Suggestions and Requests
- Thread starter Leoreth
- Start date
adhiraj.bose
Deity
Was it ever discussed giving religions some unique ability ?
Zaddy
Prince
- Joined
- Jan 14, 2018
- Messages
- 361
I don't really feed the need to defend my suggestion from someone who isn't even running a game on the same mod, thank you.
TheMughalEmperor
Chieftain
- Joined
- Jan 14, 2019
- Messages
- 35
Iirc, the differences between the 2 in this regard are minimal, and your response was rude and uncalled for.
Visard
Warlord
- Joined
- Jan 14, 2009
- Messages
- 214
I have some suggestion for buildings:
Aqueduct could give
if the city is next to mountain to differentiate it from granary.
Levee is very powerful, so I suggest that it would give hammers only to those rivers which the city is actually connected so it would also be more realistic.
And the Dike should only give hammers to rivers and coasts, not to ocean and lake tiles.
Star Fort should give
to so there would be a reason to built it sometimes.
Aqueduct could give
if the city is next to mountain to differentiate it from granary.Levee is very powerful, so I suggest that it would give hammers only to those rivers which the city is actually connected so it would also be more realistic.
And the Dike should only give hammers to rivers and coasts, not to ocean and lake tiles.
Star Fort should give
to so there would be a reason to built it sometimes.
Last edited:
inthesomeday
Immortan
- Joined
- Dec 12, 2015
- Messages
- 2,798
Levee needs to be very powerful, to help simulate modern industrialism and to help scale the production game.
Since Levees are being discussed, is there any possibility for them to be buildable so long as there's X river tiles in the BFC? There's some preplaced, non riverine cities on the current map that feel terrible because they have BFCs full of rivers but are 1 tile removed: e.g. Bordeaux, Madrid, Boston, Washington (I think?), Toronto, the city NE of Beijing.
However, it's understandable if you want to maintain the current rules and the distinction between riverine and non-riverine. After all only a few cities are affected by this.
However, it's understandable if you want to maintain the current rules and the distinction between riverine and non-riverine. After all only a few cities are affected by this.
Enyavar
Prince
- Joined
- May 16, 2015
- Messages
- 517
Another levee-related idea: Scale the costs according to how many river tiles are covered in the BFC.
Maybe in steps of five. A levee in a city with 6-10 tiles would be current cost.
2-5 would be half cost (1 tile not possible, I suggest)
11-15 would be 1.5 the cost, 15-20 tiles would be 2 times the hammer price.
But, as was said, maybe that discussion is for later.
Maybe in steps of five. A levee in a city with 6-10 tiles would be current cost.
2-5 would be half cost (1 tile not possible, I suggest)
11-15 would be 1.5 the cost, 15-20 tiles would be 2 times the hammer price.
But, as was said, maybe that discussion is for later.
adhiraj.bose
Deity
Shouldn't Alsace-Lorrain have hills ? the region is plains in the current map. It would certainly help Paris' productivity if there were a few hills in its BFC. Also in re France, how about giving them a goal for colonizing Africa as well ?
adhiraj.bose
Deity
What about giving france goals to colonize Africa ?
Publicola
King
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2014
- Messages
- 759
A few suggestions for Great People names:
Subutai was one of the most successful generals in world history, and is widely regarded as belonging in the top ten of all generals to ever lead a campaign. It honestly boggles my mind that he isn't already one of the candidates for Great General for the Mongol civ. Can we please add him to the list?
The second one is a bit more obscure: Guillaume Boucher was a Parisian goldsmith who was brought to Karakorum to build the Silver Tree Fountain at the center of the Mongol palace complex. I'm not sure whether he should be considered a Great Artist or a Great Engineer, but can we add him to the list as well?
I'd also suggest Sorghaghtani Beki, the wife of Tolui and the mother of Mongke, Hulagu, and Kublai Khan, deserves a spot as one of the Mongol's 'Great Statesmen', given her outsized impact on her family's rise to power.
Subutai was one of the most successful generals in world history, and is widely regarded as belonging in the top ten of all generals to ever lead a campaign. It honestly boggles my mind that he isn't already one of the candidates for Great General for the Mongol civ. Can we please add him to the list?
The second one is a bit more obscure: Guillaume Boucher was a Parisian goldsmith who was brought to Karakorum to build the Silver Tree Fountain at the center of the Mongol palace complex. I'm not sure whether he should be considered a Great Artist or a Great Engineer, but can we add him to the list as well?
I'd also suggest Sorghaghtani Beki, the wife of Tolui and the mother of Mongke, Hulagu, and Kublai Khan, deserves a spot as one of the Mongol's 'Great Statesmen', given her outsized impact on her family's rise to power.
Jarlaxe Baenre
Emperor
They're clearly making a suggestion that France's UHV should include such a goal.
Oblivionyx
Warlord
- Joined
- Sep 10, 2018
- Messages
- 173
I have some suggestion for buildings:
Aqueduct could give
Levee is very powerful, so I suggest that it would give hammers only to those rivers which the city is actually connected so it would also be more realistic.
And the Dike should only give hammers to rivers and coasts, not to ocean and lake tiles.
Star Fort should give
I second a health bonus for aqueducts, but maybe it can provide +1 Health regardless of whether there's any mountains hear it? The primary function of the aqueduct is to bring fresh water to cities, after all, and it doesn't always have to be near a mountain/hill.
As for my own suggestions:
- How about moving the Mali Empire's capital to Niani instead of Djenne? It is the historical capital, and it's only 1S from where Djenne is now (not sure about the new map).
- When meeting a new civ for the first time, can there be a guaranteed number of turns that they won't forget you? Maybe 3 turns or 5? It annoys me that sometimes I can't trade with civs I've just met because they forget me instantly. I often have this problem playing as Japan.
- Mongolia should stick around for a while after their initial collapse to represent the Yuan Dynasty under Kublai Khan. I believe someone already suggested this in the Core Area Reform thread. Their core can shift upon Chinese collapse.
- Can we get a label in the civics tab on which civics have become outdated? It would be nice to not have to guess.
- Britain could get conquerors against China to represent the Opium Wars.
The French UHV looks hard enough as it is. 40% of North America and Europe is a big area. Besides, French holdings in Africa IRL would just be useless desert in the map, except the coastal areas and Malinese land.
EDIT: It looks like they have holdings in Central Africa as well... I dunno if that's jungle or rainforest in the map. Or maybe you're suggesting that they should hold a percentage of Africa instead of North America?
Last edited:
adhiraj.bose
Deity
Yes that is what I meant, that France should have a goal to colonize 40% or maybe even 50% of Africa. Its been much more impactful than its North American colonies. Also, it makes the play more interesting, historical and challenging.
adhiraj.bose
Deity
North African lands are NOT useless.
adhiraj.bose
Deity
40-50% of Africa in 1900 as part of the third UHV goal.
Similar threads
