Murky
Deity
It's a descent game but I don't put much stock in online game reviews.
You do know what stress relief is right?
Pissing off devout fans of the series like you by spilling dat truth will always be amusing, despite this game being terrible.
Nothing more fun then popping bubbles.
And as Aristos said, there have to be some people to make sure the same mistakes are not made again come CiVI, considering the rant thread is too long to read in a single sitting and the rave thread is about 5 pages I'd say we're doing a pretty good job on this forum at least.
Originally Posted by Kotaku
The legendary real-time strategy series changed things up significantly with Civilization V to make would-be world domination tons more streamlined. Maps are easier to navigate, crucial information flows easier and it's the best-looking entry in the family tree.
A Good Match for: Event planners. Like a wedding or a milestone birthday party, Civilization V's all about knowing your guests and what they need to have a good time. Of course, those "guests" are rival nations and "a good time" is submitting to the power of your empire.
Not for Those Who Want: Older Civ games. Civilization V is no incremental sequel, and the difference could alienate die-hard fans of the historical franchise.
Kotaku said:This means nothing. This is the worst review site I have ever seen. Is this even serious list at this point? They should feel horrible and the sponsors of this site should immediately withdraw their funding.
Conformism is the sure path to mediocrity.
in order to (and I reckon this might be empty hopes) create some sort of "pressure" to "force" reconsideration for the next iteration...
zevel said:Please please please, stop with rant posts. Just because you have issues with the current itteration of the franchise doesnt mean you have to be bitter about it on its dedicated discussion board. It helps no one, its counter productive, and it lights the whole community in a bad light. Think about the potential new members, the random un-educated player coming here to find new information, and has to browse through negative comments about how this game ruined the franchise.
Just because it has a lot of views doesn't mean it automaticalyl deserves respect. Fox News is a major news organization in the USA with millions of viewers, and it is still mediocre at best most of the time. Gawker is a pretty scummy company, they've had some shady deals before and their security was non-existent.Kotaku is one of the biggest gaming sites around, its part of the gawker family, and has more then tens of thousand page views a day (a non educated guess by myself, feel free to point me wrong). There are bigger sites like IGN and Gamespot, but give it the respect it deserves.
Correction, if you are into reading articles by people who actually do a good job most of the time and really care about their work.If you are into PC title, check RPS. And btw, the "otaku" thing references nerdy obsession, not only related to Japanese anime or manga.
While you have a point that doesn't excuse the fact they made that mistake in the first place. It is a pretty major error and reflects upon the low quality of the website.1. Yeah, they called it a real-time strategy game and its a shallow review coming from a website most of you aren't familiar with and we all like to hate. But, this is something we should all celebrate here instead of dismising cause the writer had a few mistakes in. This article has the potential to bring in new players, or spark the fire with players that stoped playing. This article is good for the game, the community and this very website. If a random gamer sees this article, sees the game is listed as one of the best PC games around and goes on to buy it of steam, its a win for all of us. If you cant see that, you're just selfish.
I was on killing spree aiming at all the haters here, knowingly risking a ban, but most of that got shot down by the mods, only one comment went through. So im gonna go out of character and be nice here.
Zevel, Otaku does refer to just japanese obsessions, the term is only commonly used in Japan to refer to the anime/manga afficianado's, and in other countries it is used in the same way but only by Japanophile's (or more commonly known as weaboo's).
Ergo this site has no relevance to this kind of review, it'd be just as relevant if I linked a CiV review from Equiestriadaily.
And I will second that Gawker are a bunch of hacks, they do want the big advertising bucks but don't care about their customers private information being easily accesible in plaintext for a scriptkiddie.
On to the numerals:
1: It's a terrible review made by someone who doesn't know anything about the franchise to the extent that they couldn't even get the name of the genre right, if your reviews are bad, your a bad review site.
This is the same as a bicycle magazine giving a stellar review of a Fiat Panda, they have no proper framework to judge any part of it, and their love for a mediocre to bad car makes their opinions seem invalid and garners hate from anyone who has knowledge about cars in general.
2: What would really be counterproductive is peope abandoning their ranting, it would give the devs the impression they actually did a good job and don't need to fundamentally change the game.
For a complacent person like you there is no use for the ranting because you don't need any real changes, for us there is.
Stating that there is no reason for us to rant without bothering to look at it from our perspective is a bit weird.
And those new poeple that are comming to this site, considering how many ranters there are I would say that a good amount of those people might be looking for rants and people who agree with their frustrations, much like I, and I'm sure many before and after me did.
And I find the "there will be more DLC and expansions" comment absolutely hilarious, the studio's have said nothing to the effect and they've been (and are still) busy on other games like FaceCiv and X-Com, and until now all the DLC's have been tiny and overpriced, put together new leader, couple maps, done.
And I find the "there will be more DLC and expansions" comment absolutely hilarious