caketastydelish v. bootstoots

Caketastydelish is appealing the following infraction:

All relevant PMs are above. As you can see, Cake's appeal is based on his assertion that this was made on April Fools, he is known for making jokes like that, it wasn't that bad, and he is middle eastern.

My take: first of all this is an RD thread about Islam, so a higher standard applies. Under that standard, even if we accept as true everything Cake said, this is non-substantive spam warranting points.

However I don't think any of Cake's points have merit anyway and a trolling infraction (if not a ban) is warranted under our rules for RD posts.
(a) April fool's day is not a license to troll or make offensive posts, the forum's rules apply 365 days a year, 24 hours a day and I fail to see how this is any sort of "prank" or anything remotely close to an April Fool's jest;
(b) a poster's history of trolling only means the poster is more likely deserving of infraction, not less (and Cake does have an infraction history);
(c) I see zero humor in the "joke," it is in incredibly poor taste at best; and finally,
(d) being middle eastern is not license to troll middle easterners.

So, I would vote to uphold.

edit: Cake wanted to add two additional PM's to the record here:

and

 

Yes. 5 char