Here is my desired rules for combat, if people feel this is too complicated please say so:
Combat Part 1: Unit movement
For every army you need to enter a set of orders, which need to last 5 phases.
The orders:
Combat Readiness:
1) Passive: Passive increases moral overtime, however cannot engage in combat. Passive requires 25% of the supplies of active. Passive units will not be shown on the map (but will be recorded off map).
2) Garrison: Garrison can increase the defence of a specific territory, they can only defend. Garrison mode increases moral over time, but at half the rate of passive. Garrison requires 50% of the supplies of active.
3) Active: Active units lose moral over time, but can actively attack enemies.
Passive and Garrisoned units require no further orders. However If Active then there are 4 combat types they can use:
Siege: Slowly occupy a territory.
Assault: Faster then siege, but at the cost of moral and strength.
Engage: If possible, attack nearby enemy units.
Defend: Acts like a garrison unit, except it can transition to offence more easily.
To give orders indicate where you want the unit to move and what type of combat that will be conducting.
Below is an example of entering orders. We are playing the Arab Empire (Green) and fighting a war against American Empire (red).
We have 5 armies, 1st army is garrisoned in Najran (represented by 1g), 5th is garrisoned in Kufah (5g), 2nd is active in Baghdad (2a), and 3rd is active in Najran (3a). 4th army is passive, and thus not shown on the map.
The enemy has 4 armies, 2 in Phily and 2 in Boston. 1 active 1 garrisoned in both.
In actual gameplay, cities wont be named on the map as such, however they have been added for this tutorial as that will make it easier to explain what each unit is doing.
1st army is garrisoned at Najran. (Indicated by 1g) He will remain there for the rest of the round (since 1 has no other orders, it is assumed)
3rd army is to attack an army in boston (indicated by 3 a e, a indicates this is his first objective, e indicates he is engaging). Once boston is free of enemy armies, he will move to DC where he will lay siege (indicated by 3 b s, b indicates this is his second objective, s represents its a seige). Once the siege is complete, he will then go to New York to engage potential enemies.
4th army is currently passive, he upgrades his readyness from passive to garrison (Since he was passive, he is moved to our capital, Mecca) and then active. Now ready for combat he moves out first moving to Damascus, gaining double movement thanks to the roads connecting the two provinces and then moves to Baghdad to engage potential enemies. Finally he moves to Atlanta where he lays seige.
2nd army is currently in baghdad, now because baghdad has an important strategic resource, before moving out, 2nd army wants to wait for reinforcements, in this case 4th army. (Indicated by 2 a d, a indicated this is his objective for phase a, and the d indicating defense. Since he has no orders for phase b or phase c, he will remain on defense until phase d). Afterwards he will move to Philadelphia where supported by 5th army (indicated by the 2+5), will engage nearby enemy units. Following that he will lay siege to Phily.
5th army is garrisoned in Kufah, he switches to active in phase c, supports 2nd army in an attrack on Philadelphia, before moving to Chicago to lay siege.
Americas orders:
See if you can make our Americas orders without detailed explination. Just to see if you understand combat.
Combat results:
Phase A
Arabian 3rd army and American 4th army engage on the Boston-Najran border. (keep in mind I haven't provided any details about the combat strength of each unit, but I would provide those numbers to human players. I will detail that in Combat Part 2).
In this case, the American 4th army is victorious. Normally the Arabian army would be forced to retreat, but in this case it was such a crushing defeat, that the Arabian 3rd has routed and forced to become a passive army while it regroups.
No other battles this phase:
Phase B
4th army arrives in Najran and assaults the city. The Garrison in Najran emerges victorious and the 4th army is forced to retreat. It retreats backwards 2 territories into DC.
Phase C
4th and 3rd American armies where meant to attack Baghdad together, but the 4th army is no longer in position.
Since the 4th army was the primary attacker (indicated by the number being first), the order is cancelled.
Since it was an engage order, the unit looks for active enemy units nearby. The only one is the Arab 2nd army stationed in Baghdad. However this army vastly outnumbers American 3rd army. As a result the general (automated) chooses not to engage.
Phase D:
2nd and 5th army attack 3rd army in Philadelphia. Since there is a garrisoned unit in Philly, the general can chose to support the defence, or hide behind Philadelphia's walls.
The general decides the best case of action is to assist the defending army. 2nd army, with 5th supporting it, attacks 3rd army, with 1st supporting it.
3rd army is completely wiped out in the battle, while the 1st army retreats. Since its a garrisoned unit, it retreats behind the walls of Philadelphia.
Phase E:
No battles. Atlanta, Philadelphia and Chicago are seiged by Arabia. However none of the sieges are over at the end of the round.
At the end of the round, here is what the map looks like
Notice how the Arab armies that are in American land are Green, to make it easier to see the difference between them and the American ones.
This is the end of the first round of the war between Arabia and America.