Your take on face transplant?

Yeeek

Seizing The Day
Joined
Dec 25, 2005
Messages
1,121
Location
Grenoble, France
French doctors perform partial face transplant for 29-year-old man

PARIS (AP) — French doctors announced Tuesday that they had performed the world's third partial face transplant on a man whose face was disfigured by severe tumors, giving him a new nose, mouth and chin and replacing part of his cheeks.

Going into the 15-hour operation Sunday, the 29-year-old patient had such large, heavy tumors on his lips that it was difficult to speak or eat. The operation removed most of the tumors from his face, doctors said.

"The patient is doing well from a surgical point of view," chief surgeon Dr. Laurent Lantieri said at a news conference in Paris.

Still, he added, "We will have to wait many months for the results" — including whether the patient's body would accept the tissue, whether his new nerves would function correctly and whether he would psychologically accept his new face.

The patient suffered from a genetic condition known as neurofibromatosis, which causes tumors to grow on nerve tissue throughout the body, the doctors said. The patient had undergone some 30 to 40 operations over 10 years to try to improve his face's appearance, Lantieri said.

Jean-Paul Meningaud, another member of the medical team, said the patient's condition made him increasingly reclusive.

"Any day, all of us can go into a restaurant or have a coffee in a cafe, and he had reached a point where he could not do that," Meningaud said. Doctors said one of the patient's main sources of suffering was that he could not get a job because of his appearance, though he has a university education.

Despite the lifelong risks that a transplant surgery poses — episodes of rejection or even death — the patient "didn't hesitate a single second," Lantieri said, adding that the patient was "completely serene" going into the surgery. New tumors cannot grow on the transplanted tissue, he said.

Lantieri carried out the operation at Henri-Mondor hospital in the Paris suburb of Creteil. The patient remained sedated Tuesday, and still had not seen a picture of himself. The doctor did not release any information about the patient or the donor, seeking to protect their privacy.

In 2005, Frenchwoman Isabelle Dinoire received the world's first partial face transplant after her dog mauled her. Since that surgery, a Chinese farmer also received a partial face transplant after he was disfigured in a bear attack.

The latest procedure is different because the patient was disfigured by a genetic condition, not an accident.

Lantieri, an adviser to the French medical ethics panel, had criticized the first partial face transplant, saying Dinoire's surgeons should first have tried reconstructive surgery.

Dinoire also underwent a second experimental treatment along with her transplant — an infusion of the donor's bone marrow — to try to prevent rejection of the new tissue. Lantieri said he did not use that tactic in the new surgery.

On the anniversary of Dinoire's procedure in November, doctors said her operation was a success and that she is gaining more sensitivity and facial mobility.

Changing Faces, a British charity for people with disfigurements, said it believes patients can choose to undergo such radical procedures if they are fully informed about the risks, especially of tissue rejection.

"We wish this man well and hope that his privacy and that of the donor's family will be respected," said James Partridge, the group's founder and chief executive. "We hope that the clinical and surgical teams in France will be learning from these procedures and disseminating their findings within the scientific community.

Doctors in Britain and the United States are also working toward similar procedures.

In October, an ethics panel approved plans by surgeons at the Royal Free Hospital in London to carry out what could be the world's first full-face transplant, though it said no patients had been selected yet. The Cleveland Clinic in Ohio is also working on plans for full-face transplants.

http://www.usatoday.com/news/health/2007-01-23-partial-face-transplant_x.htm

Lets take a look at Isabelle Dinoire, first person to undergo face transplant. Post-transplant and one year after :

Spoiler :
1.jpg


Isabelle Dinoire at Wikipedia, information on face transplant at Wikipedia
 
Hm not really, though i agree i should rename the thread tittle. Its been one year, we can now see what happened to her new face. There has also been a new face transplant. Wich is in the "quoted" article.

Edit - Added the link to the online article about it.
 
Good for her. :)

I don't see what makes a face transplant any more wrong than a heart, brain, or kidney transplant.
 
Good for her. :)

I don't see what makes a face transplant any more wrong than a heart, brain, or kidney transplant.


I agree. If the operation improves quality-of-life then that's great.
 
I've never really understood the media's attempts to turn face transplantation into some kind of ethical controversy. Their arguments seem to hinge on the idea that the donor's friends or relatives might suddenly see someone wandering around with their face, but it's been demonstrated this is a non-issue. It is underlying bone structure that largely determines appearance, so the receiver of the transplant won't bear the slightest resemblance to the donor.

I have no objections whatever to face transplants. Major facial disfigurement has a huge impact on the quality of a person's life, other reconstructive surgery is not always going to be effective, and if it can be repaired in this fashion then it should be. There's no real difference here from any other transplant. I guess it's just the growing tendency for the media to try and turn any story related to medecine into an ethical dilemma
 
Nothing wrong with it.

Would you rather look like the woman in the first picture or the second?
 
Nothing wrong with it.

Would you rather look like the woman in the first picture or the second?

Depends on if you want to scare children.
 
I read about it at the time the first one happened, creeps me the hell out, but then again the people who need would probably scare me more without the transplant.

Whats wrong with just wearing some cool mask? I wear a cool metal one like some kind of a super hero if my face was all screwed up.
 
Nothing wrong with it.

Would you rather look like the woman in the first picture or the second?

That's not what's being compared. I'm not too sure, but I believe that posting a photo of the woman before her face transplant surgery would violate the Code of Conduct for this board. Keep in mind that she was pleased with her new face that we see in the first photo, because her old mug was horrifyingly worse.

Face transplants seem more creepy than a heart transplant; but that's merely a social event. Logically, they should be awfully similar.
 
If it would make me attractive to the opposite sex, I would go through with it!
 
Both pic of the woman is after the transplant, the 2nd pic shows her face after some more surgery. Her face was bitten off by a dog.
 
Both pic of the woman is after the transplant, the 2nd pic shows her face after some more surgery. Her face was bitten off by a dog.
Yes, my mistake. :blush:

What I meant was, if you had such a situation, wouldn't you try and get a new face instead of... (?).
 
I don't think anyone would be opposed to getting a new face after such an accident. Anyone saying the opposite cannot appreciate the technology or choice to make it possible.
 
Think about it this way, what gives you the Jimminies more, having someones skin on your face, or their heart in your chest?
 
I think face transplants are kind of weird, but unless you're killing someone to steal their face, I don't see how it's a moral issue. If you're disfigured, I don't see why we shouldn't try and help you if we can.
 
Back
Top Bottom