Returning Civs - Elimination Game
- Thread starter The Kingmaker
- Start date
- Status
Returning Lurker
Prince
Babylonians 22
Ethiopians 14
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 18-3=15
Malians 25
Mayans 24
Mongols 24
Ottoman Turks 2+1=3
My reasons are well established by now. I've said all I can. I do not understand how it came to this but I, as a good captain, will go down with the Barbary Corsair.
Ethiopians 14
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 18-3=15
Malians 25
Mayans 24
Mongols 24
Ottoman Turks 2+1=3
My reasons are well established by now. I've said all I can. I do not understand how it came to this but I, as a good captain, will go down with the Barbary Corsair.
Babylonians 22
Ethiopians 14
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 25
Mayans 24
Mongols 21 = (24-3) - Great conquerors, and will certainly return, but another conquering powerhouse isn't a priority, especially with Scythia providing a similar role (albeit somewhat earlier).
Ottoman Turks 4 = (3+1) While Renaissance conquest will certainly feature in an Ottoman civ, there's a lot more to them than that, and they are far too interesting and important an empire to be on the way out already.
Ethiopians 14
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 25
Mayans 24
Mongols 21 = (24-3) - Great conquerors, and will certainly return, but another conquering powerhouse isn't a priority, especially with Scythia providing a similar role (albeit somewhat earlier).
Ottoman Turks 4 = (3+1) While Renaissance conquest will certainly feature in an Ottoman civ, there's a lot more to them than that, and they are far too interesting and important an empire to be on the way out already.
Babylonians 22
Ethiopians 14-3=11 - Not as interresting as the others.
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 25+1=26 - If there should be some African civ, Mali should be it.
Mayans 24
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 4 (I'd love to save them, but their end is inevitable. Some people will still say they are Europeans, although they aren't)
Ethiopians 14-3=11 - Not as interresting as the others.
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 25+1=26 - If there should be some African civ, Mali should be it.
Mayans 24
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 4 (I'd love to save them, but their end is inevitable. Some people will still say they are Europeans, although they aren't)
Babylonians 22 - 3 = 19 I have to give negative vote to someone, and everyone on this list interest me a lot, if we have Persia and Macedonia recently added, so I think they can wait a little bit. Do not get me wrong, I really want them in the game, but decisions must be made.
Ethiopians 11
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 26
Mayans 24
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 4 + 1 = 5 Surprised that they is still here, the maximum I can try to do is to delay their imminent fall. The Ottomans are too important, their place is in the top5. And undoubtedly, they are not eurocentric, and I do not know why this is being motive to employ negative votes.
Ethiopians 11
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 26
Mayans 24
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 4 + 1 = 5 Surprised that they is still here, the maximum I can try to do is to delay their imminent fall. The Ottomans are too important, their place is in the top5. And undoubtedly, they are not eurocentric, and I do not know why this is being motive to employ negative votes.
The Kingmaker
Alexander
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2004
- Messages
- 1,973
Babylonians 19+1=20 I was going to try and give the Turks a boost, but I can't do that if Babylon's being thrown into jeopardy too. The Near East is in serious need of some TLC. I'd rather lose one of the two than both.
Ethiopians 11-3=8 This is a very tough choice. I do want them back, just trying to prioritize here. I'll let Mali take the lead for Africa.
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 26
Mayans 24
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 5
Hopefully our top 5 gives us at least one civ from each of the neglected regions.
Ethiopians 11-3=8 This is a very tough choice. I do want them back, just trying to prioritize here. I'll let Mali take the lead for Africa.
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 26
Mayans 24
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 5
Hopefully our top 5 gives us at least one civ from each of the neglected regions.
Liufeng
A man of his time
Babylonians 20
Ethiopians 8
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 26
Mayans 24 -3 = 21 because between two pre columbian civs, I prefer the Incas
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 5 + 1 = 6 Ok, so this anti european is getting a little out of hand. Turks are not european ! They come from central Asia ! Yes, their capital is in Europe, so what ? It's not like it was the city they originated from. They used powder and that makes them european ? I guess the chinese were much european far before europeans themselves ! Mehmet II called himself emperor of Rome because it makes legitime to occupy Constatinople, and to further conquer Europe. Ottomans are not european, and was one of the most important actors in the world on early modern history
Ethiopians 8
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 26
Mayans 24 -3 = 21 because between two pre columbian civs, I prefer the Incas
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 5 + 1 = 6 Ok, so this anti european is getting a little out of hand. Turks are not european ! They come from central Asia ! Yes, their capital is in Europe, so what ? It's not like it was the city they originated from. They used powder and that makes them european ? I guess the chinese were much european far before europeans themselves ! Mehmet II called himself emperor of Rome because it makes legitime to occupy Constatinople, and to further conquer Europe. Ottomans are not european, and was one of the most important actors in the world on early modern history
Babylonians 20
Ethiopians 9 (8 + 1) -- A very interesting civilization with an ancient history and the unique distinction of having never fallen under European colonization. Can we skip Selassie this time, though?
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 23 (26 - 3) -- Like I said before, Mali is fine, but it's not at the top of my wishlist. One downvote to move them closer to other leading contenders won't hurt them.
Mayans 21
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 6
Ethiopians 9 (8 + 1) -- A very interesting civilization with an ancient history and the unique distinction of having never fallen under European colonization. Can we skip Selassie this time, though?
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 23 (26 - 3) -- Like I said before, Mali is fine, but it's not at the top of my wishlist. One downvote to move them closer to other leading contenders won't hurt them.
Mayans 21
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 6
Orange1861
Warlord
- Joined
- Apr 16, 2017
- Messages
- 131
Babylonians 20
Ethiopians 9
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 20 (23 - 3) Least enthusiastic out of the rest of the civs in this list.
Mayans 21
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 7 (6 + 1) This "European" Civ should be much higher than this.
Ethiopians 9
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 15
Malians 20 (23 - 3) Least enthusiastic out of the rest of the civs in this list.
Mayans 21
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 7 (6 + 1) This "European" Civ should be much higher than this.
WillowBrook
Lurker
Babylonians 20
Ethiopians 9
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 16 (15+1) personal preference
Malians 20
Mayans 21
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 4 (7-3) deserves to be top ten, but I can't say I want them sooner than the others left on the list
Ethiopians 9
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 16 (15+1) personal preference
Malians 20
Mayans 21
Mongols 21
Ottoman Turks 4 (7-3) deserves to be top ten, but I can't say I want them sooner than the others left on the list
Dirk Hartog
Chieftain
- Joined
- Mar 27, 2017
- Messages
- 31
Babylonians 20-3=17 I can't help but notice the people voting off European civs for being concentrated into one area of the world have no problem with other crowded areas of the world. In light of this I thought I'd help remedy this (after all, the three Greek civs are close to this area too).
Ethiopians 9
Incas 26
Khmer 15
Koreans 16
Malians 20
Mayans 21
Mongols 21+1=22 A staple civilization that is missing.
Ottoman Turks 4
Guandao
Rajah of Minyue, Hlai and Langkasuka
Babylonians (17-3)=14 I feel like Mesopotamia can wait a little longer for a second civ. I'm not sure if they will be geared towards science. I think there's a reason no Civ in Civ6 has been focuses entirely on science, because it's OP.
Ethiopians 9
Incas 26
Khmer (15+1)=16 I know it's not realistic to expect a SE Asian nation in a DLC, but I can keep on wishing. The Khmer had a great empire in the middle ages.
Koreans 16
Malians 20
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Ottoman Turks 4
Ethiopians 9
Incas 26
Khmer (15+1)=16 I know it's not realistic to expect a SE Asian nation in a DLC, but I can keep on wishing. The Khmer had a great empire in the middle ages.
Koreans 16
Malians 20
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Ottoman Turks 4
Morningcalm
Keeper of Records
Babylonians 14
Ethiopians 9 + 1 = 10 (Upvoting a civ with a rich history, glorious leaders, and unquestionable religious victory pertinence).
Incas 26
Khmer 16
Koreans 16
Malians 20
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Ottoman Turks 4 -3 = 1 (Dull. Byzantine heirs with cannons (and not just Mehmed II, the Kayser-i-Rum or Caesar of Rome). European in many respects, and indeed, Europeans made up a large portion of their armies. The Janissaries were, after all, Christian slaves raised as Muslim warriors.)
Ethiopians 9 + 1 = 10 (Upvoting a civ with a rich history, glorious leaders, and unquestionable religious victory pertinence).
Incas 26
Khmer 16
Koreans 16
Malians 20
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Ottoman Turks 4 -3 = 1 (Dull. Byzantine heirs with cannons (and not just Mehmed II, the Kayser-i-Rum or Caesar of Rome). European in many respects, and indeed, Europeans made up a large portion of their armies. The Janissaries were, after all, Christian slaves raised as Muslim warriors.)
Amrunril
Emperor
- Joined
- Feb 7, 2015
- Messages
- 1,239
Babylonians 11 (14 - 3) The game already has a solid array of Middle Eastern civs. Babylon would be a fine choice but shouldn't be a top priority.
Ethiopians 10
Incas 26
Khmer 16
Koreans 16
Malians 21 (20 + 1) Mansa Musa's fame gives the civ obvious flavor and mechanical "hooks", and this is one of only two remaining choices that didn't make it into V.
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Ottoman Turks 1
Ethiopians 10
Incas 26
Khmer 16
Koreans 16
Malians 21 (20 + 1) Mansa Musa's fame gives the civ obvious flavor and mechanical "hooks", and this is one of only two remaining choices that didn't make it into V.
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Ottoman Turks 1
Babylonians 11
Ethiopians 10+1= 11 (we need the only uncolonized African civ pronto)
Incas 26
Khmer 16
Koreans 16
Malians 21
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Ottoman Turks 1-3 Eliminated (bye bye pesky Turks, your behaviour on the elimination thread is just like the one in game, formidable!)
Ethiopians 10+1= 11 (we need the only uncolonized African civ pronto)
Incas 26
Khmer 16
Koreans 16
Malians 21
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Ottoman Turks 1-3 Eliminated (bye bye pesky Turks, your behaviour on the elimination thread is just like the one in game, formidable!)
Returning Lurker
Prince
Babylonians 11
Ethiopians 10
Incas 26+1=27
Khmer 16
Koreans 16-3=13
Malians 21
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Whelp, I guess the Ottoman Empire is officially European now. I better hop into my time machine and tell Jan Sobieski to call off his Hussars since the Ottoman Invasion of Europe is entirely fictitious, that the Ottomans are actually just having border disputes with their other European neighbors. I'll just leave it to him to pass on that message to the rest of his European coalition against the invading Middle Eastern European Ottomans (who are now part of that coalition I suppose).
Anyway Inca because they're the only side remaining that I really care about seeing in the immediate future and Koreans because of the same reasons I have been giving.
Ethiopians 10
Incas 26+1=27
Khmer 16
Koreans 16-3=13
Malians 21
Mayans 21
Mongols 22
Whelp, I guess the Ottoman Empire is officially European now. I better hop into my time machine and tell Jan Sobieski to call off his Hussars since the Ottoman Invasion of Europe is entirely fictitious, that the Ottomans are actually just having border disputes with their other European neighbors. I'll just leave it to him to pass on that message to the rest of his European coalition against the invading Middle Eastern European Ottomans (who are now part of that coalition I suppose).
Anyway Inca because they're the only side remaining that I really care about seeing in the immediate future and Koreans because of the same reasons I have been giving.
Last edited:
Babylonians 11
Ethiopians 11 (10+1) I'm just too much into Africa
Incas 27
Khmer 16
Koreans 13
Malians 21
Mayans 21
Mongols 19 (22-3) Give me another central asian civ that comes with another leader. Like the Timurids, or the Golden Horde, or the Ilkhanate.
Ethiopians 11 (10+1) I'm just too much into Africa
Incas 27
Khmer 16
Koreans 13
Malians 21
Mayans 21
Mongols 19 (22-3) Give me another central asian civ that comes with another leader. Like the Timurids, or the Golden Horde, or the Ilkhanate.
Babylonians 11
Ethiopians 11
Incas 27
Khmer 16
Koreans 13-3=10 - Korea isn't really the thing the game needs right now...
Malians 21+1=22 - I think I'll give my point to Mali. Inca shouldn't be leading by so much points...
Mayans 21
Mongols 19
Ethiopians 11
Incas 27
Khmer 16
Koreans 13-3=10 - Korea isn't really the thing the game needs right now...
Malians 21+1=22 - I think I'll give my point to Mali. Inca shouldn't be leading by so much points...
Mayans 21
Mongols 19
The Kingmaker
Alexander
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2004
- Messages
- 1,973
Babylonians 11+1=12 The Middle East is way underrepresented, with just 3 civs, of which 1 is a pay-to-play DLC, 1 is actually based out of Africa this time, and 1 is "the Epic of Gilgamesh Graphic Novel: The Civ," starring Dwayne "the Rock" Johnson. We need a proper Mesopotamian civ!
Ethiopians 11
Incas 27-3=24 Because a down vote won't even take them out of the lead.
Khmer 16
Koreans 10
Malians 22
Mayans 21
Mongols 19
Ethiopians 11
Incas 27-3=24 Because a down vote won't even take them out of the lead.
Khmer 16
Koreans 10
Malians 22
Mayans 21
Mongols 19
Babylonians 12
Ethiopians 11
Incas 24
Khmer 16
Koreans 10
Malians 22
Mayans 21 + 1 = 22 One of my favorite civilizations, and I think they can provide a very interesting gameplay.
Mongols 19 - 3 = 16 I do not think so highly needed now, we already have Scythia that is similar enough. I think civs from the Americas, Africa and Southeast Asia are the top priorities.
Ethiopians 11
Incas 24
Khmer 16
Koreans 10
Malians 22
Mayans 21 + 1 = 22 One of my favorite civilizations, and I think they can provide a very interesting gameplay.
Mongols 19 - 3 = 16 I do not think so highly needed now, we already have Scythia that is similar enough. I think civs from the Americas, Africa and Southeast Asia are the top priorities.
- Status
Similar threads
