Soul Scourge [Game Thread - Concluded]

^^ the above is actually incorrect lol

forgot to change the timer to PDT rather than PST

since I personally adhere to posted timers more when I look at them, it'll be 1 hour from now as end of night
 
End Night 5​

The peaceful nights were no more!

Another Champion had fallen.

SamSniped was found dead!

Spoiler :
He was a Spearman!
units_0058_sm.jpg



Day 6 ends in:
[TIMER=3/11/2015 10:00 PM PDT; Day 6 Over][/TIMER]​


All updates linked in post 2
 
guh... gg scourges. Tomorrow is likely to be lylo (unless we have another night without a kill... scourges, this isn't mafia game in the east :p)






Visor, I asked you this question twice yesterday, and you dodged it both times, either by going silent or by voting for Dingdong. Why? I've given my reasons for suspecting Zack, what are yours? Sure, we know that Jar is town now, but what reason did you have for knowing it then.


Kennigit, will Verarde and Dingdong be WOGed or replaced, and if so how soon?



Visor Senpai, why don't you notice me?

________________________________

In all seriousness, I'm running out of ideas.

Visor and Zack's commitment to lynching each other is... committed, what can I say. That said, Zack claimed to have protected Jarrema on a no-kill night, and then Jarrema turns up town. Visor, you've also repeatedly ignored my questions, so right now I'm actually leaning towards vote: Visorslash
_____________________________________

More broadly speaking, all we have left is me, Visor, Zack and Verarde and Dingdong who have apparently forgotten that this game exists.

One of Zack and Visor is scourge.

That means one of Dingdong and Verarde is scourge.

The active scourge is obviously more of a threat than the inactive one, so for now, my vote will settle on Visor or Zack.
 
Another (somewhat meta) reason for my vote is this: Until recently I've been fairly committedly anti-Zack in thread, whereas Sam has been more on the fence. Perhaps the plan was to kill sam, get me to (predictably) lynch Zack, and thus win for scourges?

Isn't lylo fun...

Forgive me if my posts are more rambling than usual. I'm, amongst other things, ill right now...
 
Visor, I would like to hear why you think we should lynch Zack preferably to Jar, and why you didn't think so earlier when you voted for Jarrema

I wanted to lynch Zack for days. But I kept flip flopping, zack was active and for whatever reason I just didn't want zack to be scum. It is the same thing I do with Bsmith, I give him too much rope and hang myself with it in the end. So I looked elsewhere and latched (appallingly to be honest) onto Jarrema.

Also jarremas last post was really townielike of him and pretty much convinced me. An alternate theory is of course both spaceman and zack are scum and I've been screwed for days, but I'm not going to live in that world.

Eh, you can put your speculations on about my nightkill, but I wouldn't have killed stmarco on night 2 had I been scum. I like to give new guys a chance, read into that what you will.

I'd be interested to see who protected who, as it might give us some clue, but most likely it would be themselves I guess. I attacked zack again. Seems I'm like the only swordsman left.
 
As a sidenote, the reason I was so unwilling to rank suspects was because I did not want to let zack know that samsniped had been potentially protected.
 
Actually I'm just really lazy and can't be bothered going through the posts.

Its just a general feeling about zack to be honest.

As another sidenote, if the scum are you two, please just tell me so we can get this over with. I doubt it, because I believe the reason kennigit is loathe to replace is because one of verarde and dingdong is scum, and it would be unfair to either side to replace only one.
 
Re wogging:

I forgot to check the read receipt box on verardes but his last activity on cfc was mar 08

Count dingdong read receipt his pm.
 
Vote: Visorslash

Eh, you can put your speculations on about my nightkill, but I wouldn't have killed stmarco on night 2 had I been scum. I like to give new guys a chance, read into that what you will.
As if I love to kill/lynch new guys early on. :lol: You voted for Count Dingdong on D2 anyways, so your already silly point is even more silly.
 
Actually I'm just really lazy and can't be bothered going through the posts.

Its just a general feeling about zack to be honest.

As another sidenote, if the scum are you two, please just tell me so we can get this over with. I doubt it, because I believe the reason kennigit is loathe to replace is because one of verarde and dingdong is scum, and it would be unfair to either side to replace only one.

LAZY? This is lylo... Today's vote will literally decide the whole game...

In the end, I'm still going to vote for you, simply because if Zack was the last remaining Scourge, he would have likely killed me, as I had been skeptical of him for basically this whole game.
 
I've been going after Zack most of the game and you've followed. Now suddenly, you decide to vote me?

What convinced you that I was scum? Speculation over nightkill? What?
 
I even responded to your queries, but you seem to have missed that.

Unvote; Vote: Spaceman maybe you were trying to get the egos to clash? Certainly seems that way. If you want to speculate over nightkills, clearly sam was killed so that me and zack would continue to vote each other and then you get away with it easy.
 
I even responded to your queries, but you seem to have missed that.

Unvote; Vote: Spaceman maybe you were trying to get the egos to clash? Certainly seems that way. If you want to speculate over nightkills, clearly sam was killed so that me and zack would continue to vote each other and then you get away with it easy.
That would also explain why spaceman was so certain SamSniped was town for such a weak reason, i.e. PIS.
 
In the end, I'm still going to vote for you, simply because if Zack was the last remaining Scourge, he would have likely killed me, as I had been skeptical of him for basically this whole game.
Mafia don't kill every person that is skeptical of them. That paints a big red target.
 
I even responded to your queries, but you seem to have missed that.

Unvote; Vote: Spaceman maybe you were trying to get the egos to clash? Certainly seems that way. If you want to speculate over nightkills, clearly sam was killed so that me and zack would continue to vote each other and then you get away with it easy.

I've seen your response, and tbh I'm not impressed by it

I wanted to lynch Zack for days. But I kept flip flopping, zack was active and for whatever reason I just didn't want zack to be scum. It is the same thing I do with Bsmith, I give him too much rope and hang myself with it in the end. So I looked elsewhere and latched (appallingly to be honest) onto Jarrema.

Also jarremas last post was really townielike of him and pretty much convinced me. An alternate theory is of course both spaceman and zack are scum and I've been screwed for days, but I'm not going to live in that world.

Eh, you can put your speculations on about my nightkill, but I wouldn't have killed stmarco on night 2 had I been scum. I like to give new guys a chance, read into that what you will.

I'd be interested to see who protected who, as it might give us some clue, but most likely it would be themselves I guess. I attacked zack again. Seems I'm like the only swordsman left.

Here, for reference, are Jarrema's last posts:

ok. I think I will unvote; vote : Zack. I am a townie, if not really helpful.
My only hope is that Visor can read me correctly at the end

no, that was rather a joke. I am not even sure if he is not mafia. But if he is town, I hope he will change his mind and vote for Zack rather than for me (I have not so much faith in you changing your mind, but it also would be nice)

Pretty much all he's doing is asserting that he's town and begging you to vote for someone other than him.

Of course, it turns out that he genuinely WAS town (which is one thing that makes me trust Zack more: Zack claimed to have protected him on a no-kill night). However, I see nothing too inspiring in his defense.

I even responded to your queries, but you seem to have missed that.

Unvote; Vote: Spaceman maybe you were trying to get the egos to clash? Certainly seems that way. If you want to speculate over nightkills, clearly sam was killed so that me and zack would continue to vote each other and then you get away with it easy.

lol Visor, if I was scourge, I would have voted Zack as you expected me to, and sat twirling my demonic moustache while he got lynched. I wouldn't have bothered with anything so... elaborate.

Frankly, this post reads like a desperate scourge, realizing that they won't be able to get their intended target lynched, and realizing that unless they can convince said target to vote with them, they'll be the ones to hang.

That would also explain why spaceman was so certain SamSniped was town for such a weak reason, i.e. PIS.

Certain? Hardly. Nonetheless, I was least suspicious of him, because the reason for his innocence, no matter how week, is the only objective one. Every other person we only have in-thread posts for. On the other hand, the evidence for Sam's innocence came from night actions and results, which are objective information, reflective of actual roles.

As Visor said earlier, in these sorts of situations, assumptions had to be made, and given what I knew, assuming Sam was town was the most reasonable way to narrow down the list.
 
Back
Top Bottom