The Messiah

Do you like the Messiah?

  • It is a Christmas tradition.

    Votes: 5 11.9%
  • I like it, but it is not a tradition.

    Votes: 9 21.4%
  • I dislike it.

    Votes: 3 7.1%
  • I have never heard it.

    Votes: 25 59.5%

  • Total voters
    42

Taliesin

Puttin' on the Ritz
Joined
Jun 11, 2003
Messages
4,906
Location
Montréal
Aha! Got you! It's not a religion thread at all!
Anyway, I've just finished listening to Handel's Messiah and, besides being awe-struck, am also wondering if people here listen to it, especially as a Christmas tradition.
 
I have heard it (as a matter of fact I was humming some of it). It's OK taken in sections, but as a whole it just get's repetitve and boring.
 
I think the "Weihnachtsoratorium" is better :) .

But that's only because I once participated in it, I guess.
 
If you find this repetitive and boring, then most the rock and punk music of today must be the kill-me-so-repetitive-and-unoriginal type.
 
I had never even heard of it until we studied Handel in my Music and Society elective this year. I still haven't heard anything of it but a tiny excerpt from that class.
 
I can't remember what it sounds like off-hand, although I'm sure I'd recognize it if I heard it, because I played in my orchestra once. I remember liking it then, and I'd probably still like it now.
 
I went and saw the Seattle Symphony perform it last year, and I liked it.

I'm not an expert on classical music by any means, however. I like almost any classical that does not prominently feature the harpsichord.
 
andvruss said:
If you find this repetitive and boring, then most the rock and punk music of today must be the kill-me-so-repetitive-and-unoriginal type.
I didn't say repetitive. I find most classical music boring, except for some Wagner stuff.
 
Afaik, I am not familiar with it.
 
I've had to play it, beginning to end, a few times with my local symphony. There are a whole bunch of individual numbers in it I like. And I wouldn't mind listening to the complete thing on rare occasion. But... really... it IS horrendously overlong. Much longer than any other symphony concert I've ever played, and longer than most non-Wagner operas. To paraphrase the second theme of the Hallelujah Chorus: "And It goes On for Ever and E-e-ever."

An unfortunate side effect of its length and the fact it is in 3 parts - and that the Hallelujah Chorus ends the 2nd part - is that about 1/3 of the audience LEAVES after the Hallelujah Chorus and does not stay for Part III.
 
I heard it for the first time earliler this year, and I liked it. Very powerful.
 
Plotinus said:
[Reno] Never heard of it??? Does the "Hallelujah Chorus" not mean *anything* to you? It's one of the most famous bits of music in existence!

Like 95% of the famous classical pieces of music, only the tunes are famous, not their names.
 
Plotinus said:
[Reno] Never heard of it??? Does the "Hallelujah Chorus" not mean *anything* to you? It's one of the most famous bits of music in existence!

I have never heard the Alleluia chorus.
 
Stapel said:
Like 95% of the famous classical pieces of music, only the tunes are famous, not their names.

Although since the Hallelujah Chorus consists of a huge chorus belting out the word "Hallelujah" over and over again, you'd think the name might stick.

It's a cliche in films and TV for divine manifestations and suchlike - to such an extent that when it's played in such circumstances now it's usually a joke. Thus, it is the piece of music that is played before the Holy Hand Grenade of Antioch explodes...
 
Back
Top Bottom