Returning Civs - Elimination Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Assyria - 19
Babylon - 15+1=16 Just as worthy as the other entries on this list.
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 15
Iroquois - 23
Maya - 31
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 29
Siam - 1-1=0 They are worthy too. I’m less attached to them though. My apologies.
 
Assyria - 19+1=20 My first choice for an Ancient Civ.
Babylon - 15
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 15-3=12 Not my first choice for an Ancient Civ or another one from Anatolia even though they haven't been in the game for a while.
Iroquois - 23
Maya - 31
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 29
 
Assyria - 20
Babylon - 15+1=16 We need more Ancient Era civs, and Babylon has very strong credentials.
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 12-3= 9 Speaking of Ancient Era civs, the Hittites are the exact opposite. They dont have much credentials at all.
Iroquois - 23
Maya - 31
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 29
 
Correcting the values because Babylon should be at 17 - I can't vote for another few hours, but the increase to Babylon's score from The Kingmaker was missed by the next two voters.

Assyria - 20
Babylon - 17
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 9
Iroquois - 23
Maya - 31
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 29
 
Siam...:( I'm glad that at least there's a great Siam mod on Steam.

Assyria - 20
Babylon - 17
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 9
Iroquois - 20 (23-3) Iroquois would undoubtedly be one of my first choices for Native Americans of NA, but choices need to be made, and this one does not interest me as much as most others on the list.
Maya - 32 (31+1) All votes to the Mayans are few, they are too interesting and important, they simply should be in the base game.
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 29
 
Assyria-20
Babylon-17+1=18 should last longer than Assyria
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 10
Iroquois - 20
Maya - 32
Morocco - 29
Portugal-26-3=23 nothing new another European Sea power
 
Assyria-17 = 20-3 I also want Assyria back, but I had to pick between someone and at this point it will be rotating hits to even out scores and keep the faves on top. Sorry Assyria.
Babylon-18
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 8 = 7+1 I know they're next on the chopping block but I want to throw them a bone as well since I've always hoped for their return.
Iroquois - 21
Maya - 32
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 23
 
Assyria-17 =
Babylon-18
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 8
Iroquois - 21
Maya - 32 + 1 = 33 - Old favourite, it is a must be in the Civilization franchise
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 23 - 3 = 20 - Agree with most of the posts here... Already enough European maritime civs
 
Assyria-17
Babylon-15 (18 -3) I see this as a fairly average option among potential returning civs. I would have been disappointed to see it go in the early stages, but I don't see an especially compelling argument for it over the other top 10 options.
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 9 (8 + 1) Among the ancient near eastern civs, I'd very much prefer to switch things up and add the one that wasn't portrayed in Civ V.
Iroquois - 21
Maya - 33
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 20
 
Assyria-17
Babylon-15
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 9
Iroquois - 21
Maya - 33-3=30 - Do I miss the Maya? Of course I do. Do they deserve to be added? Absolutely. Are they going to make their are cramped and bloated with civs? Not at all. The thing here is that my interest in Maya is not that great to allow them such a significant lead.
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 20+1=21 - Eh, you guys are aware that Portugal was not just some random European naval empire, but the one who started the whole new era of exploration and colonialism, right? And that it could work very well with trade? And its Manueline architecture? And no, I don't think we have too many maritime European civs. Spain has an ability that I don't believe is often used - hardly a full maritime empire in Civ VI. The Netherlands have a ship unit and that's all. Again, hardly a maritime full maritime civ. Norway is one, I admit that, but it's tied to the viking legacy, making it unique case, with only England sort of remaining as a naval colonial Civ. That's not too many for me.
 
Some votes were skipped, just correcting, the current score is:

Assyria - 17
Babylon - 15
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 9
Iroquois - 18
Maya - 30
Morocco - 29
Portugal - 22
 
Assyria - 17
Babylon - 16 (15 + 1) - Feel like we've pretty much exhausted the argument on Babylon by now. I want them in the game
Byzantium - 16
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 9
Iroquois - 18
Maya - 30
Morocco - 26 (29 - 3) - I like Morocco as much as the next guy, but 2nd on this list is rich for my taste
Portugal - 22
 
Assyria - 17
Babylon - 16
Byzantium - 17 (16+1) There is an argument to be made about how there would be too many Greek leaders if Byzantium is added, but I don't think that should hinder such an important empire from appearing in the game.
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 6 (9-3) As mentioned before, they don't have much of a legacy to speak of.
Iroquois - 18
Maya - 30
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 22
 
Assyria - 17
Babylon - 17 (16+1) Only remaining contender to be in... Every. Single. Prior. Game. Bring them back.
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 3 (6-3) Don’t get me wrong, I’d love it if they made a comeback, but I’d prefer Babylon and Assyria first.
Iroquois - 18
Maya - 30
Morocco - 26
Portugal - 22
 
Assyria - 17
Babylon - 14 (17 - 3) - Doesn't fit VI's thesis. Also I'd prefer Armenia.
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 26
Hittites - 3
Iroquois - 18
Maya - 30
Morocco - 27 (26 + 1) - The only remaining civ besides the Maya I have any attachment to.
Portugal - 22
 
Assyria - 17
Babylon - 14
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 23 (26-3) Not a fan of civs that gonna start become good after medieval era.
Hittites - 4 (3+1) We need more ancient civs.
Iroquois - 18
Maya - 30
Morocco - 27
Portugal - 22
 
Assyria - 17
Babylon - 14
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 23+1=24 Ethiopia has plenty of characteristics that can make it an early game Civ.
Hittites - 4
Iroquois - 18
Maya - 30
Morocco - 27-3=24 Maybe it's me but I feel like Morocco is too high and I don't feel as much attachment to them as I do most others who are lower.
Portugal - 22
 
Assyria - 17
Babylon - 14
Byzantium - 17
Ethiopia - 24
Hittites - 4
Iroquois - 18
Maya - 30
Morocco - 21 (24-3) I really want it in the game, but its score is too high, I do not think this is as necessary to the game as Ethiopia and more than Portugal.
Portugal - 23 (22+1) Not only a naval power, but it was what started the era of navigation, besides being one of the largest overseas empires in history.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Taefin
Expansion idea: Colonization crisis
Replies
2
Views
456
leif erikson
leif erikson
O
Allow switching leaders not civs.
Replies
1
Views
455
Zaarin
Zaarin
D
Civ 7 where it let me down
Replies
0
Views
421
Ditpoct
D
SupremacyKing2
Where does civ go after civ7?
Replies
11
Views
914
Krajzen
Krajzen
Lord Lakely
TIMELINE: A Civilization concept by Lord Lakely
5 6 7
Replies
129
Views
4K
Ryansinbela
Ryansinbela
Back
Top Bottom