I agree that viability should come first, but we have to put relevance relatively high compared to it. Maybe 3/5 of the worth or something. Just because it is easy to make, doesn't mean we should make it. Have the relevance and viability decided seperately, and have the coolness part on a poll. That is the part that other people would have a say in. The actual designers of the mod should decide what the Viability, and Relevance are. Anyone could decide with the coolness. For example:
The Empire. Anyone could see that it is Relevant, maybe the highest Relevance possible. Viability, I don't know, but it shouldn't be too hard. Coolness, well, I don't know much about it, but maybe let people download a sample of it, and then decide. I don't know how much to put in the sample, though. It shouldn't be so much that it is the civilization, and no more work needed, but it should be large enough that people could see what it is like. I dunno...
The Empire. Anyone could see that it is Relevant, maybe the highest Relevance possible. Viability, I don't know, but it shouldn't be too hard. Coolness, well, I don't know much about it, but maybe let people download a sample of it, and then decide. I don't know how much to put in the sample, though. It shouldn't be so much that it is the civilization, and no more work needed, but it should be large enough that people could see what it is like. I dunno...