Which Civ is superior?

Which Civ do you prefer?


  • Total voters
    301

kochman

Deity
Joined
Jun 8, 2009
Messages
10,818
Now that Civ 5 is out, I was curious as to where people stood in regards to this magnificent series of games.
 
I'm expecting heavy bias for IV, though I've never been able to get "into" it the way I have Civ3.
 
A ties between IV and V.

Both of two very different games, and are both the best of their bunch.

Never played anything before IV so I can assume they're crap ;)
 
Civ4 > Civ2 > Civ1 > Civ5 > Civ3 is the correct order.
 
Civilization II is the best Civilization, and one of, if not the greatest game ever made.
 
never played I, II, or V. Wasn't too fond of civ 3 so civ 4 it is.
 
CivIV, closely followed by CivIII. I'm curious and will follow this poll. So far V is doing very poorly. I expected IV to win but thought more votes would go to V.
 
I used to like Civ III the best, but I've since converted to Civ IV.

Some people have become upset that I have fallen under the sway of a heathen religion.
 
Civ 3 FTW!
 
Civ 3 was the first Civ game I ever played and it's still great. Although, I have heard good things about Civ 2.
 
For vanilla versions:
Civ3 > Civ5 > Civ2 > Civ4 > Civ1

For expansion versions:
Civ3 > Civ4 > Civ2 > Civ5 > Civ1
 
Paradox>Civ 3>Civ 5>Civ 4>never played the others
 
Jeez, Civ 5 is getting trounced... anyone else notice that when an established major franchise goes exclusive to steam, the quality usually diminishes? (I consider exclusive to mean that even a boxed version of the game requires steam to legally play).
 
Never played I or II but could very well imagine they were great in their time. Got my first fix with III and thought I was hooked for life. IV was a more polished game than III but it had lost some of the magic. One day last spring I woke up and realized I didn't need V, I could see where it was heading. Now when I read about it I can see that it's even worse.

Recently I've actually gone back to "partyplaying" III. I'm going to vote III because in its time it was a better game relatively, than IV in its time.
 
Civ 4, followed by Civ 1 for me. Civ 1 is incredible but before a lot of peoples' times.
 
Back
Top Bottom