Aspiring Rapper's MAFIA- Game Thread

Oh Dear, I'll just take a seat over there?!!

Good analysis on the Visor-vote, shows that even if you disregard a few there is still a core of CFC players that suspect after pages of Visor-fluff that there is something fishy is with our Aussie friend.

Why Golden1knight? It's d1, even if you don't have time to read everything, your here on the forum so make a post and chuck a vote to a lurker if need be.
Lorens- seems a good plan to post some previous town games to use a template, since everything is so "meta" these days.
 
Good analysis on the Visor-vote, shows that even if you disregard a few there is still a core of CFC players that suspect after pages of Visor-fluff that there is something fishy is with our Aussie friend.

Not necessarily. But I understand your desire to lynch members of the superior nation. Can't be helped
 
*snip*

Sooh - This is a minor one, but Sooh's been quite quiet despite being around, I would like to see more from her and what she thinks, just a gut read on this one.

Now the lot of you can sod off and lynch someone who is actually scummy.
Just an excuse or explanation if you will.

This game has been moving a lot faster than I expected, so I've been trying to read along from work. I work in a middle school, so I rarely have more than five minutes to myself which makes it difficult to be active from work. I've been here reading up and catching up, that's why I've been lurking.

*cue all the people who thinks I'm overdefending myself*
 
Tomorrow fluff convo:
Spoiler :

Hmm... Seems to be an easy statement to make. Why does it not really matter?

Is that really alignment indicative? Weak.


It doesn't matter who he is, and meta changes, but you want him to supply meta that may no longer be useful?
First part: It doesn't matter to me that I don't know who he is, and also me agreeing with Cass is sort of a none statement. I was giving my opinion on how when he asked others for meta he should supply the same so that those who may be so inclined can go and read some previous games on their own.

I won't go read them, because I believe meta changes. Also I don't have time, so unless I have specific questions about one person's meta I won't go read other games.

These questions/comments are really reaching IMO. Bordering on misrepping. I don't like it. It's either an overly eager townie who's searching for stuff to suspect or a scumbag trying to make others seem suspicious.
 
Alright, so have you caught up Sooh?

Working on it.

I think I need to reread everything too, because on a new forum with so many new people to relate to I can't really remember who said what without doing more work and making lists and stuff.
 
Sushi, when you get back I'd like to hear your view on what I was doing in Mel Gibson. Describe my play, and show how it's similar to this game.
 
I'm going to have dinner now, and when I come back I'll dig in from the beginning of the game.

Our lovely mod cooked for me :love:
 
These questions/comments are really reaching IMO. Bordering on misrepping. I don't like it. It's either an overly eager townie who's searching for stuff to suspect or a scumbag trying to make others seem suspicious.

Agreeing with this because it saves me the time having to dig back through for the post Sooh is referencing here. Sushi's sloooowly starting to look better to me, but then there are posts like this that make me wonder. The whole grammatical analysis thing feels like it could be really forced. Like it makes me wonder if we were somehow playing this by mail correspondence if GS would try to invoke handwriting analysis as a legitimate way to gauge people. Also a lot of Sushi's posts have been flat assertions about things being weird or things being town or the like, or using some predetermined scumtells or Meta, both of which are unreliable IMO. I have moments where I'm like "Oh, ok, this seems towny to me" but overall I don't actually see evidence of a lot of thought. There are some here who know Sushi right? To those who do, how good is she at faking town? The reason this read is giving me such a hard time is that I don't recall anything that couldn't be faked by an experienced enough player.

Had a brief wolf ping on Mat, but then I went to take a shower and I forgot what it was. The interaction between Mat and Cuth has me feeling better about Mat and worse about Cuth. IIRC, Cuth is usually similar in playstyle to a lot of the other players here, and the fact that he's seamlessly slipped into MU mode is making a lot of what he says and does seem disingenuous.

Visor is a medium town lean of mine now(I was rereading parts of the first pages, last night, where I got that impression + I like the work he has put in while I have been sleeping)
Glossy also leaning town, but haven't played against her where she was scum - I do know she won a recent game as scum though, where she was deep wolfing(or at least just the last scum for some days) - so might be I'll go take a look at that and compare to this, at some point.

What I'm primarily trying to say with this, is that I'm not too impressed with the votings here - top 2 most talkative players in vote lead.. That's a dream scenario for the scum team, if they both are town, which is likely.

Also wanted to address this because I'm seeing it differently than you are. If I was scum this game, I'd be very happy about the level of activity Glossy and Visor are showing. Let's them draw all the attention. Talkative does not equal townie and judging a player on volume rather than content is a mistake IMO. On the other hand, it follows that if scum want all the attention on those two, then scum will be found lurking and low posting. But like I said, I'm having trouble reading GS, and I'm not willing to assume that she's not scum. On the other other hand, she hasn't been dominating the discussion as much as she was earlier, and a handful of other players seem to have picked up steam, which is good.

Jeez, every line of thought I have makes it harder for me to solidify my read on Sushi...I'll have to look in other directions for now I suppose.

I'd vote for Al Sips or Cass for this day phase. All of the stuff against Al has been reasonable and I haven't noticed anything in his behavior that says "town" particularly, and, as others have pointed out, someone on the Visor wagon is bound to be mafia.

Cass reads just as bad as Cuth when I take a second look at the Visor/Newyn/Cass/Cuth wolf joke thing.
 
Back
Top Bottom