Darths and Droids Mafia- Game Thread

[Askthepizzaguy]

Tally:

Lynch:

spaceman98: 2 (Gone 3 the Celt, Mergle)
Zack: 1 (Backwards Logic)
topsecret: 1 (spaceman98)
Mat93: 1 (Ravus Sol)
Backwards Logic: 1 (Zack)

Orb:

Zack: 2 (Mergle, Zack)
Backwards Logic: 1 (Backwards Logic)
Gone 3 the Celt: 1 (spaceman98)

This tally makes my teeth bleed.

 

[Buddhafish]

chox, I voted for spaceman.

And Atpg, you don't have teeth. You're a droid.

 

[johnhughthom]

chox, I voted for spaceman.

And Atpg, you don't have teeth. You're a droid.

Haven't you heard of Dragon's Teeth? They're robotic, and not really teeth, and part of a completely different....


Shut up.

 

[Jarrema]

vote: spaceman

 

[SamSniped]

Yeah, I'll Vote: Spaceman.

 

[topsecret]

Players:
2. Autolycus - Lurker. Maybe something here, maybe not.
4. Backwards Logic - Continually goes after Zack. Also insists he's more powerful lynched.
6. Buddhafish - Somewhat a lurker. And, totally unrelated, but still curious, he claims to have voted for spaceman, though a simple "who posted" search refutes that, at least for today's vote.
12. Gone 3 The Celt - Yoda.
13. Jarrema - Hmm. Lurker. Zack insisted he was a bad lynch.
17. Mat93 Yep. Zack's scanner got a "no result" on him.
19. Mergle Town, IIRC. Also, the primary accuser of spaceman, for reference.
20. SamSniped Lurks, but has a PG scan, AFAIK.
22. spaceman98 Switched to Ninjacow at the last second before SK was lynched. Definitely could be a scummy move, since Optical would replace SK. Also, had accused me of being scum. (which I know I'm not. ) He claims to be Watto, this is confirmed by Kennigit's beard scan.
25. topsecret I know I'm a townie, and I survived a nightkill. Also, I would be fine with revealing my role to someone.
26. traius Ravus_Sol Hmm, can't remember why we didn't lynch traius...
29. Zack I'm not repeating everything here. Pretty much has to be town.

My thoughts (and simple facts) in bold.

I'll vote when I think this through.

 

[Buddhafish]

Oh sorry. I meant to vote for spaceman.

Vote:spaceman

 

[Zack]

Why spaceman? Other than myself, he's arguably the least likely cultist (due to his confirmed avoidance ability).

 

[Takhisis]

Zaccino, do you still insist that BL be lynched?

My thoughts:
Palpatine is a perfect Masterchief role, but since the cult killed JHT this turn, I doubt he/she could have been converted. While mechaerick was a cult leader, the cult would not have converted Zack, so unless he was in a pointlessly elaborate bussing operation, he/she was not converted then. Therefore, as suspicious as Zack's "network" is, he/she was not cultified recently. Could he/she have been somehow insiduous before? Yes, but a mix of scan and his effective scumhunting make that unlikely. Actually, there is a remote possibility that every cultist can kill or convert (perhaps with a probability attached) and Zack was converted, but that would be OP. My suspicion is this: Zack is a third party with one goal: To get the orb at all costs. Not inherently anti-town as giving himher the orb could be mutually benificial, or he/she may just blow up the planet...

I still don't like BL either. His/her PG confirms his roleclaim, but his/her logic is terrible and his/her desire for the orb is strange in the context of his role. That makes me think BL is a jester, especially since his power is after death. I have nothing against vidging him/her, but we have bigger fish to fry.

Specifically, vote: Topsecret, who is often much more active than this, but has hardly posted today, or in this game. Also, something about Mergle strikes me as slightly off, but not enough for a vote or a case... Just, I find his willingness to defend Zack strange and his statements about the killer in stormtrooper armor (instead of a stormtrooper) seem to be PIS.

Also Ord to G3tC, since he is the vidge and if he does not kill, we know he was converted, so that is reliable and without the risk that Zack+orb = planet buster.

You're voting toppsecret to try to start a counterwagon. You spread dung on mergle without much fundament. Then your logical fallacy: 'we have a vig that doesn't have an obligatory nightkill, if he doesn't kill he's converted'. Ain't there some PIS for you, pal? Why would the Orb make it a mandatory kill? What're you driving at, exactly?

This tally makes my teeth bleed.

Yeah, inactives are really a crap, they get a victory just for being miraculously surviving cannon fodder, or they manage to help the scum win by not voting them to death.

And Atpg, you don't have teeth. You're a droid.

He rolled a new character, silly!

 

[Zack]

Zaccino, do you still insist that BL be lynched?

I'm not insisting on it, but BL did insist I vote for him. I merely obliged.

 

[topsecret]

Orb to Zack

Also Zack, couldn't spaceman be mafia, not cultist?

 

[Zack]

That's true, I suppose we don't know for sure that there aren't any mafia left.

I think Backwards Logic, Mat93, Ravus, and spaceman would be the most likely mafia suspects, and I have no idea who the most likely cult suspects would be (hence the low-risk policy).

 

[topsecret]

I'm going to vote: Autolycus for a placeholder, until I decide whether or not to vote for spaceman...

 

[topsecret]

Alright, all we know about spaceman is that he's likely not a cultist, he has a beard, and claims to be Watto. But what if Watto isn't town? I mean, he's obviously not a nice guy in either the comic or the movie...

After thinking about it further, I'll vote: spaceman. I'm not really satisfied with this, but it's the best lead we have right now. But if spaceman is innocent, Mergle has explaining to do. Serious explaining.

 

[Zack]

But if spaceman is innocent, Mergle has explaining to do. Serious explaining.

passing the buck = lame

Take accountability for your votes and the consequences which result from it. It's not like Mergle claimed a scan result.

 

[topsecret]

IIRC, Mergle said he'd put his money where his mouth was. Maybe I took it wrong, but it seems that was an all-or-nothing accusation. And I take full responsibility for my vote.
Don't say that I won't.

 

[spaceman98]

So long. Final thoughts: We had a PG scanner, so scan Zack's PG. Also, I dissaprove of Sam and Jarrema's wagonning. I can understand the charges against me by those who believe Zack is indeed credable, but I cannot understand those two and their meaningless bandwagon. Consider scanning or vidging them (before Mergle, against whom my suspicion is weak at best) after I flip town. On Mergle: I just find it strange that he is getting almost no scrutiny for his posts, which are few, if thoughtful. I still think what he said about Luke in stormtrooper armor is PIS with no in thread foundations.

On the accusation of PIS against me:
I never said the vidge must kill. However, due to Zack's brute force policy, the vidge will be given a cult hunting target every night and will attempt to kill. If Celt is ordered to kill and does not, that means he may be cultified, or may have attacked a bletproof, in which case he would be able to explain himself and be confirmed. Thus, while Zack's policy is in place, we can best keep track of the orb.

 

[choxorn]

Day 9 Over. It should have been over 2 hours ago, really.

Tally:

Lynch:

spaceman98: 6 (Gone 3 the Celt, Mergle, Buddhafish, Jarrema, SamSniped, topsecret)
Zack: 1 (Backwards Logic)
topsecret: 1 (spaceman98)
Mat93: 1 (Ravus Sol)
Backwards Logic: 1 (Zack)

Not Voting: 2 (Mat93, Autolycus)

Orb:

Zack: 3 (Mergle, Zack, Ravus Sol)
Backwards Logic: 1 (Backwards Logic)
Gone 3 the Celt: 1 (spaceman98)

 

[choxorn]

The citizens of the planet that shall henceforth be known as "Dagobah" were mostly quiet compared to recent days, not really sure what they were doing. But then, as usual, they all started to go after one suspect. This time, it was spaceman98.

His defense was being a normal shopkeeper with a weird thing for gambling.

They still really wanted to lynch him, and so they did.

Spoiler :

spaceman98 was lynched! He was Watto! He was Town!

Players:

1. askthepizzaguy Killed Night 3, R2-D2
2. Autolycus
3. azzaman333 Killed Night 8, Owen Lars
4. Backwards Logic
5. BSmith1068 Lynched Day 4, Count Dookû
6. Buddhafish
7. CivCube Lynched Day 3, Jango Fett
8. CivGeneral Vengeful Lyncheed Day 6, Boss Nass
9. classical hero replaced by NinjaCow64 Killed Night 5, Chewbacca
10. Darth Caesar Lynched Day 6, Greedo/Han Solo
11. Dreadnought Killed Night 1, Darth Maul
12. Gone 3 The Celt
13. Jarrema
14. JoanK Killed Night 2, Beru Lars
15. johnhughthom Killed Night 8, Obi-Wan Kenobi
16. Kennigit Killed Night 5, Padme Amidala
17. Mat93
18. mechaerik Killed Night 7, Anakin Skywalker
19. Mergle
20. SamSniped
21. SouthernKing Lynched Day 5, TZ-4
22. spaceman98 Lynched Day 9, Watto
23. Takhisis Killed Night 4, Jar-Jar Binks
24. The Black Knigh Lynched Day 8, Han Solo
25. topsecret
26. traius Ravus_Sol
27. Visorslash Lynched Day 1, Nute Gunray
28. Xenoneb Lynched Day 7, General Grievous
29. Zack

Begin Night 9. It will end in: [TIMER="2/2/2013 1:00 AM PST; Night 9 Over"][/TIMER]

 

[spaceman98]

Sigh... What did I tell you. I was one of the most anti-cult roles alive too:
SO:
The planet is still here. That means that Zack is trustworthy.
Megle still feels like PIS, rolescan him.
Vidge the lurkers
Topsecret's analysis clears him of my suspicion for now