Police Probe Pair Per Phony Pirate Porn Privacy Plunder

Zelig

Beep Boop
Joined
Jul 8, 2002
Messages
17,419
Location
Canada
Earlier this year, malware which purported to be an erotic PC game punished file-sharers who believed they were downloading the real thing. Instead of endless hours of digital titillation, unlucky pirates had their personal details published on the Internet and had to pay a fee to have them removed. Now police have arrested two men in connection with this unusual fraud.

After seemingly endless delays, the pervy PC title Cross Days from developer 0verflow was finally released.

A fake version of the game was widely available on file-sharing networks, but when installed it punished the would-be pirates. After gathering highly personal information from the victim’s computer, accompanied by a screenshot of his or her desktop and what they were doing at the time, the malware uploaded the whole lot to a public website.

It was possible to have the stuff taken down, but at a price. Not only would the victim have to apologize for downloading the ‘game’ for free, but they would also have to pay money to their tormentors.

But, as they say, what goes around, comes around.

According to a Japanese media report, this week two men were arrested on suspicion of creating the Cross Days malware and using it to extort money from victims.

Kenzo Oka, 27, of Tokyo, and an unnamed second man, 20, were arrested earlier this month on suspicion of defrauding several people out payments of around $64 each to have their personal details removed from the website.

While writing computer viruses isn’t a crime in Japan, extorting cash with them is. The pair become the first to be arrested in the country while using a virus as a tool to commit fraud.

http://torrentfreak.com/police-probe-pair-over-phony-pirate-porn-privacy-plunder-100530/

Did the pirates having their personal details published deserve what they got?

What would you do in that situation?

What's a suitable punishments for a) the pirates, b) the makers of the malware and c) the type of people who would buy this game in the first place?

Should virus writing be a crime even if you don't extort cash with them?

After reading this, are you more likely to try the game out? Are you less likely to pirate it?
 
Yes, virus writing should be a crime it's malicious damage to property.

Punishments:

a) whipping followed execution
b) poking with a stick followed by execution
c) a strong ticking off followed by execution
 
These guys are geniuses and should be released immediately, and even given financial help to widen their scheme. Pirates deserve no protection. Developers can work for months (maybe years) on producing games, and its disgusting that people think they're entitled to the results for free.
 
What No Navy SEALs Sniper head shots ?
 
These guys are geniuses and should be released immediately, and even given financial help to widen their scheme. Pirates deserve no protection. Developers can work for months (maybe years) on producing games, and its disgusting that people think they're entitled to the results for free.
So, do you pay for your porn?
 
:raisedeyebrow:
 
These guys are geniuses and should be released immediately, and even given financial help to widen their scheme. Pirates deserve no protection. Developers can work for months (maybe years) on producing games, and its disgusting that people think they're entitled to the results for free.

Because the guys surely did it to help the poor game developers and not at all for lower motives, right?

Even if your criminal activities primarily target other criminals, it still doesn't justify your actions. Especially, since I think the crime these guys committed (computer sabotage, blackmail/extortion) are quite a bit more severe than those of the game pirates.
 
I don't like viruses, but I would have had sympathy for the guys if they hadn't demanded money.
 
Astoundingly amazing alliteration. But anyway...

Did the pirates having their personal details published deserve what they got?
No. The punishment does not fit the crime.

What's a suitable punishments for a) the pirates, b) the makers of the malware and c) the type of people who would buy this game in the first place?
A fine, I guess. Whatever the punishment for identity theft is (I'm thinking jailtime or a hefty fine). Unless they commit a crime, then nothing.

Should virus writing be a crime even if you don't extort cash with them?
Yes, especially if it causes damage.

After reading this, are you more likely to try the game out? Are you less likely to pirate it?
Violence is my gaming vice, not sex.
 
I read the title...

I lolled... :lol:

Seriously, It is kinda hard to pick, since planting a virus is a crime, but pirating files it too. But what did they do to not get in trouble... Nothing!!! What did they do to get in trouble... They planted a Virus!!!
 
Because the guys surely did it to help the poor game developers and not at all for lower motives, right?

Even if your criminal activities primarily target other criminals, it still doesn't justify your actions. Especially, since I think the crime these guys committed (computer sabotage, blackmail/extortion) are quite a bit more severe than those of the game pirates.
Potential taking of someone's property is worse than actual taking of someone's property?
 
Potential taking of someone's property is worse than actual taking of someone's property?
well you're the lawyer but in this case I'd say the usual punishment for the extortion would be higher than the punishment for the theft, so (at least in Switzerland) the law seems to agree with me :)

ok, 'quite a bit' was a bit of an overstatement :)
 
Back
Top Bottom