Zack
99% hot gas
seems pretty nonsensical actually
Aspiring Rapper's MAFIA- Game Thread
- Thread starter Askthepizzaguy
- Start date
Huh? What are you saying, that Arakhor was hinting about his role with the dice thing? Where was it ever implied that had anything to do with his role?
If you're thinking about Kenni's post, I'm also a little confused right now after having read it. Might just be too early for me.
You kept tabs on the thread while you were dead, yet you entered the thread basically not sharing any thoughts other than some theory on Glossy's punishment I couldn't really make sense of. And now, seemingly, you only want to enter the thread to make another confusing post, voting for me, without commenting on anything else.
This looks bad for you.
About towns being truthful, I can show you example of my most recent game that I lied about having a NA that made me able to check if someone had a PR or not. I used it on someone who had outed himself from having a town PR - claiming that he had a PR. So in cases where he would be scum(which means he would likely have a PR in the setup of that game), it could had made him make up a fake claim for a town PR, which I know he couldn't have. In this case, he was town - so when he yelled enough about my claim of him having a PR being a lie, I told the truth and put him towards town, based on his reactions to my claim. You can see it here:
http://www.mafiauniverse.com/threads/1000-Internet-Lyfe?p=197307&viewfull=1#post197307
So yes, I do lie as town, if I find it reasonable that it can be beneficial
as of right now, I'd say there's best chance of finding scums in here:
kennigit
cuth
mat93
xym
those are lynches for 4 days, hopefully things should get more clear over that amount of time, but in case not, I'd say at this time, that the rest I'd suspect the most are:
landlubber
murska
Backwards logic(I took a good look at his first post, #113, and I tend to agree with Visor that the last part of it, seemed very off(he takes an obvious joke vote from someone very seriously)).
on other notes, from what I made yesterday:
edse's intro is actually fairly towny. He complains about me posting a lot - that is generally a towny thing to do, complaining in that way, in the very first post. Also, both visor and Pouter also complained about me in their first posts, kinda in the same way as he did, and they were both town, while also both writing their posts after him(so he can't have copy/pasted their opening style)
Takhisis is heavily towards town for me both because of his tone, how he comments on other people, but also the first line in his first post #198 - where he comments to a quote of lohrenswald that there is no flavor texts in pms. Scums usually avoid comment on anything related with pms, and I highly doubt they would make that their first line in the game, in any case
Cass is also heavily towards town, he suspicion of me, when she thought I was Alette, seems legit - while her further questions for me, has also felt like a town actually trying to figure out my alignment. Add to that, that she has been fairly focused on solving and answering questions, at the times she has been in thread.
Zack is probably my biggest town read at this point, he had complaints early in the game that felt very towny(especially the one in response to me saying that activity was small and people weren't doing enough solving, which Visor did in much the same way, also being town).
Glossysushi I believe still is town too - her D2 not as good as her D1, but yeah, she wouldn't be my choice for lynch on any day soon, considering what other options there is. Also, I find it towny how she now twice ends up writing posts after EOD and edits with frustration when she realizes(on D1 her post were within allowed time, though, but she still seemed to think she had posted on wrong time). Also, her punishment isn't really much of a punishment if she's scum - considering how it's actually just +EV for scums to have an official reason to not be posting. She loses vote though, but that stills a tiny punishment for what I consider her semi-spewing herself town.
KingMorgan has had some posts that I've liked, especially the one were he said "I drunkenly believe that Lassie is too scatty to be a scum"(or something along those lines) - that felt like a towny thought process from him.
I noticed that some people complained about me moving Choxorn away from my scum suspects from D1 to D2 - I'm still not too sure about him, but compared to those I have/and had listed as scums now and on D2, he's not really someone I'd lynch above any of those. Actually the vibes I get from his posts on later reads of the thread, feels fine - although his play style isn't too convincing.
I think the semi-afk players like Al sip, Autolycus, BSmith, Golden1Knight isn't really who we should focus on right now - not saying they should be cleared, but simply that we should pick targets who we are able to feel more sure about, than what is possible on people with that little game content. I mean, we're on D3, and haven't got just one scum yet - as it looks now, I could very well be another mislynch - so this is mostly a thought for D4 if I'm not here. Stacking votes on same target, should be a high priority on D4, if we don't get a scum lynched today(which is the case every time I get lynched, fyi)
kennigit
cuth
mat93
xym
those are lynches for 4 days, hopefully things should get more clear over that amount of time, but in case not, I'd say at this time, that the rest I'd suspect the most are:
landlubber
murska
Backwards logic(I took a good look at his first post, #113, and I tend to agree with Visor that the last part of it, seemed very off(he takes an obvious joke vote from someone very seriously)).
on other notes, from what I made yesterday:
edse's intro is actually fairly towny. He complains about me posting a lot - that is generally a towny thing to do, complaining in that way, in the very first post. Also, both visor and Pouter also complained about me in their first posts, kinda in the same way as he did, and they were both town, while also both writing their posts after him(so he can't have copy/pasted their opening style)
Takhisis is heavily towards town for me both because of his tone, how he comments on other people, but also the first line in his first post #198 - where he comments to a quote of lohrenswald that there is no flavor texts in pms. Scums usually avoid comment on anything related with pms, and I highly doubt they would make that their first line in the game, in any case
Cass is also heavily towards town, he suspicion of me, when she thought I was Alette, seems legit - while her further questions for me, has also felt like a town actually trying to figure out my alignment. Add to that, that she has been fairly focused on solving and answering questions, at the times she has been in thread.
Zack is probably my biggest town read at this point, he had complaints early in the game that felt very towny(especially the one in response to me saying that activity was small and people weren't doing enough solving, which Visor did in much the same way, also being town).
Glossysushi I believe still is town too - her D2 not as good as her D1, but yeah, she wouldn't be my choice for lynch on any day soon, considering what other options there is. Also, I find it towny how she now twice ends up writing posts after EOD and edits with frustration when she realizes(on D1 her post were within allowed time, though, but she still seemed to think she had posted on wrong time). Also, her punishment isn't really much of a punishment if she's scum - considering how it's actually just +EV for scums to have an official reason to not be posting. She loses vote though, but that stills a tiny punishment for what I consider her semi-spewing herself town.
KingMorgan has had some posts that I've liked, especially the one were he said "I drunkenly believe that Lassie is too scatty to be a scum"(or something along those lines) - that felt like a towny thought process from him.
I noticed that some people complained about me moving Choxorn away from my scum suspects from D1 to D2 - I'm still not too sure about him, but compared to those I have/and had listed as scums now and on D2, he's not really someone I'd lynch above any of those. Actually the vibes I get from his posts on later reads of the thread, feels fine - although his play style isn't too convincing.
I think the semi-afk players like Al sip, Autolycus, BSmith, Golden1Knight isn't really who we should focus on right now - not saying they should be cleared, but simply that we should pick targets who we are able to feel more sure about, than what is possible on people with that little game content. I mean, we're on D3, and haven't got just one scum yet - as it looks now, I could very well be another mislynch - so this is mostly a thought for D4 if I'm not here. Stacking votes on same target, should be a high priority on D4, if we don't get a scum lynched today(which is the case every time I get lynched, fyi)
It's a bit frustrating that I can't put up a high confidence POE, at least right now - but I might get to that, if I get time to do a full read(yesterday(irl) were only first 20 pages and things that was going on in the thread of that day).
Also, I'd appreciate everyone else to actually do some work at this point. It might be that I was a bit too early to complain about it on D1 - but we're on D3 now, and I think there's lots to look back at and analyze. If I'm going to be mislynched today, then my hopes aren't too high, even if my reads on scum suspects should all be correct.
Vote: Kennigit
Says he has been following the game after his death, enters the game as replacement, yet only writes some nonsense about Glossysushi's punishment, and then later shows up only to vote and talk about me.
I believe he'd have at least a little more to share right away, if he subbed in as a town who have been following the game since he died in his first player slot.
Says he has been following the game after his death, enters the game as replacement, yet only writes some nonsense about Glossysushi's punishment, and then later shows up only to vote and talk about me.
I believe he'd have at least a little more to share right away, if he subbed in as a town who have been following the game since he died in his first player slot.
Lohrenswald
世界的 bottom ranked physicist
Heptupal posting oh my word
I don't know what Heptupal means, but I'm having a gut feel it isn't you appreciating me writing what I did.
Anyway, I'm looking forward to cases of your own. You can present your guess at who the scums are, then we can compare in end game who had most correct. If you're up for some competition(and are town, as I believe).
If anyone else wants in on this competition, just put a list of the 5 you are the most suspicious of, and we see who had most scums, eventually.
Lohrenswald
世界的 bottom ranked physicist
single double triple quadruple quintuple hexuple heptuple
guess I spelled it wrong first time around
Anyway all your "shenanigans" make me uneasy, so that's my main read right now
but as for top five mafia leanings
you
glossysushi
kennigit
choxorn
Al Sipsclar
maybe Takhisis
mostly because of metastuff from previous games (notably choxorn had me completely played a few games back)
not the best post but I'm technically busy (trying to push all obligations into the future at this point)
single double triple quadruple quintuple hexuple heptuple
guess I spelled it wrong first time around
Anyway all your "shenanigans" make me uneasy, so that's my main read right now
but as for top five mafia leanings
you
glossysushi
kennigit
choxorn
Al Sipsclar
maybe Takhisis
mostly because of metastuff from previous games (notably choxorn had me completely played a few games back)
not the best post but I'm technically busy (trying to push all obligations into the future at this point)
Even though I can't follow your top 5 all that much, this is still a good post(looks towny, the way you made it and explained it) - everyone else should make a top 5 too. It doesn't have to be people you are sure are scum, just those you think are most likely.
In the shadows I lurk.
Is it too much to ask for your reasoning?
Also, what other reads do you have
Yes, the Kennigit I'm suspicious is obviously the one who's alive, meaning Newyn was also a scum..
Anyway, I'd like to hear if you're planning on actually contributing with anything? All you've done so far is sponging reads already made by others and commenting on "main events" in the thread. Aren't you willing to play this game? Right now, I have no reason to consider you town, based on what I've seen.
Cuth, I'd like you to be more vocal - let us see a case on Mat93, because if he's the one you suspect the most, obviously you're aware that it isn't going to happen as things are going now. Why is Mat93 the person you want to see lynched the most?
Also, I'd like to see a top5 list of suspects from you, like the one Lohren and me have made.
Is this just words, or are you going to follow up on it by actually participating yourself?
Why can you get behind a lynch of me very easily? You said yesterday that I were probably too scatty to be scum. Did that change simply because I was wrong on Visor?
Also I'd like to see a case from you on Al Sipscar, which shouldn't be too hard, since he has so few posts.
