Possible coup in Turkey

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't know, there's something odd with that explanation (the one from australia). I just can't believe Gulen didn't knew. And if he had a hand in it, so did his hosts.

And it fits: the kemalists are nationalist: once informed about who was conducting the coup, they refused to be baited into joining it. That was the gamble by the planners of this coup, that failed.

r16's rants have more to it than being just rants...
 
Erdoğan announced State of Emergency in whole country for three months. This gives almost unlimited power to governors (whom are appointed by interior ministry not elected) and government.
Just read that and was coming to post it. Very disturbing.

I meant to multi-quote you first comment to me as well. Somehow missed doing so. DFAT is all over the place in their predictions right now, especially since much of the staff is busy dealing with the fallout from Brexit and the South China Sea. The best they can come up with is a coin toss. Most of the more accurate prognosticators among my contacts - the people who, like me, predicted things like the Leave vote winning in the UK and Trump becoming the Republican nominee - think the coup is still on, and Erdogan is clamping down ever more tightly with this state of emergency in a desperate attempt to retain power. He's also offering to let the Kemalists loose on the Kurds and/or ISIL, and making contradictory promises to different cliques in the military.

At the moment it seems that he's retaining power for two reasons. The military hates the Gulenists more than they hate him, and the military is divided about what exactly to do if they replace him. Erdogan has done such a good job of destroying the opposition in Turkey that there really aren't any civilians capable of taking the reins, and the military doesn't want a dictatorship. That was one thing the Gulenists had over the Kemalists; a suitable figurehead. Yildirum and even Gul, the previous Prime Minister, are apparently being sounded out, but neither are willing to commit; probably scared of being included in Erdogan's round-up. Right now, I would put my money on Gul leading a coalition 'Government of National Unity' if a coup took place, but it's a very confusing situation.

This sounds like a someone turning a republic into a dictatorship.
Because it is. Erdogan's long-term goal has always been to install himself as a dictator - he is known to speak admiringly of Vladimir Putin to foreigners - and he has been nearing that goal for some time. That's a major reason the two separate coups have been planned; to keep him from becoming an Islamist dictator in the Khomeini vein, which seems to be his goal. If he was a militarist dictator like Saddam Hussein, I doubt the Kemalists would have a problem with him.

Makes me think about this famous exchange:
You're not the only one who has thought so. Those 14 ships are being dubbed "the Rebel Fleet" by DFAT. The Admiral in charge has been nick-named "Ackbar" by the same people.

Another version from Iranian media - Erdogan was warned about coup by Russian military intelligence, which was eavesdropping Turkish military communications.
http://en.farsnews.com/newstext.aspx?nn=13950430001452
My sources say the Russians and Iranians both knew about the coup, but don't know if they tipped off Erdogan. The Chinese also seem to have known; they withdrew a LOT of their cash from the country in the hours before the coup. It's being kept quiet to avoid any conspiracy theories about Chinese involvement, but they seem to have begun withdrawing capital 8 hours before the attempt on Erdogan.

I don't know, there's something odd with that explanation (the one from australia). I just can't believe Gulen didn't knew. And if he had a hand in it, so did his hosts.

And it fits: the kemalists are nationalist: once informed about who was conducting the coup, they refused to be baited into joining it. That was the gamble by the planners of this coup, that failed.

r16's rants have more to it than being just rants...
Unfortunately I couldn't make heads nor tails of that rant. It hurt my eyes, and I just couldn't read it.

The Americans didn't know. DFAT is certain of that, and given Australia's heavy infiltration of the US intelligence services - and their requisite infiltration of ours - my contacts would know if they did. It came as a complete shock to them. They knew about the Kemalist coup plans, but not the Gulenist plot. Gulen's communications are strictly monitored by the Americans; not necessarily for espionage, but mostly because they don't want Erdogan doing to Gulen what Stalin did to Trotsky. If he knew, they would know.

Gulen was apparently completely in the dark and was asking the Americans for updates. While Gulen certainly has his own underground in Turkey, the coup-plotters didn't share their plans with it, or with him. It's highly probable that the original intent was to tell Gulen before the coup took place, but the need to rush changed that plan. DFAT seems to think that one of the plotters had booked a plane trip to the US, via Germany, later this month, ostensibly to visit relatives there. It wouldn't take much to get a message to Gulen while there.

My contacts are getting unconfirmed reports that Gulen has been in contact with the plotters since the coup failed, FWIW. He's apparently absolutely furious with them for botching it, as well as for launching it in the first place. Gulen seemingly wanted the Kemalists to launch their coup, then return to Turkey and become the President-in-waiting as the figurehead of a popular democratic movement. That is, incidentally, a much better plan than anything these conspirators came up with, and something Gulen would probably be really good at. He's not the coup-type, IMO.
 
You're not the only one who has thought so. Those 14 ships are being dubbed "the Rebel Fleet" by DFAT. The Admiral in charge has been nick-named "Ackbar" by the same people.

There are reports around that ships are hanging out with a NATO fleet involved in an exercise in the Black sea. Wherever they are I'm sure their location is known to all governments of nations with spy satellites, strange that we have not been hearing much about it.

Unfortunately I couldn't make heads nor tails of that rant. It hurt my eyes, and I just couldn't read it.

We're used to his style.

The Americans didn't know. DFAT is certain of that, and given Australia's heavy infiltration of the US intelligence services - and their requisite infiltration of ours - my contacts would know if they did. It came as a complete shock to them. They knew about the Kemalist coup plans, but not the Gulenist plot. Gulen's communications are strictly monitored by the Americans; not necessarily for espionage, but mostly because they don't want Erdogan doing to Gulen what Stalin did to Trotsky. If he knew, they would know.

And we have your word for it. Thanks, I guess. It certainly is helpful that a neat narrative about a coup related to an ongoing political crisis situation should be provided by an intelligence agency.

But there are still many events left to explain. Why has the US government been protected Gulen? Where did his money come from? How has he managed to create such a widespread "sect"?
And how come the iranians, russians, and even the chinese knew about the plot in advance, but US intelligence, better placed to have contacts among all players in Turkey, did not? And, not directly related to this but of a more general nature, how unified is the US "deep state"? If it is anything like Turkey, one hand may be playing against the other.

My contacts are getting unconfirmed reports that Gulen has been in contact with the plotters since the coup failed, FWIW. He's apparently absolutely furious with them for botching it, as well as for launching it in the first place. Gulen seemingly wanted the Kemalists to launch their coup, then return to Turkey and become the President-in-waiting as the figurehead of a popular democratic movement. That is, incidentally, a much better plan than anything these conspirators came up with, and something Gulen would probably be really good at. He's not the coup-type, IMO.

That would now seem to be a better plan. But the plan that was actually carried out could have succeeded in creating a power void temporarily managed by a "gulenist" junta, if only Erdogan had been killed. With the "kemalist military" caught by surprise, a quick "need to return to democratic processors" could be invoked to put Gulen in power before the rest of the military could organize to propose a different government.
Whereas the plan that you describe would have required taking over a military regime already controlled by an anti-religious and nationalist military, with a plan for a future government that didn't include Gulen. I'm not saying it's impossible, I'm saying it would be less likely to succeed.
 
I can't believe even the biggest of idiots could ever take this seriously, but apparently Erdogan is blaming the downing of that Russian plane on the coup plotters. He just arrested the pilots that did it.
 
@Pundit: Do you have anything to corroborate what you are saying? Because if we take what you say at face value, I'm pretty sure you are leaking classified information which I'm also sure is a big no-no. Especially since you claim to be a government employee. With that being the case, I doubt someone in your position would seriously risk losing your job and facing prison time just to post some info on an internet forum.

I also doubt that your "sources" in DFAT would risk telling you classified information that is coming from your intelligence services since they would also get in quite a lot of trouble. More so than you would, in fact. So you'll have to forgive my skepticism, but the risk you are taking to post this stuff, and the risk your "sources" are taking telling you this stuff just doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

Plus, a lot of the stuff you are posting I am seeing on other, more obscure conspiracy-theorist type sites, so what assurances do we have that you aren't just getting your info from them and posting it here, while pretending it is coming from DFAT? Again, sorry for the skepticism, but your story about where you are getting your info just doesn't make sense and I don't think it's unreasonable to ask for some proof that what you are saying is legit before we all continue basing this discussion on your info.
 
@Pundit: Do you have anything to corroborate what you are saying? Because if we take what you say at face value, I'm pretty sure you are leaking classified information which I'm also sure is a big no-no. Especially since you claim to be a government employee. With that being the case, I doubt someone in your position would seriously risk losing your job and facing prison time just to post some info on an internet forum.

I also doubt that your "sources" in DFAT would risk telling you classified information that is coming from your intelligence services since they would also get in quite a lot of trouble. More so than you would, in fact. So you'll have to forgive my skepticism, but the risk you are taking to post this stuff, and the risk your "sources" are taking telling you this stuff just doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

Plus, a lot of the stuff you are posting I am seeing on other, more obscure conspiracy-theorist type sites, so what assurances do we have that you aren't just getting your info from them and posting it here, while pretending it is coming from DFAT? Again, sorry for the skepticism, but your story about where you are getting your info just doesn't make sense and I don't think it's unreasonable to ask for some proof that what you are saying is legit before we all continue basing this discussion on your info.
Nothing I'm saying is classified, and I'm not getting actual news anywhere except the Guardian and ABC 24. Some of the wilder conspiracies I've just read after a quick Google upon reading your post, involve false flag operations, the US funding Gulen, the Russians funding Erdogan, so-on and so-forth. I don't buy any of them.

The information is from DFAT, not ASIO. In other words, diplomatic channels, not intelligence ones. Doubtless DFAT is getting the info from intelligence sources - they have flat-out told me as much - but anything I'm being told is not secret, simply not all that widespread. Most Australian news services stopped caring about the coup the second it failed. My employment has nothing to do with DFAT itself; I work for the Department of Agriculture ATM. If you look at my posts on the Australian election, I think you'll see I have some inside information, but not any secret information. I simply know people who know a lot more than me, and occasionally tell me things.

@innonimatu: Good point about hindsight making the reported plan seem better. I don't make a habit of planning coups.

The US isn't so much protecting Gulen as simply being stuck with him. He showed up there after Erdogan turned on him in 2013, and as a private citizen with absolutely nothing illegal on him they can't force him to leave. I understand he has been "encouraged" to head to Europe on more than one occasion, but he has a strong following amongst Turkish emigres in the US, so he is more comfortable there. He is also a relatively moderate Muslim voice, which likely makes the US feel somewhat favourable towards him.

His money comes from his sect, and the reason his sect is so large is because he's spent at least two decades building it. He's been suspected of planning government takeovers before, and was once a close ally of Erdogan; they have the same goal of ending Turkish secularism, they simply differ on what they want to change it to.

As for how the US missed it, I have absolutely no idea. The more information that leaks out, the more confusing that becomes. Greece missed it too, and they're right next door. The fact that it was a rush job might explain it, but it would hardly be the first big intelligence stuff-up America has made. The interesting question, to me, is why Turkey is promoting the coup as being conducted mostly by the Air Force, when it seems to be the navy that was the root.
 
The Americans didn't know. DFAT is certain of that, and given Australia's heavy infiltration of the US intelligence services - and their requisite infiltration of ours - my contacts would know if they did. It came as a complete shock to them. They knew about the Kemalist coup plans, but not the Gulenist plot. Gulen's communications are strictly monitored by the Americans; not necessarily for espionage, but mostly because they don't want Erdogan doing to Gulen what Stalin did to Trotsky. If he knew, they would know.
I don't believe that US did not know. Maybe they contained it but no one (unless they're anti-US like failed march 9 coup attempt in 1971) is stupid enough to attempt a coup in Turkey without some kind of endorsement, or at least permission.

The US isn't so much protecting Gulen as simply being stuck with him. He showed up there after Erdogan turned on him in 2013, and as a private citizen with absolutely nothing illegal on him they can't force him to leave. I understand he has been "encouraged" to head to Europe on more than one occasion, but he has a strong following amongst Turkish emigres in the US, so he is more comfortable there.
I don't think this is true either. It may be true that US "encouraged" him to go to Europe but, i don't buy that US is not supporting him and only thing causes that US letting him stay is legality.
His movement opened charter schools all across US and many countries under US sphere of influence. He has been pro-US almost all his life. He is one of the founders of local branch of "Struggle against communism foundation" in 1950's.
He is also a relatively moderate Muslim voice, which likely makes the US feel somewhat favourable towards him.
he's nowhere near "moderate" (I hate this word on this context but this is another debate). His organisation is one of the most radical and fanatical organisations operating Turkey. Actually Erdoğan's movement is much more "moderate" than Gülen movement religiously. If your reference is likes of IS or Al-Qaeda then yes he could be called "moderate".
His money comes from his sect, and the reason his sect is so large is because he's spent at least two decades half a century building it.
fixed :D

Please keep these posts coming it is nice to have an insight from a diplomatic perspective.

On a side note my gut is telling kemalist will attempt a coup this weekend if they see an opening. I have no info or evidence on this, just a feeling. But i don't think they'll act if there's any chance of failure. I give it a 10% chance to happen.
 
I don't believe that US did not know. Maybe they contained it but no one (unless they're anti-US like failed march 9 coup attempt in 1971) is stupid enough to attempt a coup in Turkey without some kind of endorsement, or at least permission.

I don't think this is true either. It may be true that US "encouraged" him to go to Europe but, i don't buy that US is not supporting him and only thing causes that US letting him stay is legality.
His movement opened charter schools all across US and many countries under US sphere of influence. He has been pro-US almost all his life. He is one of the founders of local branch of "Struggle against communism foundation" in 1950's.
he's nowhere near "moderate" (I hate this word on this context but this is another debate). His organisation is one of the most radical and fanatical organisations operating Turkey. Actually Erdoğan's movement is much more "moderate" than Gülen movement religiously. If your reference is likes of IS or Al-Qaeda then yes he could be called "moderate".

fixed :D

Please keep these posts coming it is nice to have an insight from a diplomatic perspective.

On a side note my gut is telling kemalist will attempt a coup this weekend if they see an opening. I have no info or evidence on this, just a feeling. But i don't think they'll act if there's any chance of failure. I give it a 10% chance to happen.
I tend to agree with you on the US, the more I think about it. They probably contained the information tightly, but if the plotters weren't even in contact with Gulen himself - and this coup attempt was ridiculously amateurish, so I believe that - it's conceivable that the US completely missed it, or discounted it.

It's more than just legality. It's largely that they have no reason to get rid of him. The US isn't exactly fond of Erdogan, and Gulen is a likely replacement somewhere down the line. Better to have him continue his pro-US stance than to search elsewhere for a patron. He's occasionally embarrassing to have around, like right now, but otherwise he doesn't actually do anything to hurt the US, and keeping him around gives the US a big stick to beat Erdogan with if they need one.

Gulen is not as radical as Turkish media portrays, according to everything I hear. His view of Islam is certainly unique, I'll grant that, but he seems far less interested in destroying secularism than Erdogan himself. Gulen strikes me as far more similar to European Christian parties than Erdogan himself, though the latter is often compared to them. Erdogan is far more similar to Putin, IMO, whereas Erdogan is more of a Sarkozy. Still not exactly Abraham Lincoln, but better than the alternative.

My gut tells me a coup will either happen in the next fortnight, or not at all. Erdogan is scrambling to put all opposition to the sword. He'll either succeed quickly, or fail quickly. I don't believe he can afford to back down and take his time right now, which means potential coup plotters can't do so either. He's in trouble, especially if Admiral Kosele ("Ackbar") returns with those ships and lends them to a Kemalist coup. That might be Kosele's only escape route now, as Erdogan will probably have him killed. That's not from my friends, that's just my own reading. The situation is very, very confused though.
 
Gulen is not as radical as Turkish media portrays, according to everything I hear. His view of Islam is certainly unique, I'll grant that, but he seems far less interested in destroying secularism than Erdogan himself. Gulen strikes me as far more similar to European Christian parties than Erdogan himself, though the latter is often compared to them. Erdogan is far more similar to Putin, IMO, whereas Erdogan is more of a Sarkozy. Still not exactly Abraham Lincoln, but better than the alternative.

religious texts (Risale-i Nur) his movement based on are much more radical than normally Erdoğan's movement -at least openly- defends. And all gülenists i know are much more radical than ordinary Erdoğan supporter.


My gut tells me a coup will either happen in the next fortnight, or not at all. Erdogan is scrambling to put all opposition to the sword. He'll either succeed quickly, or fail quickly. I don't believe he can afford to back down and take his time right now, which means potential coup plotters can't do so either. He's in trouble, especially if Admiral Kosele ("Ackbar") returns with those ships and lends them to a Kemalist coup. That might be Kosele's only escape route now, as Erdogan will probably have him killed. That's not from my friends, that's just my own reading. The situation is very, very confused though.
If a there isn't a coup in a couple of weeks then we won't have one for couple of months but wouldn't say not at all. As once -AFAIK- İsmet İnönü (2nd president of Turkey.) said "Turkish military is such a place, when commanders are planning a coup, their aides plan another coup in next room."
 
I can't believe even the biggest of idiots could ever take this seriously, but apparently Erdogan is blaming the downing of that Russian plane on the coup plotters. He just arrested the pilots that did it.
From what I read he didn't say downing was somehow related to the coup, just claimed that the pilots in question also participated in the coup and were arrested for that. That's kind of irrelevant to the relations with Russia, since Russia's demands were to punish people responsible for the downing, not the pilots.
 
He was, directly or indirectly.
And while he is in power, Russia-Turkey relations will not restore to normal.
 
Funny how we talk about how Erdogan controls everything. He is suposed to be the president of a parliamentary republic. He should be a figurehead and be as visible as as the president of Germany Joachim Gauck and the Preisdent of Italy Sergio Mattarella(ever heard of those?).
 
Funny how we talk about how Erdogan controls everything. He is suposed to be the president of a parliamentary republic. He should be a figurehead and be as visible as as the president of Germany Joachim Gauck and the Preisdent of Italy Sergio Mattarella(ever heard of those?).
He can't even legally serve as the head-of-state, due to the fraudulent nature of his university degree. His Presidency is in and of itself, unconstitutional. After that, what's a little authoritarianism?
 
What is his (fake) uni BA degree supposed to be on?

Iirc he was a footballer.

That he is pretty much illiterate is obvious. Although he does produce the occasional funny statement, like when he confused byzantine emperor Romanos Diogenes with cynic philosopher Diogenes of Sinope :D 'you cannot do like Romanos Diogenes and look for people with a lantern' :lol:
 
What is his (fake) uni BA degree supposed to be on?
We don't know his major. He finished "Faculty of Economics & Administrative Sciences" but we don't know his major.
Iirc he was a footballer.
he was a football player in the making but his career ended after an early injury.

That he is pretty much illiterate is obvious. Although he does produce the occasional funny statement, like when he confused byzantine emperor Romanos Diogenes with cynic philosopher Diogenes of Sinope :D 'you cannot do like Romanos Diogenes and look for people with a lantern' :lol:

it's all greek to him :crazyeye:
 
I can't believe even the biggest of idiots could ever take this seriously, but apparently Erdogan is blaming the downing of that Russian plane on the coup plotters. He just arrested the pilots that did it.
At this point, I wouldn't be surprised if Erdogan claimed that a solar eclipse was Gülen trying to eat the sun.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom