So what does one think of the iPad (not iSlate/iTablet/iWhatever) ?

On a related note, Apple stock is down 4% today.
That is to be expected after any announcement Apple makes due to the huge bump they already got from all the hype.

Here is a pretty good review of the iPad from today's local paper. The criticisms at the end of the article also raise some very good points:

Spoiler :
The stats

. 9.7-inch touch screen, a half-inch thick, 1.5 pounds
. Comes with 16, 32 or 64 gigabytes of flash storage; WiFi and Bluetooth connectivity
. Battery lasts 10 hours
. Basic models, available in March, will cost $499 to $699, depending on memory. Models with 3G will be out in April and cost $629 to $829.
. Apple also will sell a version with data plans from AT&T that will cost $14.99 to $29.99 per month, depending on usage.

Criticism, beyond that name

Not everyone fell in love with the iPad when it was unveiled. Online reviewers and commenters had their share of criticisms. Some of the bigger problems they saw: lack of a camera; the battery isn't removable; it doesn't use Adobe Flash; and it has no phone. Oh, and that name! Here are some excerpts.

Joshua Topolsky, editor-in-chief of Engadget

There's no multitasking at all. It's a real disappointment. All this power and very little you can do with it at once. … The keyboard is good, not great. Not quite as responsive as it looked in the demos. … No Flash confirmed. So Hulu is out for you, folks!

Brad Stone, blogging live
for the New York Times

Expectations were very high for this device. Some missing features that many people were expecting:

• No ability to play Adobe Flash animations, widely used on the Web
• No camera, still or video
• No non-Internet phone function
• No removable battery for a device that can suck a lot of power
• No removable storage

A commenter on DigitalTrends.com

A little disappointed by Apple for me. The design is still not anything to jump out of your seat about. Idk lets see how it takes off. And seriously the iPad?? MadTV made a skit about this a while ago. check it out on Youtube.

Chris Duke blogging on AppModo

• No camera. Video conference calls over Skype or iChat with a front-facing hidden iSight camera would have been a killer feature.

• Picture frame. What's the deal with the humongo black frame? My guess is usability tests showed that it was necessary (the way users held the iPad), but it sure doesn't look as slick as if the screen met up with the edge of the case.

• Storage. 64GB is the best they could do? What about support for network drives, memory expansion, or even tossing in a small hard drive?

• Battery. Like all Apple products these days, there's no way to change the battery. A trend that nobody likes except for Apple.

Priya Ganapati for Wired magazine

• No multitasking. Apple hasn't commented on this but it looks like the iPad works like the iPhone when it comes to apps. It can run just one app at a time and there's no background processing.

• And no GPS for the Wi-Fi model. Though the iPad has Google Maps, the lack of GPS means you can't use it for turn-by-turn navigation or in areas where's there's no wireless connectivity.

Finch44 commenting at PCmag.com

*Yawn* So its the Iphone with a bigger screen and can read books? Fascinating. Wake me up in a couple years when something interesting happens.

Marty232 commenting at PCmag.com

I just hope they don't name the higher end model the "Maxi iPad"!

1348.gif
 
I'm confused as to what this really is other than an iPhone mutated to gigantic size by nuclear radiation.

Why would I not just buy some small, super portable laptop? What does this thing do that my iPhone can't do?
 
Why no flash? It's just incomprehensible. So basically no streamed tv/ films/ sport except what you buy from apple. Why on earth would someone pay two-three times the money for a less-able netbook? No camera so no video-calls.

It's like holding the internet in your hands, only without a bunch of the good bits.
 
I'm confused as to what this really is other than an iPhone mutated to gigantic size by nuclear radiation.
That is essentially what it is. Think of it as a huge iPhone that you don't hold up to your ear. And that you can't use to make regular cell phone calls or take photos... Grrr. Lack of multitasking and not being a complete replacement for the iPhone is what I don't personally like...

Why would I not just buy some small, super portable laptop? What does this thing do that my iPhone can't do?
Surf the web and access and reply to CFC-OT anywhere you can get a connection? Do your email in relative comfort? Watch a movie or TV (or read a digital book or newspaper), while waiting to get through a Department of Hopeless Stupidity line at the airport or commuting to work? When you aren't driving of course... Accessing the web from your couch while watching TV?
 
It made me poop bricks.
Spoiler part 1 :
ipad1.jpg

Spoiler part 2 :
ipad2.jpg

Spoiler part 3 :
ipad3.jpg

From the Smoshpit. Heh.

Now, srsly, I'd never buy one of those things. It's just too big!
 
I'm a Mac user but I think that, for now, the iPad is a bit useless. It's just a huge iPhone experience, without being a phone. I'm not excited at all right now, but I'm sure the next versions will be much more interesting.
 
Wow. I can't believe MadTV made a funny clip.


Oh, right. The ipad. Seriously, it seems its impractical and lame. It's awesome as a show-piece to show how far technology has come. It's no waiting to start up is also wonderful. But it just seems like a bad commercial venture as is and right now.
 
Seems to me like Apple is trying to create a niche, knowing that Apple fanboys are going to eat up whatever i% they put out. It's usually hard to get clients for a niche that doesn't even exist yet, but.. yeah.. Apple fanboys are going eat this crap up and help drive sales.

This thing reminds me of Star Trek datapads, but for the life of me I can't think of a good use for this that warrants the hefty price tag.
 
No flash? Nevermind. Awful decision, apple.
 
[to_xp]Gekko;8851035 said:
being smug about it because you're not just another Bill Gates drone?

What does Bill Gates have to do with Apple? (other that he owns a bit of their stock)

And where am I being smug?
 
Surf the web and access and reply to CFC-OT anywhere you can get a connection? Do your email in relative comfort? Watch a movie or TV (or read a digital book or newspaper), while waiting to get through a Department of Hopeless Stupidity line at the airport or commuting to work? When you aren't driving of course... Accessing the web from your couch while watching TV?

I can do all that on my iPhone, albeit a little less conveniently owing to the small screen. But then, the portability of the iPhone is what makes it so convenient to be able to do that stuff. Lugging around the iPad kind of defeats the point, and makes me wonder why I wouldn't just spend less money on a more capable notebook or something.
 
I can do all that on my iPhone, albeit a little less conveniently owing to the small screen. But then, the portability of the iPhone is what makes it so convenient to be able to do that stuff. Lugging around the iPad kind of defeats the point, and makes me wonder why I wouldn't just spend less money on a more capable notebook or something.

Well the interface is rather awesome. It'd be nice to be not have to scroll side to side to read CFC :p
 
warpus said:
Gekko said:
being smug about it because you're not just another Bill Gates drone?
What does Bill Gates have to do with Apple? (other that he owns a bit of their stock)

And where am I being smug?

People will buy it so they can be smug about not being a Bill Gates drone. A very stupid reason, but most fanboys are very stupid.
 
Well the interface is rather awesome. It'd be nice to be not have to scroll side to side to read CFC :p

But on my net book that cost half the price of the iPad I can do that too! In fact I'm doing that at this very moment!
 
Back
Top Bottom