How do you think the world would have evolved if there had not been the World Wars?

taking a detour from an interesting and so far unfamiliar discussion :

P.S.: What is that goofy 'i' character you use? Is it a Cyrillic character?
we have two varieties of the letter in Turkish . ı don't refer to myself in capital letters , partly because am a failure in life , partly because have to fight off my self confidence leading to my doom . This year ı have been unlucky once or twice and my ramblings coincided with world events , as such ı am supposed to be a real deal . By all means no . Yet it doesn't stop some smarties to make dough with my name ; ı keep hearing there is a protection racket going on . Now that ı have run into people with capital letters ı can assure anybody that while r16 is harmless , say an R will make people Regret it - big time - if aRoused . ı am a perfect loser who has to remind his place continiously ; currently am a Starfleet admiral who lost seniority because ı pressed for an immediate pre-emptive anti-matter strikes on good old Uncle Sam while commanding Moon Base Alpha , only to be exiled to Saturn to handcount the rings . More fiendish a stellar punishment is yet to be invented . In short it is a CFC tradition to generally ignore me .
the Entente wasn't a full, offensive alliance
this is something ı rather will not agree . The World History Forum has just seen a debate on how the Entente enginereed the downfall of the Ottoman Empire , to steal its oil . My take on the event is that the war was inevitable because London and Paris reached an agreement to co-operate since Germany was driving forward fast yet its potential was still limited compared to what US or Russia might have done given time . Maps were to be redrawn and empire / empires to fall . Keeping the "West Europeans " ahead of the "demons" of De Tocquvelle . Relevance of oil is that the known and presumed Ottoman reserves would keep the German tanks full . In return Germans would keep the Ottoman Empire afloat . Because:
Oil was a relatively recent discovery and still being uncovered in stable trading partners like the United States.
and that stable trading partner lies across the Atlantic . Something to remember when the Royal Navy begins blockading enemies of the Crown in the European landmass . The Cash and Carry Act , the one before the Lend Lease was so charming ; the US industry would have gladly taken German orders , had the Germans have any means of overcoming the RN . The solution in WW1 would be the merchant submarine and that was just a drop in a bucket . On the other hand the one intrusion into the Sea of Marmara that far was not that bright . A halfway competent Ottoman Army and Fleet would be sufficient to keep everybody at home and , mind you , in peace .
the Germans for instance did not even start such conversions until the second two ships of the Bayern class of superdreadnoughts, neither of which was laid down until 1914
is a notion that does not make full justice to Wilhelm Der Britischer . ( My German was never good and ı practically forgot all of it ) Oil was coming of age and fast . And while Germans were blinding themselves to the fact - with their blackmail of naval parity where they intentionally remained behind in order not to be too much of a threat - , especially the British were in the La-La land . Accustomed to their safety behind the channel , they had fobias about the new ways of warmaking . Funnily enough they all got to Berlin in due time . All aircraft were banned over the city when the war began , one pilot strayed and an entire battalion of troops expanded all their rifle ammunition firing at it . When the Sikorsky bombers made their appearence over the front , German High Command simply announced there were no such giant aircraft . And of course that most Germanic of things , the tank . ı am long known to be making up stuff yet as already said my German is miserable , how do you combine Angriff with Kraftwagen ? That quaint Burstyn was for crossing trenches when all the European car makers were pushing armoured cars with tiny wheels is a mystery . Yes , the story of the tactical assault vehicle is yet to be written .
you know , it would be a steady money earner for the incredible German industry , now that AustroHungarians passed it over and would balance Russian hordes and French elan .
a typical alternate history timeline, regardless of points of divergence, always converge in the general types of events, actors, trends or concepts familiar to the author of the timeline
only to preempt any criticism . And yes , war was inevitable , now that London Paris Axis stopped Russians from too much dalliance with the Japanese , "pushed off" Americans in Morocco 1907 -am a Wikipedia reader and not ashamed of it - broke the opposition by giving Libya to Italians , all of them stuff the Germans could not . Germans could not because it was the global perception that Britain was the mostest . Then came the Balkan Wars , where the first shattered the Ottoman Empire and the second took away any advantages Germans and Austrians might have derived from an enlarged Bulgaria . In 1913 the First World War was an absolute certainity . There were doubts about the thing during the first war , about the evil Turk making a comeback a la 1897 and talks about averting a collision between the Great Powers , at the second it was obvious Ottomans were dead and our carcass better be shared . Berlin approved it all now that we would be their slaves if we wanted to live , yet Western Europeans saw the German case was "mortally" wounded and soon it would be clear . With the Russian Bear getting fatter everyday .

what if there were more loyal guards in Sarajevo ? There would have been another thing , Archiduke could have died in Vienna why not ? Before the Russian Bear got too fat , you know .

what do Germans know about alliance ? They are merely human , just like anybody else . They will stab you in the back for a single gold piece in your hand . Just recently two neo-Nazis were committed to suicide , their female element panicked and set fire to destroy the evidence and voila , the German police discovered these guys have been behind a decade long series of murders , have been planning raids on military installations , have a hitlist of 88 names to honour HH ( the eight letter so necessary to say Heil Hitler ) and so on . Meanwhile TV channels here taking about the dangers of "deep" states . Considering one of the victims was a Greek döner worker , killed by mistake and one German loony pumped 40 rounds into a Turkish supermarket immediately afterwards , we should have framed the Greeks .

resource management clashes have never resulted in war
control of oil was incentive enough for half of Libya to sally forth to topple Kaddafi and it appeared war enough . Saddam rightly accused Kuwait of stealing oil under the border thought ı will admit that it was only a peripheral reason . Argentinian junta knew it would overcome any opposition to a clash with Britain on promises of Falkland oil and ı really count my anti-Americanisms , even when the said junta was led into a blind alley . Doubles the score . And of course the Bushist Crusades , where Rice justified Afghanistan by denying a base to Islamic terrorism reminding the poppy fields which were still in the game last time ı checked and Iraq , the glorious self financing invasion . Maybe the more correct thing would be to say promise of wealth from resource is the best motivator for war ?

Spoiler :
actually "lack of oil" is a fixation of Turkish state where domestic concerns push an active foreign policy . 1990s saw many learned editorials on why the Serbs were allowed to do their thing against the Bosnians because there was no oil in Bosnia , same argument is now used in the Syrian case . Lambasting the Anglo-French for not saving the poor Syrians in the way poor Libyans were saved .Actually works for the neo-Ittihadists . Economic crisis is coming to Turkey , 460 000 people now have the opportunity to buy their way out of compulsory military service at the cost of something like 17 000 US$ and the poor will still be in Syria to kill and die .Yes , ich habe the courage to say that even when ı , too , had a paid short-term back in 2000 . And the President says it will be all rosy and nobody will be hurt if the rebels of Syria sign a paper that they will respect differences ; all opposition will evaporate . See where being soft on broken promises take you : More promises to be broken . Well , if a capital letter is around when the world orders our smarties to move , all the fatsos who wrote learned editorials for saving the great enterprise will be tied to the tanks as more civilised countries hang ERA boxes .

Why , ı have a bulging belly , too . And nobody feels threatened , one brilliant smartie just recently talked against compulsory military service by saying the first step was respecting people's right not to serve on pasifist , political and religious grounds , second step would not be a peaceful tomorrow but a fully professional army . The Armed Forces are still a political threat , that is exactly why people want them out of country . They are to be broken if possible with demoralization coming from serving and suffering while others do not , if this does not help then by fire . So that "proper" people can be brought in , servant to current smarties . They think they will remain in the graces of Westerners forever .
 
Erm, Stormont? Rhodesia? There are remarkably close cases of British conservative imperialists deciding that being loyal to the King didn't involve obeying His Majesty's Government. The mutineers would take over Dublin Castle. London would surely fudge rather than fight, e.g. sending a new pro-Union Viceroy, who would postpone Home Rule indefinitely. Then there would be a bloody civil war between Irish Nationalists and Unionists - essentially 1918 brought forward, but with London rather hoping the Nationalists win. But there would not be fighting in Great Britain, and the Empire would not collapse.*
So they'd establish Home Rule in the name of Union? :huh:
 
I think this calls for an althis timeline...

June 28, 1914
Sarajevo, Bosnia-Herzegovina

Gavrilo Princip choked on a sandwich outside Moritz Schiller's cafe...

(to be continued)

Hilariously, Princip was not a part of the original assassination attempt; his involvement was purely coincidental. If you want to really throw a spanner in the works, you'd have to do something about Nedeljko Čabrinović, or the driver who took a wrong turn.

Of course, this was only one of several assassination attempts. WWI was basically inevitable.
 
God I wish people would stop saying that WWI was inevitable. It wasn't. Not even slightly. It was based on an astonishing coincident of events which was highly unlikely to be repeated.
 
The people who think WWI was inevitable tends to be the same people who think WWII could've been easily prevented if only Versailles was less harsh/racial equality was adopted/Chamberlain had balls.
 
The people who think WWI was inevitable tends to be the same people who think WWII could've been easily prevented if only Versailles was less harsh/racial equality was adopted/Chamberlain had balls.
I haven't noticed that. But, funnily enough, Chamberlain having balls may well have ended the war before it began. It was the French having balls that was the bigger issue, however.
 
God I wish people would stop saying that WWI was inevitable. It wasn't. Not even slightly. It was based on an astonishing coincident of events which was highly unlikely to be repeated.

Sooner or later, someone in Serbia would have assassinated a member of the Austrian royal family. You'd basically have to wipe Wilhelm II from history, thus rearranging the web of alliances in Europe, in order to prevent WWI.
 
Sooner or later, someone in Serbia would have assassinated a member of the Austrian royal family. You'd basically have to wipe Wilhelm II from history, thus rearranging the web of alliances in Europe, in order to prevent WWI.

Britain needing an excuse to weasel out of the Home Rule Crisis had a helluva lot more to do with the start of WWI than the "Austrian royal family", whatever that means.
 
Sooner or later, someone in Serbia would have assassinated a member of the Austrian royal family.
Why?
G-Max said:
You'd basically have to wipe Wilhelm II from history, thus rearranging the web of alliances in Europe, in order to prevent WWI.
Dammit, and I already used "ah yes, [historical fallacy]...we have dismissed that claim" in another thread a few minutes ago.
 
hmm... interesting stuff, what if there was no ww2...

1. there would have been 5 million Jews, if there wasn't no holocaust.
2. there would have been 200,00 Japs, if there was't no atom bombs.
3. world wouldn't have known of the brilliant strategist Erwin "Desert Fox" Rommel.
4. there would have been 60 million more people... that's the number of people who died in ww2.

yes there were losses.
but to be honestly selfish, without ww2, my country India, would not have been free. We aided "Great" Britain by supplying troops, food, machine parts (most of it forcefully taken) and they gave us freedom, not before severely crippling the communal harmony of the region though...

if there wasn't no Ww2, the damn old lady would still be ruling over the subcontinent .. . .
 
We aided "Great" Britain ... and they gave us freedom, not before severely crippling the communal harmony of the region though...

Come again?
 
Come again?

Probably referring to The Partition.

but to be honestly selfish, without ww2, my country India, would not have been free. We aided "Great" Britain by supplying troops, food, machine parts (most of it forcefully taken) and they gave us freedom, not before severely crippling the communal harmony of the region though...

British rule was becoming increasingly untenable in the lead up to the Second World War, anyway. The War accelerated independence (not because of any British gratitude for Indian assistance during the War, for that matter). This isn't a good thing in itself, either; absent war, a more gradual and peaceful transition might have been possible.
 
wW1 was inevitable , and once brilliance took hold again so was WW2 , Versailles was harsh , though maybe not as harsh as Sevres . Wars actually do not start out of accidents but designs ; it is designs that allow the accidents . That's how the entire theory of deterrence kinda works . When you press on the opposition feels there is something they haven't yet noticed .
 
Probably referring to The Partition.
Yes it was the partition that i was referring to ... dividing the community along the lines of religion. Anyways, the Empire was all ways known to employ "Divide and Rule" pretty efficiently.

British rule was becoming increasingly untenable in the lead up to the Second World War, anyway. The War accelerated independence (not because of any British gratitude for Indian assistance during the War, for that matter). This isn't a good thing in itself, either; absent war, a more gradual and peaceful transition might have been possible.
I am pretty sure, if there wasn't no war, there wouldn't have been any independence either. They would still be ruling over us, until some one git frustrated and led a coup. Thanks to our 'great' leaders, we never even got a chance to fight the oppressors. we are so damn peace loving, it makes me sick at times.

Heck, even our minuscule neighbor, Bangladesh, can boast of snatching away freedom from the hands of the oppressors. We can't.
 
but wasn't it the Indian military force that decided the Bangladesh case ? This is not denying Pakistan failed big time in ruling the Eastern part .
 
Heck, even our minuscule neighbor, Bangladesh, can boast of snatching away freedom from the hands of the oppressors. We can't.

If it makes you feel any better, the Bangladeshi War of Independence was essentially won by the Republic of India after the Bengalis got genocided by the Pakistani Army.
 
Sooner or later, someone in Serbia would have assassinated a member of the Austrian royal family.
Why? There exists more emnity between, say, India and Pakistan than existed between Austria and Serbia. Yet, no Pakistani has ever assassinated the Indian President.

You'd basically have to wipe Wilhelm II from history, thus rearranging the web of alliances in Europe, in order to prevent WWI.
The alliances that were so binding that Italy joined the other side? And the monarch who had no control over his own nation and who tried to actively rein in the generals who pushed him into war? Wilhelm II had about as much influence on WWI as Elizabeth II has on the Iraq War.

I am pretty sure, if there wasn't no war, there wouldn't have been any independence either.
Britain could no longer sustain the economic burden required by pacifying India through force, and the native elites were no longer willing to assist it in ruling by proxy. India's independence was inevitable by 1939. The war may well have contributed to the partition, which was unlikely in 1939, but it did not contribute to independence in any great measure. It changed the timetable and likely increased the violence, nothing more.

They would still be ruling over us, until some one git frustrated and led a coup.
How would that NOT be independence?

Thanks to our 'great' leaders, we never even got a chance to fight the oppressors. we are so damn peace loving, it makes me sick at times.
Tell that to Portugal and Sikkim.

Heck, even our minuscule neighbor, Bangladesh, can boast of snatching away freedom from the hands of the oppressors. We can't.
You snatched it and gave it to them.
 
Yes it was the partition that i was referring to ... dividing the community along the lines of religion. Anyways, the Empire was all ways known to employ "Divide and Rule" pretty efficiently.
You mean the partition that was demanded by Indians?
The idea that India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh would have been one big happy family if only the British hadn't forced the partition on them is simply ludicrous.
 
Back
Top Bottom