With that done, I'll issue complaint number 1 about how the game's set-up was town-biased: We didn't get cover roles. That should be obvious, with how I attempted to claim Lo Pei, not having any idea that tailless was Lo Pei. That's a problem in any game with roles, but especially in this one, where we also couldn't really claim any talismans aside from the one we started off with.
And there are a very, very small number of roles we could have reasonably claimed to be without someone counter-claiming us.
Here's a list of characters in the show on Wikipedia, and
another list on the Wiki for the show. Take away all of the villains (we obviously couldn't claim that), the spirit animals (We could, but it would be kind of ridiculous), and every role that a townie had and you're left with about 3 or 4 characters, and some of the roles the townies had aren't roles we could really expect them to have the way we could be certain that Captain Black, or Jackie, or Tohru was in the game. How could we reasonably be expected to guess what characters we could claim to be if all the townies pushed role-claiming (which, at the end, you did)?
And speaking of role-claiming, giving the main character of the show nightkill immunity when nobody can counter-claim that he's Jackie Chan is overpowered, even if we can steal it from him.