Ask a soldier thread....

18 years, E7. Respectable career.

If you could change just one thing about the way the US Army does business, what single improvement would you make to enhance it? I'm thinking organisation rather than equipment here.
 
whats with the whole rivalry of

"Go navy splash army!"

?
 
CivGeneral said:
A picture would suffice ;).

So in otherwords (for better visual referance), how Major Kusanagi rolls her leather jacket is considered the "wrong way"?

Heck no that's not the wrong way! That's the Marine way, the right way, only way! Those army pukes are the ones with the fixation on looking pretty for the enemy and rolling their sleeves in. Nancy boys, the lot of 'em!

P.S. - I liked the pork patty back in the 80s. Wasn't terribly fond of the 'chocolate' bar, but the pork patty was fine. As was the Meatballs in barbeque sauce (I think that's what it was).
 
What is the average age of retirement from the military?
 
Blazer6 said:
What requirements must be met before joining?

You used to have to have a high school diploma or GED equiv..not sure that is still the case though. And you have to be able to score high enough on the army placement test for certain jobs....the more technical the higher your score needs to be.

In order to get out of basic training you must pass a physical test at a certain level and ditto with advanced individual training (AIT).
 
Dreadnought said:
I want to join the army in a few years (via West Point). So:

What is the most rewarding branch in the army (do you think)?

How often do you get promoted (captain -> major, etc.)?

Not a commissioned officer. However, the most rewarding branch would be: most likely the one the person you ask is in....that is if you ask a nurse she would probably say medical...if you ask your S-2 officer he would probably say intelligence.

As for officer promotions - they have different gates and requirements than the enlisted side does. They do go through officer promotion boards and the process/career tends to be far more political than the enlisted side is. Officers can get promoted ahead of their gates if they are rated above their peers...if they get passed over twice for promotion and miss two gates...they get separated from the service.
 
CruddyLeper said:
18 years, E7. Respectable career.

If you could change just one thing about the way the US Army does business, what single improvement would you make to enhance it? I'm thinking organisation rather than equipment here.

Needs work in the PR department and ensuring that the general population knows how we do things as opposed to how we are sometimes perceived. A lot of times the perception is quite different from the reality, but we are not very good in showing how.

Also, I might add that things are constantly changing organization wise. Units move around every five years or so and even change their base structure. Modernization seems to have picked up quite a bit in the last 5-7 years in an effort to get more bang for the buck. Not sure where it will lead, but things have certainly been changing.
 
Dawgphood001 said:
whats with the whole rivalry of

"Go navy splash army!"

?

From what I can guess, and it is a guess..its from the service schools sports rivalrys. All the service academys compete against other schools in the NCAAs and against each other. Long tradition of rivalry amongst the army, navy and air force.
 
VRWCAgent said:
P.S. - I liked the pork patty back in the 80s. Wasn't terribly fond of the 'chocolate' bar, but the pork patty was fine. As was the Meatballs in barbeque sauce (I think that's what it was).

Silly marine. What kind of marine wouldnt like the John Wayne bar as the old MRE chocolate bar was called.:lol:

But the meatballs were acceptable as I recall.
 
Dawgphood001 said:
What is the average age of retirement from the military?

Early to mid 40s for a full time service retirement. A 20 year career nets you a 50% base pay retirement and other lifetime benefits - medical and base privileges. For every year you stay in after 20 you get an additional 2.5% raise in your retirement pay. As an E7 I can stay in a maximum of 24 years and get a 60% base pay retirement and start collecting the checks as soon as I walk out the door.
 
Let's see; which would I rather have ... my sleeves rolled out on my field uniform, or have to hastle with that new blasted black beret all the time. Hmm, I'll take the sleeves-out, please. :p
 
MobBoss said:
Actually, having a college degree may or may not qualify you for a commission as an officer. Depends upon the degree. I have known people with college degrees to join the military for different reasons.
Friend of mine refused to go to University to gain an officers commission on the basis that there is a degree of stimga attached to those officers who do. Is there a similar stereotype attached to those who haven't been promoted through the ranks in the US army?
 
I read you havn't killed- would you shoot an enemy soldier- considering hes probably just a mirror of you, just the puppet masters at the top have sent you out to kill each other?

or is it kill or be killed?
 
Most soldiers/Marines that have killed, aren't totally sure if they've killed or not (usually happens at a distance, bullets flying everywhere, usually you can't immediately go over and check the guy's pulse, etc.), so you just have to live in wonder, whether you've killed or not.

And if that bothers you, you have no business holding a rifle. I knew some Marines that were in Somalia, the Balkans, etc. that had been in situations where they'd fired rounds at the enemy, but kills were never confirmed for whatever reason, and it kinda bothered/stressed them psychologically, years afterwards. Whatever. I say they need a good @ss-kicking. Maybe a 'cowardice' discharge as well.

If you don't have at least a small "GET SOME!! :ar15: " -bone in your body, just don't join up in the first place for crying out loud.

Of my two grandfathers, one killed quite a few Japanese, and he's actually proud of it, whereas the other bombed/strafed a whole bunch of Germans in his P-38, and it really got to him after the war.

You just gotta do what ya gotta do. People die every day. It's a bloody little planet we live on. And somebody's gotta do it. Why does God love the Marine Corps so? Because they keep Heaven stocked with fresh souls...

Hmm. Pretty morbid. Ah well... tough. No point in being soft, is there...? Just so somebody harder can come around and take you down...

Kill or be killed. It's nature.
 
How long do those MREs "shelf life" ???
5 years ? 7 years ? or the navy emergancy rations 15 years ?

(poor poor navy) :D
 
Lotus49 said:

thankfully there are people dedicated to better things aswell.

Focus:

Which special forces are considered the best of the best? Is it the Delta? or perhaps the DEVGRU?

Who do the people in the army/navy/air force/marines look up to most?
 
superisis said:
thankfully there are people dedicated to better things aswell.

Focus:

Which special forces are considered the best of the best? Is it the Delta? or perhaps the DEVGRU?

Who do the people in the army/navy/air force/marines look up to most?

There really is no one clear 'best of the best' jack of all trades super-human hero squad. Each is kinda specialized for what they do. Army Rangers think they're the best, they jump out of planes and take airfields, primarily. USAF combat controllers have very specific jobs as well. Delta Force, those guys are more like CIA operatives, more often that not, with long hair & wearing civilian clothes (it's not all commando stuff like in the computer games). They're definitely combat oriented, but also biased towards the intel/counter-intel side of things.

Navy SEALS, those guys are probably your best jack-of-all-trades. If this was "Mission Impossible", you'd probably want to send a SEAL team, if you didn't have Tom Cruise, to get the job done.

But, as far as who is the biggest hard-@ss, grunt, commando, wouldn't-wanna-meet-in-an-alley, I know my choice.

Put it this way... if I was to lead a platoon of men, into the outback of Australia, or the Amazon, Congo, makes no difference, and we were to go up against an equal number of men, and the 'game' was, a hunter-killer mission to track the other guys down, engage them, and fight to the death... the last group I'd want to have to face as my enemy is the Marine Force Recon.

When it comes down to a 'Rambo'-type scenario, where it's just you, the jungle, guns and ammo, and hunting down the enemy like an animal and wasting him, I'm sorry, but I'd fear the Marines most. They're just more psychotic, when it really comes down to it. "Masters of chaos", as a German general in WWI said of them.

I've served with the Army and Marines, so, I feel I have some authoritah on the subject. They Army does their job. But, they don't do it with the bloodthirsty eye of the tiger like the Marines do. Going from the Marines, to the Army, I felt like I was in a civilian environment. And Air Force... they really are a corporation, more than a branch of service (but, I appreciate their role, and if I could do it all over again...)

Basically, you know that spirit of wicked fury and unrelenting warpath from Hell of say... the Comanche tribe? Pure warrior spirit. That fighting spirit is most alive in the Marine Corps, more so than the other branches, that's for sure. That's why they'd be the last ones I'd choose to fight, if I could pick my opponent amongst the U.S. forces. People from rural areas all over the country that want "ta kill somethin'" join the Marines. Thus, their ranks are filled with a bunch of crazies. Typical Army recruit, is a minority from a large urban area, that is joining because they have no better way to move up in life. Not the case for all, but that's the general idea/prevailing case. You tell me who's gonna 'make the most' of a situation, in the heat of the moment in combat.

I mean think about it... what kind of person joins the Marines, in the first place... something's GOT to be wrong with them...
 
@ Lotus49
Given that you are answering all the questions I presume you are in an Army somewhere. Which one is it? Sorry didn't know which country you are from. How long have you served?
 
A. I know you aren't in the reserves, but are they in basic training for the same number of weeks as are their cohorts in the regular branch (i.e. army, navy, etc)?

B. I'm friends with a former (well he says "never former") marine tanker, and he had interesting names for the other branches of the service (squids for the Navy, airdale for Air Force, etc). I was wondering if they are general terms used by all branches of the military? Also, he didn't say what the army's was, so do you know what it is? (I apologize if any of them are durogatory or meant as an insult)

C. Why does everyone think the marines are a bunch of crazy's?

D. A classmate of mine that was in the Air Force usually has a chat with me daily around lunch time. Yesterday it was about the worst possible bases to be assigned at, he mentioned Korea and a particular base in Japan (I forget which one). So what do the servicemen here think?

E. This classmate also said that USAF have to buy their BDU's (well uniforms in general) as opposed to having them supplied to them like with other branches. He served from the mid 1990's until about 2003. So is this true of the BDU and other uniforms?

F. Is Vienna Sausage the only good thing to come from C rations?
 
Back
Top Bottom