Aspiring Rapper's MAFIA- Game Thread

[Zack]

BSmith, one thing re: arakhor wagon. I pretty much created the wagon, so your reasoning that an arakhor vote was scummy because it's "easily justifiable" doesn't really apply to me, because it wasn't easy to justify for me, I had to put a lot of work into it.

also lol at you throwing shade at backwards for ignoring the accusation after you picked on me for "defending" myself

 

[Murska]

Vote: Backwards Logic then. Both work.

 

[BSmith1068]

But of course his reluctance to take the limitations to his grave are suspect, though Arakhor chose to do the same.

 

[Zack]

Regarding Al – I’m inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt. Him being a doctor would fit why he was fishing for power roles – he could have been looking to find people to protect. It sounds like he does have limitations on his role, so that would lend credence to multiple doctor type roles. Mafia also have 2 kills per night, so more than one doctor is a way to balance that.

double doctor is inherently broken because the doctors can protect each other which the mafia can't do anything about. pizza would be well aware of the pitfalls of such a design

 

[Zack]

4 Al Sipsclar
4 Zack

3 Backwards Logic

2 glossysushi

1 lohrenswald

 

[BSmith1068]

BSmith, one thing re: arakhor wagon. I pretty much created the wagon, so your reasoning that an arakhor vote was scummy because it's "easily justifiable" doesn't really apply to me, because it wasn't easy to justify for me, I had to put a lot of work into it.

also lol at you throwing shade at backwards for ignoring the accusation after you picked on me for "defending" myself

True. I hadn’t considered that part of the Arkahor vote, but it is absolutely true. I haven’t been pushing for your lynch though, just calling my reactions to your reactions as I see them.

No shade intended there re: BL. Ignoring an accusation is hard to do as a townie, but much easier as scum where you are more concerned whit how you respond to it. A lot can be told by how one responds to an accusation.

 

[BSmith1068]

double doctor is inherently broken because the doctors can protect each other which the mafia can't do anything about. pizza would be well aware of the pitfalls of such a design

Assuming the doctors know who each other are (no PMs or outside communication in this game make that pretty hard) and there are no limitations on the protection.

 

[Al Sipsclar]

with my avatar, it's about as perfect opportunity to curse me with his last breath

I aim to please.

 

[BSmith1068]

A doctor could be pretty limited in this game by say only having one use of their ability.

 

[Zack]

A doctor could be pretty limited in this game by say only having one use of their ability.

al has directly refuted that

 

[Zack]

Look at the mafiascum wiki entry for doctor

It is very important when including a Doctor in a game to check for broken combinations arising from its synergy with other power roles. Follow the Cop, for instance, arises when it is known in advance that there is a Cop and a Doctor in the game. Another broken combination involves two Doctors in the same setup; they can protect each other each Night and thus become immune to kills for the rest of the game. Because of this, full Doctors have fallen out of vogue in favor of Jailers or simply not including a protective role at all.

 

[choxorn]

No, thanks, better keep scum guessing.

But... why? What secret could you possibly have about your role that it's better if you take it to the grave than it is if you tell us what it is and maybe keep us from mislynching a claimed doctor? If you really are what you say you are, why can't you just tell the full truth?

I'm willing to lynch Backwards instead of you if you give me a good enough reason to switch and also switch with me so that it's Backwards and not Zack that gets lynched, but I've seen you as scummy for days now and I'm not changing that opinion unless you can do a better job of convincing me you're telling the truth.

 

[Zack]

I would be willing to lynch Backwards, but if I move my vote now it means I will be lynched. BL has to go into the lead.

Though I still maintain that Al's claim is absurd.

 

[BSmith1068]

Al has indicated there is a limitation... I agree that he should tell us at this point.

 

[choxorn]

I would be willing to lynch Backwards, but if I move my vote now it means I will be lynched. BL has to go into the lead.

Though I still maintain that Al's claim is absurd.

Like I've already said, I prefer either Backwards' lynch or Al's to yours, so I'll switch to BL if you do, not sure which one I want to lynch more, though.

 

[Zack]

Al has indicated there is a limitation... I agree that he should tell us at this point.

regardless i am skeptical

 

[Legato Endless]

Vote: Zack

This lynch on Backwards smells doctored as hell.

 

[Cass_]

Back sorry, dealing with kids.
The only thing holding me back from voting Sips is the claim, and even then I can see possible scum motivation. Zack seems overly defensive.

My main concern with a BL lynch is the votes that have been on him to before this point - Legato's 'spam vote', Glossy sheeping Visor, Cuth sheeping Glossy.

I would've been happier with a Choxorn CFD tbh.

 

[Zack]

5 zack

4 al sipsclar

3 backwards logic

2 sushi

 

[Murska]

Vote: Al Sipsclar. That claim seems bad.