Estebonrober
Deity
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2017
- Messages
- 6,023
Sin taxes disproportionately effect the poor though and maybe, MAYBE, discourage behavior. I'd argue the drop in tobacco use was less about the tax and more about the health reality when a generation finally came up seeing the images day in and out of its effects.
One of the primary reasons I've switched sides in the last two decades is this consistent propensity to punish the broken in our society. If someone has made a series of bad choices it seems logically unethical to make it tougher for them in general.
Of course I've long since given up on the idea that markets are rational and that was well after I woke to how irrational almost all people are. . .
Again the primary problem is the wealthy just aren't paying the same tax rate as everyone else on their assets.
One of the primary reasons I've switched sides in the last two decades is this consistent propensity to punish the broken in our society. If someone has made a series of bad choices it seems logically unethical to make it tougher for them in general.
Of course I've long since given up on the idea that markets are rational and that was well after I woke to how irrational almost all people are. . .
Again the primary problem is the wealthy just aren't paying the same tax rate as everyone else on their assets.