A Tale of One City [Game Thread]

[BSmith1068]

Hell. Just for that, Unvote. vote: NinjaCow64.

 

[Kennigit]

I like wagon, I like wagons, I like wagonning, vote: Ninjacow

 

[DaveShack]

Vote: Kennigit -- "most recent wagoneer" method.

 

[Jarrema]

Dave, voting someone for joining one of two big wagons is not good idea. Fate of JoanK and Ninjacow is not sealed yet.
FoS DaveShack
I agree with your FoS-sing BigTin, BSmith. I am now leaning toward opinion that JoanK is really townie, albeit unexperienced one (and I fell that I gained this knowledge thanx to pressuring him).
Anyway, Ninja looks scummier.
So, to make this a clear lead of him, unvote; vote: NinjaCow

 

[JohannaK]

Thank God that people calmed down a little bit!
But, you know, I'll still vote myself because I don't want people accusing me of bandwagoning.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Keep your chin up, JoanK. There are times in mafia games when it feels silly or unfair what your teammates are doing. However, there are a lot of great experiences to be had. I've gotten so peeved in games where I basically ragequit. At the same time, I've also had more fun in other games than a man really should have reading and writing text.

Give it a chance, and remember always to wear your thick skin. Remember, mafia kill people, townies kill people, but it's never personal, it's just business.

 

[JohannaK]

I'll give it a chance in Day 3

 

[Jarrema]

I would like to add that it is (almost) never good thing for a townie to vote for himself.

Spoiler :

The only exception that comes to my mind is when someone knows that power role is going to be lynched, and tries to be lynched instead of more important townie

 

[Skwink]

Update may or may not be delayed tonight, we're getting a big winter storm and I plan to be outside for a lot of it.

 

[BSmith1068]

we're getting a big winter storm and I plan to be outside for a lot of it.

 

[Mergle]

Well, either JoanK is a newbie townie or an incrediably skillful mafia player. And I have to agree with Jarrema about BigTin's vote. unvote; vote NinjaCow

 

[Optical]

I would like to add that it is (almost) never good thing for a townie to vote for himself.

Spoiler :

The only exception that comes to my mind is when someone knows that power role is going to be lynched, and tries to be lynched instead of more important townie

Spoiler :

Or if you're playing H2H.

 

[Jarrema]

General, I do not understand

 

[Optical]

Highway to Hell, and life after the lynch.

 

[Jarrema]

aaah. Yes, it was special

 

[Joecoolyo]

Brevity may be the soul of wit, but posting no case is total ----.

Heh, my objection to you was that a lot of your posts are tl;dr.

So I thought my response was appropriate.

 

[Skwink]

End of Day 2​

The people had gathered once again. There was much debate over wether to lynch Ninjacow64 or JoanK, and at one point, JoanK had nearly became suicidal. In the afternoon, after many hours of arguing, the people were evenly split on lynching Ninja and JoanK. Though soon the majority of votes fell onto NinjaCow64, and he was taken to Michael to be executed.

Spoiler :

Ninjacow64 died! He was MAFIA!

Spoiler :

NinjaCow- 10 (Diana Chox Moreepic Darth Verarde Olaf BSmoth Jarrema Kennigit Mergle)

JoanK- 6 (Zack Ninja Mergle JoanK Landlubber Bigtin)

Zack- 1 (John)

ATPG- 1 (Joecoolyo)

Kennigit- 1 (Daveshack)

Living

1) General Olaf
2) DaveShack
3) MjM
4) BigTin
5) Verarde
6) Mergle
7) landlubber
8)
9)
10) choxorn
11) CELTICEMPIRE
12) Kennigit
13) BSmith1068
14) LordNwahs6
15) Jarrema
16)
17) Zack
18) askthepizzaguy
19) Joecoolyo
20) MoreEpicThanYou
21) JoanK
22) Darth Caesar
23) Diana Abnoba
24) Yoshiegg737
25) johnhughthom

Dead

1) Red_Spy Lynched day 1 Innocent
2) Classical_Hero Killed night 1 Innocent
3) Ninjacow64 Lynched day 2 Mafia

Night 2 will end in 24 hours​

 

[NinjaCow64]

I think I learned a valuable lesson today: Don't try to lynch ATPG when you are Mafia. It will end badly.

 

[GamezRule]

And here is the true lesson that you should have learned: Askthepizzaguy ALWAYS has a trick up his sleeve, so be careful when doing ANYTHING to him.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Wow. I mean, the typical OMGUS vote from me would be my standard play because freaking mafia always try to accuse me. I had a streak of seven games in a row where I OMGUS'ed the mafia early on in the game, I thought the pattern would be over by now.

Ninja, you came off sounding so scummy, that I thought I was getting a false alarm. Seriously, well done townsfolk for catching that one.

And the above kind of tree-hugging self-righteous behavior stinks to high heavens of being a mafioso who is already taking the game far, far too seriously by comparison to everyone else, because they're all like "I have a mafia role, so the obvious solution is to act as pro-townie as possible and call out policy lynches as being bad for the town! Surely no one will suspect my diabolical plan to murder townies now that I've pretended to care about them more than anyone else does!"

Listen hippie, I'm going to lynch you next, and there's not a thing you can do about it. When you flip mafia, I hope it teaches you a lesson about trying too hard to put a halo over your own head. Lay off the bong and get a job!

I mean I did post this, but the wagon got so big I didn't even need to join it. LOL

NinjaCow, would you really play the game this way if you were mafia? Seems a bit suicidal to me. I'm the king of OMGUS votes and they usually hit scum too.

But really surprising. Really surprising. May I ask who on your team thought this was a good idea?