Aspiring Rapper's MAFIA- Game Thread

[Zack]

The people who are posting right now and thus likely to tell you anything are all being scumread by multiple people.

What? Kennigit has been universally town-read, and Lassie and I have been mixed. This is just slander.

 

[Cuthillius]

lol I just consciously connected Visor's avatar being a wolf and him joking about him being a wolf

wow my brain

 

[Cuthillius]

What? Kennigit has been universally town-read, and Lassie and I have been mixed. This is just slander.

Is this a purposeful over-reaction?

 

[Legato Endless]

The people who are posting right now and thus likely to tell you anything are all being scumread by multiple people.

Well that's comforting.

But come on, cfc has very few ppp. 27 pages really isn't that bad, and it's okay if you skim a little.

No. I'd never forgive myself. It's not the number of people. Pizza's 56 person game was way easier to parse than this. That and I've other stuff to get done. But if I wait till long I'll just stop trying. Hrrrm.

I will stop complaining about this. Soon. Ish.

And vote for someone. Maybe next post. No promises.

 

[Zack]

Is this a purposeful over-reaction?

Talk about a leading question.

 

[Mat93]

What? Kennigit has been universally town-read, and Lassie and I have been mixed. This is just slander.

This is an accurate point. I don't think anyone is being scum read across the board. Well, anyone whos posting a lot right now who isn't you.

Well that's comforting.



No. I'd never forgive myself. It's not the number of people. Pizza's 56 person game was way easier to parse than this. That and I've other stuff to get done. But if I wait till long I'll just stop trying. Hrrrm.

I will stop complaining about this. Soon. Ish.

And vote for someone. Maybe next post. No promises.

I'd suggest reading the town/scum lean posts of the few people who have posted them. Should give you a brief overview, and differing opinions, in a pinch.

Nothing beats reading it all yourself though.

 

[Mat93]

By you, I mean Cuth, not Zack

 

[Cuthillius]

Did I say scum read across the board?

 

[Cuthillius]

Talk about a leading question.

Sushi's scum.

Visor might be scum.

I miss cass's piggy avatar, but I'm pretty sure she's town.

 

[Lassie]

Yeah, I agree. Getting a few bandwagons going is ideal for Day 1, doesn't really matter on who. What matters is that people will have to choose one over the other(s), and that choice can be meaningful for later analysis. Any reads at this stage have a huge margin of error. A lot of scum tend to lurk around until the end of the day before actually placing a vote, and forcing them to make their vote have a meaningful impact in the lynch is huge.

That said, my bandwagon is the best and everyone should join it.

D1 votes does matter for more than just analysis, I've had my vote on scum at EOD in 7 out of 11 of my town games(non-turbo) on MU(just counted )

 

[Mat93]

No. I merely imputed my own opinion into my own post. Is that a problem?

Also, saying you are not someone who is being scum read across the board, is not saying you are being scum read across the board. Before the question is asked.

 

[Cuthillius]

That said, I don't think sushi and visor are scumbuddies. but I'm not ruling it out

 

[Zack]

Is this a purposeful over-reaction?

Talk about a leading question.

To expand on this, Cuth's question here reeks of fake analysis. It's a meaningless question designed to make it look like he's doing townie things.

D1 votes does matter for more than just analysis, I've had my vote on scum at EOD in 7 out of 11 of my town games(non-turbo) on MU(just counted )

Well yeah obviously lynching scum is ideal

 

[Zack]

Well yeah obviously lynching scum is ideal

And if a scum is lynched in a close margin with other bandwagons, then that leaves a lot to chew on for analysis. So my point stands.

 

[Cuthillius]

Mat, take the posts in context.

I say the active people are generally being scumread by multiple people.

Zack says, no, Ken is apparently active and he's "generally being read as town", and opinions are "mixed" (ie some people think they're scummy) on Zack and Lassie.

Then you say "Yeah, Zack's right, nobody's being scumread across the board except for you!"

Which is not very helpful, because it's

a)not reinforcing Zack's point
b)Zack's point wasn't really a very good point in the first place
c)not true

 

[Lassie]

@Zack Indeed, and that's my point against you saying we should just start voting anyone. It has more value to actually consider your vote well, before just starting a wagon.

 

[Cuthillius]

To expand on this, Cuth's question here reeks of fake analysis. It's a meaningless question designed to make it look like he's doing townie things.

Unlike your commentary?

 

[Mat93]

No. I merely imputed my own opinion into my own post. Is that a problem?

Also, saying you are not someone who is being scum read across the board, is not saying you are being scum read across the board. Before the question is asked.

Then you say "Yeah, Zack's right, nobody's being scumread across the board except for you!"

I very intentionally made sure I did not say that, as I knew qith 100% certainty that would be your response.

Also Zack's point is valid. There is a range of opinions out there. For example, me and you disagree on nearly everything.

Me and Visor disagree on a few people, me and Glossy disagree on a few, me and Zack disagree on landlubber (albeit not complete opposites).

 

[Mat93]

Thats not to mention the disagreements that don't involve me.

 

[Zack]

I say the active people are generally being scumread by multiple people.

No, that is NOT what you said. You said "the people who are posting right now", which was me, you, Kennigit, and Lassie.

@Zack Indeed, and that's my point against you saying we should just start voting anyone. It has more value to actually consider your vote well, before just starting a wagon.

I'm not convinced that D1 voting is much better than rng. In my experience scum are lynched at about the rate you would expect from randomly drawing names out of a hat.