairly sure there is no Shoshone in Civ6. I liked they're unique scout unit.
Siam - 20
Sioux - 23
Songhai - 5

 

[Xandinho]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 14
Byzantium - 19
Ethiopia - 27
Hittites - 25
Iroquois - 24
Mayan - 29
Morocco - 26 (25+1) Quite distinct and interesting culture, I would like to have Morocco again.
Portugal - 28
Shoshone - 5
Siam - 20
Sioux - 23
Songhai - 2 (5-3) Very similar to Mali.

 

[Amrunril]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 14
Byzantium - 16 (19 - 3) If this is going to be in the game, it seems like exactly the sort of thing the multi-leader system was designed to facilitate: a continuation of an existing civ with a different leader and a different capital city.
Ethiopia - 27
Hittites - 25
Iroquois - 24
Mayan - 29
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Shoshone - 6 (5 + 1) I'd rather have a new North American civ, but I'd be happy to take this one over most of the Eurasian options.
Siam - 20
Sioux - 23
Songhai - 2

 

[AmazonQueen]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 14
Byzantium - 16+1=17. Even Rome isn't served well by the narrow focus on aspects of the late Republic & Early Empire. Legions don't really fit the ERE.
Ethiopia - 27
Hittites - 25
Iroquois - 24
Mayan - 29
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Shoshone - 6
Siam - 20
Sioux - 23-3=20. Much rather see someone new from a neglected area of North America.
Songhai - 2

 

[Jkchart]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 14+1=15. Gotta keep the faith with Babylon. Gotta get me a great Mesopotamian civ in the game. Fits Civ VI’s thesis perfectly. So important to the history of Mesoptamia.
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 27
Hittites - 25
Iroquois - 24
Mayan - 29
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Shoshone - 6
Siam - 20
Sioux - 20
Songhai - 2-3=0 ELIMINATED. So much overlap with Mali in design now, and I would prefer new African countries or Morocco in instead of Songhai.

 

[AntSou]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 15
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 27
Hittites - 25
Iroquois - 25 (24 + 1) My knowledge of North American tribes is pretty poor, but I had a lot of fun with the game mechanics of the Iroquois in Civ 5.
Mayan - 29
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Shoshone - 3 (6 - 3) My knowledge of North American tribes is pretty poor but I didn't care much for their game mechanics in Civ 5. (Pathfinder was fun for a handful of turns, until you ran out of huts.)
Siam - 20
Sioux - 20

 

[alphaman21]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 15
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 28 (27+1) They have had so many interesting leaders that deserves to be represented in the game.
Hittites - 22 (25-3) They did not accomplish anything during the relatively brief existence of their empire. Their "invention" of iron smelting has now been disproved, depriving them of their only legacy.
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 29
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Shoshone - 3
Siam - 20
Sioux - 20

 

[returnofbabylon]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 16 (15 + 1) I thought it was the most underrated civ yesterday with 15 points, and it still has 15, so...
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 28
Hittites - 22
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 29
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Shoshone - 0 (3 - 3) ELIMINATED I don't think there are any bad choices left, but the Iroquois and Sioux are both more interesting to me as returning native civs from NA
Siam - 20
Sioux - 20

 

[The Kingmaker]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 17 (16 + 1) It’s one of the top five most wanted civs that are not yet in the game.
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 28
Hittites - 22
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 29
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Siam - 17 (20-3) I’m not as attached to them.
Sioux - 20

 

[Alexander's Hetaroi]

Assyria - 24
Babylon - 17
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 28
Hittites - 22
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 29+1=30. Too good to pass up not moving them up to 30 plus I'm not sure which lower one I wanted to upvote.
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Siam - 17
Sioux - 20-3=17. There are plenty of other NA tribes to choose from and I don't necessarily want another Great Plains one.

 

[SagarRathore]

Assyria-24-3=21 Sumeria is already there,have to choose between Assyria and Babylon
Babylon - 17
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 28
Hittites - 22
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 30
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Siam-17+1=18 Go War Elephants
Sioux - 17

 

[luigilime]

Assyria - 21
Babylon - 17
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 28
Hittites - 22 - 3= 19 i'm not fond of very ancient civilizations, i prefer just having egypt, sumeria and babylon.
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 30
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Siam - 18 + 1= 19 Siam was one of the gratest powers of SEAsia, modern thailand is a big player in asian politics, and ethiopia an siam should be in just for the fact they managed to avoid colonialism
Sioux - 17

 

[alphaman21]

You're supposed to explain your votes.

Assyria - 21
Babylon - 17
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 28
Hittites - 22 - 3= 19
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 30
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Siam - 18 + 1= 19
Sioux - 17

 

[Naktis]

Assyria - 21
Babylon - 17
Byzantium - 18 (17+1) If we have Ottomans then its no brainer to add Byzantium. I actually surprised they both wasnt released together in GS.
Ethiopia - 28
Hittites - 19
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 30
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Siam - 19
Sioux - 14 (17-3) There are more famous indian civs to chose from.

 

[luigilime]

You're supposed to explain your votes.

corrected, sorry i forgot

 

[Jkchart]

Assyria - 21
Babylon - 18 = 17+1: Everything else I like is still here basically, and this is the lowest of the ones that I still like, so give Babylon another +1 from me.
Byzantium - 18
Ethiopia - 28
Hittites - 19
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 30
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Siam - 19
Sioux - 11 = 14-3: I agree that there are better options for Native American Tribes, new and old. And I mean if they do bring back the Sioux, maybe we could call them the Lakota...

 

[AmazonQueen]

Assyria - 21
Babylon - 18
Byzantium - 18
Ethiopia - 28
Hittites - 19+1=20. An interesting civ who deserve another appearance.
Iroquois - 25
Mayan - 30
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 28
Siam - 19
Sioux - 11-3=8. I'd much rather see another native American tribe than the Sioux again.