Team Fortress 2 Mafia: Game Thread [concluded]

[SouthernKing]

Gentlemen. The case against Takhisis is based off of one player's vague sentence, who has unknown credibility and no evidence. Stop the silliness until Zack gives more info, you're much better off voting FoS2: Zack
In fact, Unvote, Vote: Zack

 

[Jarrema]

Good. There is nothing bad in voting for those two: Takhisis and Zack

 

[Zack]

Observe the extreme flip-flopping of SouthernKing:

Eh, I can't risk it. Unvote, Vote: Takhisis
Like has been stated repeatedly, anything said on Day 1 is all but useless. Day 1 is basically lulzvoting. Stop taking it so seriously y'all.

Silly, silly.
Why did 8-9 people just bandwagon somebody based off of one post by someone who hasn't even given his rationale for that vote?
Use some logic here.
FoS: Zack

You convinced me
Unvote; Vote: Takhisis
Zack, I want a further explanation of your reasoning. If you cant give it to us, it's going to be hard to trust you later on.

Until we get a viable explanation, Zack is next on my list.

I'm not voting Zack, I am looking for a suitable explaination for Takhisis, and I don't mindlessly vote unless.
That being said, i want an explaination from Takhisis as well.
FoS: Zack and Takhisis.
I feel that Visorslash is going a tad overboard. I also have a bad feeling about him. Vote: Visorslash

Gentlemen. The case against Takhisis is based off of one player's vague sentence, who has unknown credibility and no evidence. Stop the silliness until Zack gives more info, you're much better off voting FoS2: Zack
In fact, Unvote, Vote: Zack

Each post oscillates between "Takhisis is scum" and "Zack is scum." This isn't an isolated occurrence either. He's done this practically every other post. He can't seem to decide whether he should distance himself from Takhisis, or defend him.

Conclusion: SouthernKing and Takhisis are mafia partners.

Visorslash is also acting quite strange about the whole Takhisis thing. First he says he'll go along with voting for Takhisis, then he does a complete 180 and says I'm the devil and should rot in hell for even thinking of "pulling that stunt" of voting for someone.

Double A has reacted oddly to it as well.

 

[Double A]

Because I don't like reasonless bandwagons on people I find funny? Now that I actually know the reason, I'm going to unvote

vote: Mergle for what I said yesterday, I 'spose. I don't think 50 more damage will make a difference on Takhisis, but 5 or 10 might help somewhere else.

 

[KaiserElectric]

vote: SouthernKing for his shifty voting practices. At the very least he's a liability.

 

[Double A]

Actually, a vote on Mergle won't do anything. unvote, vote: SK

I think a bandwagon on SK with Takhisis coming in second would result in both their deaths.

 

[DarthNader]

I still think Zack's attempts to get Takhisis lynched without providing a good reason is scummy. However, I agree with mechaerik in that Zack is not likely to be mafia seeing as he's drawing so much attention to himself. This doesn't mean Zack is being anti-town though.

As for SouthernKing, he does have more waffles than a house of pancakes. Constantly flipping one's opinion in lynch voting is quite suspicious.

To be honest, unless more information surfaces, I can't really make a vote right now. So...FoS: Zack and SouthernKing, although I am leaning more towards SouthernKing.

 

[classical_hero]

There is a lot of scummy behaviour so early in the game, which is very odd. Could someone be a neutral role that we don't want to lynch? I would have no idea, but some people are just trying to get lynched, which means they could have an motive behind trying to get lynched. So far only one case looks reasonable and that is Zack's case on SouthernKing. vote:SouthernKing

 

[SamSniped]

@Visorslash: ...you think I'm scum because I agree with someone?

Unvote, vote VisorSlash for bad logic.

 

[JohannaK]

Actually, just after seeing SouthernKing's post I decided this. It might seem bandwagoning, but I have to vote someone, and certainly SK has been constantly changing opinions, and his... "passionate" defence of Takhisis makes them look like Mafiosos to me. On the other hand, that implies that Takhisis is Mafia, which is something I suspended my judgement on.
Regardless, this lynch could reveal many things if the correct candidate is lynched.
And certainly, Visorslash appears slightly suspicious. But I can't pronounce on this matter yet.
Patience is a virtue.

 

[Kennigit]

I'm not exactly confident about any takhisis case.

I am still confident about vote: samsniped being [presumably purposefully, possibly mistakingly] incorrect.

 

[Verarde]

Too...much....craziness....not...enough time....to parse...through...it all....

OTOH, SK's flipflopping is odd. But that doesn't necessarily seem scummy to me.

Zack has not said much about why Takhisis needs to be lynched. But that doesn't necessarily means he's scum, or that Takhisis is scum.

I'll just stick with BSmith1068 for now.

 

[Red_Spy]

Vote: Southernking

Why? As said before, he is a liability to the town and extremely scummy with his votes, and his defense for Takhsis points to them being partners. Same with Visorslash, with his complete 180 on his voting. However, while his votes lead to arguments that may have revealed potential mafia members, Zack can not be overlooked due to his seemingly random voting, providing no evidence to support his claims.

FoS: Zack, Takhsis, Visorslash

 

[SouthernKing]

I get that I look scummy with the vote switching, but how exactly am I a liability to the town?

 

[mgsmuhammad]

MGSMuhammed, SamSniped, both are on my hitlist, which for easiness will be located in my sig for this game. Please, town attacking parties follow this hitlist as it will make our jobs a lot easier and encourage people to play the game and get scum to talk more or otherwise be killed.

Stupid forum, automatically disabling signature.

Seems legit.
Although, unfortunately, I don't follow your reasoning.

In any case, still voting JoanK.
Because I can.

 

[KaiserElectric]

FoS: Zack, Takhsis, Visorslash

Forgive my misgivings, but what does FoS signify?

 

[Verarde]

Finger of Suspicion.

 

[CivCube]

Finger of Suspicion.

Guys. Stop. Just stop.

 

[NinjaCow64]

Finger of Suspicion.

To elaborate, it means that you think the person you are pointing at is scummy, but there is someone more scummy you are voting for at the moment, but you don't want this other person to slip under the radar so you point at them with the finger of suspision.

 

[Takhisis]

Can you at least explain to me why you're attempting to have me lynched, Zack?

It it's because of the off-game reason I think it is then shame on you.

How can people vote on an undisclosed reason that Zack promised first to reveal only after I died and then to never reveal even after the game is over? WTH?