• We are currently performing site maintenance, parts of civfanatics are currently offline, but will come back online in the coming days. For more updates please see here.

2022 Winter Olympics.

Not at all. I disapprove of doping. Read Gelion's post. I suspect her coach is the person who is responsible; she is the "win at any cost" type of coach.
You said "she was only 15 and suspending her would wreck her career" as if it was the main reason for lifting suspension.
No, being underaged is not an indulgence to take any medications you want. The court analyzed her arguments and was satisfied by them.
 
I suspect her coach is the person who is responsible; she is the "win at any cost" type of coach.
Aha. All three of the Russian girls are coached by the same person. They currently occupy 3 of 4 top positions in the individual ranking. What makes you think doping one of the three best world's athletes will change anything for the coach? Or are you suggesting something else?
 
If L-carnitine was banned then nobody would be allowed to compete, because it is naturally produced in human body. Presence of hypoxen indicates that she was taking some medication. I wonder how they make drugs. For example, in food industry they often use the same mixer to make different products, so you may read on chocolate's wrapper that among other things it may contain traces of some nuts or whatever.
Not at all. I disapprove of doping. Read Gelion's post. I suspect her coach is the person who is responsible; she is the "win at any cost" type of coach.
We've been there. You know that this is not even remotely likely.
 
"Sha'Carri Richardson Wants To Know Why She Was Banned From The Olympics When A Russian Skater Who Failed A Drug Test Was Allowed

Kamila Valieva, the 15-year-old Russian figure skater who tested positive for a banned substance ahead of the Beijing Olympics, will still be allowed to compete in her event, officials announced Monday. If she wins, however, no medal ceremony will be held until the investigation is complete.

Arbitrators said the decision was because the athlete is considered "a protected person" due to her age, adding that it would be unfair to suspend her and would cause her "irreparable harm." Valieva, who is seen as the favorite to win the women's singles event starting Tuesday, tested positive for trimetazidine, a heart medication that may boost stamina.
The decision drummed up widespread outcry, particularly because of Russia's history of Olympic doping scandals.
But the ruling also raised comparisons to another recent Olympic drug testing incident — one that was handled very differently for another athlete who, like Valieva, was favored to win her event.
In July 2021, US track star Sha’Carri Richardson was disqualified from the 100-meter race at the Tokyo Olympics and faced a one-month ban after testing positive for cannabis. The 21-year-old athlete said she used it to cope with her mother's death.

In an interview on NBC's Today show after she was disqualified, Richardson apologized for her actions and explained she had ingested cannabis after the news of her mother's death sent her into an "emotional panic."
“I want to take responsibility for my actions," Richardson said. "I know what I did, I know what I'm supposed to do, what I'm allowed not to do, and I still made that decision."
Following Monday's ruling, Richardson questioned why she lost her chance to compete at the Olympics, but Valieva won't, suggesting there was racial bias in the decisions.

"Can we get a solid answer on the difference of her situation and mines?" Richardson tweeted. "My mother died and I can’t run and was also favored to place top 3."
"The only difference I see is I’m a black young lady," she said.
Richardson also alluded to the fact that trimetazidine was a performance-boosting drug, while cannabis wasn't.
"THC definitely is not a performance enhance[r]!" she tweeted.
...Many have also pointed out the contrast in what drug each athlete tested positive for. Trimetazidine is a performance-enhancing medication, but cannabis is widely considered not to be and was in fact legal in Oregon, where Richardson consumed it."

buzzfeednews.com/article/juliareinstein/shacarri-richardson-kamila-valieva-doping-olympics?
 
Last edited:
It all must be a conspiracy against Russian athletes because they are superior and the west is jealous.
 
It all must be a conspiracy against Russian athletes because they are superior and the west is jealous.
You're withdrawing from the debate? :shifty:
 
"Sha'Carri Richardson Wants To Know Why She Was Banned From The Olympics When A Russian Skater Who Failed A Drug Test Was Allowed

Kamila Valieva, the 15-year-old Russian figure skater who tested positive for a banned substance ahead of the Beijing Olympics, will still be allowed to compete in her event, officials announced Monday. If she wins, however, no medal ceremony will be held until the investigation is complete.

Arbitrators said the decision was because the athlete is considered "a protected person" due to her age, adding that it would be unfair to suspend her and would cause her "irreparable harm." Valieva, who is seen as the favorite to win the women's singles event starting Tuesday, tested positive for trimetazidine, a heart medication that may boost stamina.
The decision drummed up widespread outcry, particularly because of Russia's history of Olympic doping scandals.
But the ruling also raised comparisons to another recent Olympic drug testing incident — one that was handled very differently for another athlete who, like Valieva, was favored to win her event.
In July 2021, US track star Sha’Carri Richardson was disqualified from the 100-meter race at the Tokyo Olympics and faced a one-month ban after testing positive for cannabis. The 21-year-old athlete said she used it to cope with her mother's death.

In an interview on NBC's Today show after she was disqualified, Richardson apologized for her actions and explained she had ingested cannabis after the news of her mother's death sent her into an "emotional panic."
“I want to take responsibility for my actions," Richardson said. "I know what I did, I know what I'm supposed to do, what I'm allowed not to do, and I still made that decision."
Following Monday's ruling, Richardson questioned why she lost her chance to compete at the Olympics, but Valieva won't, suggesting there was racial bias in the decisions.

"Can we get a solid answer on the difference of her situation and mines?" Richardson tweeted. "My mother died and I can’t run and was also favored to place top 3."
"The only difference I see is I’m a black young lady," she said.
Richardson also alluded to the fact that trimetazidine was a performance-boosting drug, while cannabis wasn't.
"THC definitely is not a performance enhance[r]!" she tweeted.
...Many have also pointed out the contrast in what drug each athlete tested positive for. Trimetazidine is a performance-enhancing medication, but cannabis is widely considered not to be and was in fact legal in Oregon, where Richardson consumed it."

buzzfeednews.com/article/juliareinstein/shacarri-richardson-kamila-valieva-doping-olympics?
It is quite ridiculous that pot is treated the same as steroids.
 
Strange that marijuana is called pot - first time I heard this word I was wondering how can you smoke clay vase? )

Russia is currently the leader by number of silver and bronze medals, but has only four golds.
It's a pity, the situation often repeats in olympic games, both Summer and Winter ones.
 
May be, they should consider using fines for taking something that does not enchance performance. Canabis was banned for ethical reasons, unless I'm much mistaken, and taking away a once in four years opportunity for it is way too harsh.
I do not like the idea that a private organisation can fine someone. If you break the rules they can stop you playing in their game, but any powers beyond this should be a democratic decision.

The fact that we give one of the worlds most corrupt organisations so much power and so little oversight is really weird to me.
 
Her coach, Eteri Tutberidze, told Russian state news agency Tass they are "absolutely sure" she is innocent.
And by the way, about Eteri, "grinding to dust" and "win at all cost".
She is probably quite strict in her methods, I don't know. There are even allusions in Western press that she abuses the athletes. But she doesn't hold anyone in chains, there are plenty of coaches in Russia and abroad. Everyone is free to go, there is a long line of other candidates ready to replace anyone.
If she is so cruel, why so many people are almost willing to sell their souls to be accepted in her team?
 
You're withdrawing from the debate? :shifty:
Not much left to debate. Everyone has admitted she tested positive for one banned and two non banned heart medications. The rest is politics.:)
 
Paywall :borg:
 
Back
Top Bottom