wise vs smart

wise vs smart

  • wise

    Votes: 41 60.3%
  • smart

    Votes: 27 39.7%

  • Total voters
    68
You're right, cuz I already mentioned that :yeah:
 
As the one of the few people in this thread who is both, I can authoritatively state that you can't have wisdom without being smart. If you think you are wise but not smart, you're wrong about exactly one of those things.
 
Common sense, you mean the nonsense of a mob that overrides truth, logic, and wisdom?

That's a fairly long bow to draw and do you really think that is what I meant ? If so , that seems to lack some common sense ;)

What I mean is that often people who would not technically be classed as either smart or wise make better choices by simply having their heads screwed on ( non pedantic term for common sense)
 
Your point was that people are happier and successful regardless of intelligence. I think by definition wise includes that element, lest it isn't entirely wise. But since you divorced them I had to go with the another definition of common sense for your statement.
 
How many smart people have failed in life... Compare that with the number of dumb people who have failed in life, but would claim to have "life skills" or "common sense" in spades. Pretty sure "common sense" isn't the critical success factor.
 
Your point was that people are happier and successful regardless of intelligence. I think by definition wise includes that element, lest it isn't entirely wise. But since you divorced them I had to go with the another definition of common sense for your statement.

Unfortunately I am personally neither smart nor wise enough to really come up with something to argue against this .

But I do have enough common sense to know that simply praising this quality in people is along way from stating that "people are happier and successful regardless on intelligence "
 
Unfortunately I am personally neither smart nor wise enough to really come up with something to argue against this .

But I do have enough common sense to know that simply praising this quality in people is along way from stating that "people are happier and successful regardless on intelligence "

Wait now you're saying common sense isn't better than wisdom/intelligence because it better leads to happiness, but for a different reason? Then what is the different reason :confused:
 
Wait now you're saying common sense isn't better than wisdom/intelligence because it better leads to happiness, but for a different reason? Then what is the different reason :confused:

Initial statement by me " often common sense trumps both " I stress the word "often" , not "always" or even "usually"

It's not a sweeping statement regarding the superiority of common sense or one of those annoying " all you smart guys don't know jack , all you need is street smarts " rubbish.

I very much doubt Albert E would have come up with general relativity by simply knuckling down to business !

So to clarify any confusion , all I was saying was that in the context of the thread , its nice to know that from time to time the universe grants the win to the fella that puts his head down and applies himself or uses some common sense .

But conversely , a world without very smart or wise people to enlighten us would be much the poorer and I'm constantly pleased to be able to learn from them
 
Oh, yeah, I totally agree that there's more to living a good life or making the world a better place than being smart or wise.
 
[...]I question the existence of wisdom. Much of what we call wisdom is just actually intelligence[...]
...yes, and the rest is experience so wisdom is made up of one or the other or most likely a combination of both.

But you can posess intelligence without being wise, wouldn't you agree? As in the professor who thinks the thugs infront of him with baseball bats are interested in sports.

How many smart people have failed in life... Compare that with the number of dumb people who have failed in life, but would claim to have "life skills" or "common sense" in spades. Pretty sure "common sense" isn't the critical success factor.
Could you eloborate on what failing in life means?
 
Success means different things to different people, just because someone has not succeeded in the usually accepted manner, ie social and financial standing, does not necessarily mean they have failed at anything, they may well have just had the wisdom to search for happiness elsewhere, there have been people who were very successful in the conventional manner but decided to give it all away and search for what was missing in their life, it's all down to people's different goals.
 
Back
Top Bottom