JH--why would you compare this to Japan? They raised rates in late 1989 early 1990 and didn't lower real rates below zero till 1996 whereas we did it in less than six months. Also, in 1989 they raised taxes from zero on VAT and capital gains to 5% and 20%, respectively. Seems like that was quite a combination of events on top of bad loans that led to that 10 year malaise.
Second question, other recessions have been caused by some combination of monetary tightness, higher taxes, and/or protectionism.
However, the current weakness isn't due to any of those factors. Instead, it seems to be coming from the massive amount of bad lending (itself ignited by loose money) mixed with untimely new mark-to market accounting rules and the uptick rule. In turn, this has impacted earnings which meant lower equity prices which meant the rating agencies changed their ratings and then we get this vicious cycle that slows the velocity of money.
Shouldn't we be addressing some of these ancillary issues by modifying some of the rules (IE 3 year market to market averaging or allowing a certain per cent to be allocated to a "held to maturity" accounting measure). It seems this recession will be driven by the snails pace of money velocity. First time ever.
I'm just thinking about pushing a bucket out to collect some rainwater. With the market the way it is certainly I could lose my investment entirely but I could also get in at the ground floor of a recovery - what kind of returns would someone get having gone into the market at the bottom of the '87 crash?
ID--don't compound the error that others have made. Leverage has been the death of many investors and do borrow from a loan shark (credit card) is even more deathly. If you have the cash to put away and let it cook for awhile that's different. What I do think is if you're doing this you should try starting with quality. What I mean by that businesses that are not only cheap but have organic growth, low debt/equity, better than market dividends, rated A+, A or A- for quality of earnings stability and dividend growth, top half ROE and free cash flow greater than dividend payout by a factor of at least one.
Ford would not meet any of these criterion and is extremely correlated to the macro economy which is not pretty right now. Look for a catalyst for growth from companies like this before buying them.
Companies like Coke, Pepsico, Emerson Electric, Chevron, Flowers Foods, ADP, P&G, Genuine Auto Parts etc meet all the above criterion. Always use the principle of K.I.S.S. when investing for your strategic core holdings. Later you can get fancy by sateliteing off the core and become more tactical.
Is now a great time to get into the market?
Better than it was a day, week, month, year or even 10 years ago, yes.
The question you should ask is in three years what should you have done in 2008.
I'd fund a Roth IRA for sure and keep adding as long as you can.
There's a lot of flexibility as you can always take out your contribution amount. You can also take out the
earnings and contributions for $10k towards a 1st time home purchase if you have the account opened for 5 years. If you don't have it open for five years then the $10k for a home taxes only what you've earned but the contribution amount can still come out free. Meaning if you contributed $10k it comes out free but if you contributed $5k and made $6k then you'd be taxed on the $4k you earned. Clear as mud, yes?
If it's for qualified education expenses only the earnings are taxed but not the contribution. This type of shelter allows for virtually any investment vehicle to be held inside
so for single earners making AGI less than $101k ($159k married) this is a layup.
For those of you with IRA accounts you will find no better time to convert to a Roth (if you qualify but if you don't wait till 2010) than right now because chances are your account is worth less than it's been in a long time and the same 5 year rule applies on withdrawals of the conversion amount (free from tax) and previously stated rules apply on earnings (house, education). Nice safety net to have...