[Development] Map Suggestions

About the Brazilian Southeast, with the original map bellow.

Spoiler :
SE Original.JPG


Before discuss the changes that I'm proposing, I wanna highlight some guidelines. This region would be probably the core of Brazilan civilization, with the largest and most productive cities. After the decline of sugar economy on Northeast following the increasing Caribbean competition, almost all economic cycles of relevance ocurred in this area, starting with the gold and precious metal production in Minas Gerais during the 18th century, the coffe by the 19th to mid-20th century and the industrialization (both centered mostly in São Paulo) starting by the 1930s. In political terms, the colonial administrative center was transferred from Salvador to Rio de Janeiro in mid-18th century; the city was also briefly the capital of the Portuguese Empire in 1808-1821. With the independance (which the region in a whole supported), Rio became capital of Brazilian Empire and was the largest city during much of the 19th and early 20th centuries. With the establishment of the republic, in 1889, the political balance shifted to Minas Gerais (then the most populous state) and São Paulo, both which maintained an informal alliance which ruled the country until 1930. Since then, São Paulo became the most populous, industrial and wealthy state (42 million people) in Brazil, with Minas (20 million) and Rio (17 million) following. As such, one of my guidelines in doing the changes here was to allow at least three big cities.

My suggestions are these:

Spoiler :

SE.JPG


1) Added a land title 1NW of Rio de Janeiro. I think that it didn't affect the shape of the continent much and, on the positive side, offers a precious title of land to Rio work.
2) rearranged the mountains and included several hills to make more geographically accurate. Minas Gerais is a quite hilly state, with mountain ranges in the borders with São Paulo, Rio and Espírito Santo and some of the highest peaks in the country.
3) I've also rearranged the rivers. Made the Paraná river and its tributaries more lookalike its real course, including the rivers (from north to south) Parnaíba, Grande, Tietê and Paranapanema. These rivers are the main tributaries of Paraná river and are important waterways with several hydroplants; they also define the borders between the states of Goiás, Minas Gerais, São Paulo and Paraná. The inclusion of Tietê is also relevant for both historical and gameplay reasons. The river was the most important inland waterway during the time of bandeirantes explorations, which eventually led to the expansion of the colony to nowadays inland Brazil, and its also today used as a waterway to connect the grain-producing states in Central-West region with the port of Santos (the largest and most important of the country). Gameplay-wise, the inclusion of the river helps São Paulo become the production powerhouse it should be.
4) changed grasslands and plains to make the distinction between vegetation the region. In the coastal region we have the Atlantic Forest, which originally covered most of Brazil's coastal regions. It suffered extensive deforestion in the last centuries, which is why is mostly represented by trees and not rainforest (as a side-effect in gameplay perspective, also helps the development of the cities). The plain titles represent the Cerrado, a savanna-like vegetation common in all central Brazil.

Resources:

Spoiler :
RSE.JPG


Pre-colonial:
Dyes (1N of Vitória): represents the Brazilwood exploration and is already discussed in the post above.
Gems (1NE of Belo Horizonte): represents diamond mining in the region around Diamantina. Developed only during colonial times (17th-18th centuries) these were one of the most important products explored in Brazil by that time. In fact, the operations here were so huge that the Portuguese crown directly tried to control the mining to avoid overproduction and decreased prices. Most of the diamond mines are nowadays exhausted, although there are still some mining of semi-precious stones.
Gold (1E of Belo Horizonte): represents the gold found by the bandeirantes in late 17th century that triggered the colonization and economic mining cycle based in Minas Gerais. By the 18th century Minas was the most populous and prosperous region in the colony.
Iron (1W of Belo Horizonte): represents the large iron reserves in central Minas Gerais, which were historically speaking the main region of iron ore mining in Brazil.
Fish (2E of Rio de Janeiro): In the original map there was a crab resource close. There is commercial fishing in this area and, gameplay wise, it also helps Rio to grow to the appropriate size.

Colonial:
Sugar (2W of São Paulo): Some of the oldest (and even the first) Portuguese cities in the Americas were located in coast of São Paulo and had a somewhat successful colonial economy based on sugar production in 16th century. Sugar plantations continued to exist in the state area during the following centuries and with the decline of coffe economy by the 1950s, São Paulo's farming focused again in sugar and the state became the leading producer in Brazil today, especially in the ethanol production.
Cattle (1S of Belo Horizonte): represents both the cattle production during colonial times and the dairy production in Minas Gerais since 19th century. As a fun-fact, the first Brazilian republic (1889-1930) was nicknamed Coffe with Milk because it was politically dominated by São Paulo (coffe) and Minas (milk).
Coffe (1NE of Rio de Janeiro): represents the oldest areas of coffe production (18th century) in Rio de Janeiro/Espírito Santo states.

Post-independence and modern:
2 Coffe (1NW and 3W of São Paulo): São Paulo became the leading producer of coffe in the world in late 19th and first half of 20th centuries.
Bananas (1SW of São Paulo): if I recall correctly, there was a bananas spawn here in the old map. I think that the main ideia is to represent the food production in São Paulo (the state is an important producer of beens, rice, cassava, corn, orange and other cultures) and allow the city to grow appropriately, thus, it could be also any other food resource. Even though, the bananas are located in a historically correct area, as the southern São Paulo state is known for this production. Either way, I think that the resource should spawn only in post-independence era (1800 CE), as São Paulo was a relatively small city until mid-late 19th century.
Aluminium (1SW of Belo Horizonte): Brazil has some of the largest bauxite reserves in the world; many of the mines are located in Minas.
Rare Earths (1NW of Belo Horizonte) : represents the reserves of those materials in Brazil. These mining operations were only devolped during WW2, as the alliance treaty with US specified that Brazil would supply the american war industry with those materials. Brazil was one of the leading producers of rare earth in the 1940s and still has some reserves nowadays.
Oil (2S1E of Rio de Janeiro): represents the main oil-producing areas in Brazil, where are located the largest reserves on seabed. It became quite important since late 1970s and Brazil today is one of the major crude oil producers in the world.
 
Last edited:
Hey, I don't know that anyone suggested this but I think that Hong Kong is a good candidate for lagoon. The lagoon would be on the eastern side of the Pearl river delta and Guangzhou could be 2N or 2N1W of there. It is very much a city built on/in a harbour and it would also give space for both Guangzhou and Hong Kong. That said, it might look strange to have a city jutting out from South China like that.
Can you show a world builder example of this? I can't seem to make it work in any way that looks right.
 
Can you show a world builder example of this? I can't seem to make it work in any way that looks right.
I hadn't tested it out but I'll see what I can come up with when I get the map branch up and running again.
 
First off, I think I have a different texture pack going on so I'm not sure how the lagoon looks aesthetically on your end...

Here are a couple ideas: For me the issue seems that Hainan is perfectly placed in relation to most major geographic features but still seems to be getting in the way of placing a Hong Kong lagoon tile. Perhaps the Pearl River Delta is not far enough East. That said, Southwest of the PR is not historically very important so it makes more sense that there is "too little" space Southwest than Northeast of the river. Here are my ideas:

This one I like because it keeps Guangzhou a coastal city until when/if Hong Kong is founded. Then whoever owns Hong Kong would almost certainly control Guangzhou's coastal waters making it effectively landlocked. That's pretty historical I think. So the GREEN SQUARE is one grass turned to coast and the RED SQUARE is one coast turned to Lagoon. City placements are okay, and allows for a somewhat accurate placement of both GZ and HK on the same map. It's fairly aesthetically pleasing too. Downside the PRD is even further West than the current version I guess but as I stated above, West of the PRD isn't super important historically. Other downside the delta is huge, but it is a pretty big delta IRL.

Spoiler :

Hong Kong Lagoon.png



This one is definitely my least favourite. Until such a time that Hong Kong is founded the river beside the lagoon tile is pretty jarring... but maybe that's different with the other texture pack. Other downside GZ is fully landlocked forever even if founded on the sugar as I assume a lagoon tile is treated as a land tile exclusively. Upside is the city placements in relation to major geographic features is good.

Spoiler :

Hong Kong Lagoon 3.png



Last one GREEN SQUARE add one grasslands tile, RED SQUARE add one lagoon tile. This one is also not great, HK will probably end up looking very odd jutting out from the landmass and Guangzhou is still fully landlocked forever. Plus side the cities are well placed and it makes HK quite distinctively separate. The delta is better placed and looks good. It also gives access to at least one city (Hong Kong) Hainan, though historically incorrect.

Spoiler :

Hong Kong Lagoon 2.png



Overall I think the first is best. Any other ideas?

Ignore any missing resources. Having right-click troubles so I have to use the erase button.
 
Last edited:
Here's option 1 in action. I think it looks quite good to me. Lots of tiles for both to work. Massive sea access for HK.

Spoiler :

Hong Kong Lagoon in action.png

 
South Brazil and Uruguay, with the original map bellow:

Spoiler :
S Original.JPG


This region was colonized relatively late when compared with other coastal zones in Brazil (like the mentioned Northeast and Southeast above) or even the other side of the river Plate (Buenos Aires and other cities on Paraná-Paraguay rivers) for two main reasons: the lack of any mineral wealth of great significance and hostile indigenous peoples (especially the Charrúa in present-day Uruguay). As such, until 17-18th centuries the region was sparsely inhabited, wtih small Portuguese settlements in the coastal areas, gauchos (Spanish mestizo cattle herders) in the inland plains and jesuitic missions trying to convert the indigenous peoples. The area was originally Spanish (as agreed in the Tordesillas Treaty), but the Portuguese founded several forts and settlements in search for natural and easily defensive borders (i.e., the rivers Paraná-Plate) between colonies. This made the area a warfare zone for much of 18th century, with neverending changes in the borders. By early 19th century, amist the Latin American independence process, the Portuguese crown (then seated in Rio de Janeiro) seized all this contested zone, which became Brazilian with the independence of the country. The originally Spanish settlers in present-Uruguay, however, wished to be part of Argentina, which led to a war in 1825-1928 between Brazilians and Argentines that ended with the creation of Uruguay as buffer state. In the 19th century there was numerous wars in the area (both civil, like the Ragamuffin War, and interstate, like the first phase of the War of The Triple Alliance), but at the end of the century the region flourished with a strong cattle and grain economy that was fueled by massive European (mainly Italian and German) immigration. Nowadays, Uruguay is one of most democratic, peaceful and prosperous nation in Latin America, while the Southern Brazil have a strong industrial-agricultural economy with one of the highest HDI of the country.

The new map with proposed changes:

Spoiler :
S.JPG


1) I changed the mountains to hills in nowadays Paraná state, as that region doesn't have any significant peaks. The places of higher elevation in the region are more close to the coast and actually south, in Santa Catarina and northern Rio Grande do Sul, where there are few peaks of 1800 mts and is the only region in all Brazil that snow (only a few times in the winter, though). We could add two titles of Mountains in 1W of Curitiba and Florianópolis, but I think that the hills are more appropriate given that the area is mostly a plateau.
2) added several forests and rainforests. In the coast, the forests represents the already mentioned Atlantic Forest, while the pine forest represents the araucaria vegetation common in the region. The rainforest are in the lowland tropical areas close to Paraná river. The far-western regions of Santa Catarina and Paraná were covered with jungle and colonization of these areas ocurred only in the early 20th century.
3) added plains and steppes titles in Rio Grande do Sul and Uruguay, representing the pampas.

Resources:
Spoiler :
RS.JPG


Colonial:
Cattle (2W of Porto Alegre, 1N of Montevideo): cattle herding, introduced by the Spanish in early 16th century, was the main economic activity during colonial times and was quite important in the identity of the gauchos.
Horse (2N1W of Montevideo): another important herd introduced by Spanish settlers. Rio Grande do Sul provided the main cavalry forces for Brazilian Army in the 19th century, recruited from the gauchos in the pampas. This location also could have an interesting perspective on gameplay, creating a zone of friction between Portuguese-Spanish players for horses in a first moment, and between Brazilian-Argentine players after the independence.
Sheep (1NW of Montevideo): represents Uruguayan wool industry, one of the main products of the country.

Post-independence and modern:
Tobacco (1NE of Montevideo): Represents the main areas of tobbaco plantation in Rio Grande do Sul, which are the most productive in all Brazil.
Rice (1SW of Porto Alegre): Rio Grande do Sul is known for its cereal production (soybeans, wheat, corn and rice), which supply much of Brazilian domestic market. I chose the rice because of its importance to Brazilian culinary, but it could be a corn resource.
Wine (1W of Porto Alegre): represents the wine production in Rio Grande do Sul highlands.
Coal (1W of Florianópolis): I have to admit that I was divided about the inclusion of coal here. It is actually where the main coal reserves of Brazil are located, but it is important to note that it does not have the quality of the resource mined, for exemple, in the Andes or Australia. Historically speaking, the poor coal quality was an obstacle to the devolopment of metallurgy industry and wider industrialization in Brazil, which was dependent to British coal imports for much of 19th and early 20th centuries. By mid-20th century, however, technological innovations made this coal more productive and nowadays these reserves are widely used both for industry as well eletrical energy production, which is why I decided in favor of the inclusion.
Corn (2W1N of Curitiba): Similar to the Rio Grande do Sul case, Paraná state also has a substantial cereal production, although was only fully developed by early 20th century. The state is one of the main corn producers in Brazil.
Pigs (2W of Curitiba): Paraná has also a large meat export industry, based mostly in pigs and chicken.
 
Last edited:
South Brazil and Uruguay, with the original map bellow:
This thread did a whole bunch of work on the region around Paraguay several months ago. That conversation starts with my own post here--
The biggest issues I see with the S. America changes revolves around Paraguay.
And concluded with Leoreth's post here--
That's a significant improvement, exactly what should be coming out of this thread. Great work everyone!
The final version of Paraguay can be seen in the post immediately before Leoreth's; it was created by TJDowling, and looks like this.

Not sure how much that'd affect your changes to Uruguay/Brazil, but it would affect the placement of rivers and certain resources.
 
This is still great, thanks. I will add it to the list of South American suggestions and then incorporate them into each other.
 
First of all, thank you for the feedback!

I remember seeing this work (and also the ones around Argentina) and used then as base for many of my suggestions. I will disscuss especifically the area around Paraguay soon, but I can anticipate that I agree that this region is difficult to properly design and represent realisticaly on the map.

The main concern here, in what revolves South Brazil and Uruguay, is the shape of Uruguay river, which is the western border between these areas and Argentina. I think that the biggest issue is the course of Paraná and Uruguay rivers, especially around Argentine state of Missiones.

Spoiler :

bacia platina.png



As I see, in TJDowling suggestion gaves preference to represent Ibicuí river over upper Uruguay river, given that Paraná and Uruguay would merge their course on the uranium title. Although Ibicuí is the main tributary of Uruguay river, I don't think its inclusion shold have priority over the proper Uruguay river, given the its historical and geographical importance.

My suggestion here is to represent both the upper Uruguay and Paraná rivers, with a slighty change on the course of Paraná 1N to avoid this merge. This will deform the Argentine-Paraguay border and Paraguay shape, however will mantain the Argentine Mesopotamia surronded by both rivers as should be. Missiones is small and probably shouldn't be represented in that size, but in the end I think this is a matter of preference and Leoreth will decide what he thinks is best. I do feel, however, that representing a territory from a country present in the game should have priority over one who isn't.

But I'm open for suggestions. I will not go Königsberg on this matter.:lol:
 
Last edited:
About Brazilian Central-West region:

The original map:

Spoiler :
CW original.JPG


Historically speaking, the colonization of this large area began in late 17th and early 18th century when the bandeirantes found alluvial gold in present-day states of Mato Grosso and Goiás. That triggered a mini-boom that broght settlers and Portuguese interest in the region (Portugal even ceded contested areas to the Spanish in Platine region to obtain recognition of this territory as her own), but, unfortunately for them, there were only small quantities of gold and the mining soon exhausted the reserves. The main economic activity in the area became cattle herding (aind it is still today quite important) and was sparsely colonized and underdevoloped in the next centuries. There were several areas where the border between Brazil and her neighbors were ill defined and communications with capital Rio de Janeiro was mostly inexistent. As a good exemple, the route between Rio and Cuiabá, capital of Mato Grosso, was the Plata, Paraná and Paraguay rivers, because it simply didn't exist any inlands roads to there until early 20th century. When Paraguay invaded the area during the War of the Triple Alliance, the Brazilian force sent to liberate the region took two years to arrive. After the war, the Brazilians took all contested region with Paraguay where they cultivated yerba mate, which gave a new economic impetus to the region, but still the Central-West continued to be underpopulated and underdevolped. The scenario began to change with the founding of Brasília (1960) which gave new impetus and broght millions of Brazilians to the region; by late 1970s, with support of the government, large areas began producing grains, especially soybeans. Today the Central-West is, by far, the largest producer of grains and beef in Brazil, although the region is still least populated area of the country.

The suggestions on the map:

Spoiler :
CW.JPG


1) made the area more flat. The Brazilian central plateau are somewhat elevated, but there isn't any mountain ranges of any significance.
2) made much of the area drier, to represent the cerrado. Also removed several jungle and marsh titles in this sense.
3) remade the swamps in the border with Paraguay and Bolivia, the Pantanal.
4) added several titles of rainforest in place of former jungle areas. The idea is to allow the movement of a few units next to major waterways and the founding of a few historically important cities.
5) remade many rivers, especially those of Amazon basin. I will explain the changes in more detail when I discuss that region.

Resources:

Spoiler :
RCW.JPG


Pre-Colonial:
Tea (2S of Campo Grande): represents the yerba mate cultivation since indigenous times.

Colonial:
Cattle (1NE of Campo Grande): represents the cattle herding existent since colonial times.

Post-Independence and modern:
Corn: (2W of Brasília): represents some of the grain farms which became more proeminently by mid-late 20th century.
Note: we can also add an extra cattle near Brasília/Goiânia region and perhaps two grain resources (millet?) near Cuiabá to represent the scale of nowadays farming (especially soybeans) in the region. I didn't included because, considering the time scale of the mod, these resources would appear much late ingame to have any significance. As a side-effect, these inclusions would also allow the cities in the region overly grow, which is not historically correct. Brasília (2,6 million), Goiânia (1,3 million), Campo Grande (750k) and Cuiabá (550k) are the most populous in the region nowadays.
 
Last edited:
Brazilian North, or the Amazon, with the original map bellow:

Eastern North:

Spoiler :
EN Original.JPG


Western North:

Spoiler :
WN Original.JPG



Amazon was claimed by the Spanish in the Tordesillas Treaty and explored in the 16th century, when they hoped to find the mythical city of El Dorado. It is interesting to note that we know nowadays that the region had some indigenous sophisticated urban settlements, although many of them were abandoned by the time of European exploration. After Orellana expedition, which sailed by the entire Amazon river, the Spanish decided to left the area unnocupied and focus their colonization efforts elsewhere where gold abundant. By early 17th century, Amazon delta was often visited by Portuguese, French, Dutch and English sailors and merchants and they built several trade posts and few forts; worried with that foreign presence, the Spanish crown (it was the time of the Iberian Union) sent Portuguese military expeditions that finally established a permant colonization by the 1620s under Portuguese supervision. The main economic activity was the so-called drogas do sertão (literally translated as "sertão drugs", basically nuts, spices and tropical fruits) and cocoa, but the region was not particularly wealthy and colonization was a slow process. The area was sparsely populated and quite poor until the first rubber boom by late-19th century, the most prosperous economic cycle in the region in history. The rubber boom, however, declined in 1910s when faced increasing competition of Dutch and British plantations in Southeast Asia, but there was a new and brief second boom during WW2, when rubber production there received considerable US investments. By late-20th century, the region experienced some industrialization process (especially in Manaus) and mining gained importance with the discovery of large mineral reserves in Pará.

The key to undestand the Amazon region is the river and its tributaries. As such, I tried to make the changes in the map based on them.

Spoiler :
amazon basin.png


Thus, in addition to Amazon, the main rivers which guide the map proposal are:
North bank, from coast to inland: Trombetas, Negro (plus Branco), Japurá, Putomayo (Peruvian) and Tigre (Peru and Ecuador).
South bank, from coast to inland: Tocantins, Araguaia, Xingu, Tapajós (plus Juruena and Teles Pires), Madeira (plus Machado), Guaporé (plus Mamoré, including Bolivian tributaries Grande, Beni and Madre de Dios), Purus, Juruá, Ucayali and Marañón (both in Peru, the latter was the original Spanish name of Amazon river).

The result is this:

Eastern North Brazil:

Spoiler :
EN.JPG



Western North Brazil:

Spoiler :
WN.JPG



1) changed the course of many rivers. There is some distortions (like in the Xingu course) though, as is quite a nightmare to position all the important rivers properly without merging them.
2) changed plains titles to grasslands, which make sense since these areas are tropical jungles.
3) placed a lot of rainforest and jungle titles to represent the Amazon rainforest. I was suprised to see so little jungle/rainforest titles in Eastern Amazon region in the original map. Similar to what I did in the Central-West Brazil, I placed rainforest titles next to important rivers to allow movement in the major waterways and founding historically important cities.
4) added a land tittle, covered with jungle, 1N of Belém, to represent the Marajó island. It's a pure aesthetic addition, to make the coast look more accurate. Marajó is way too big (has a comparable size to Switzerland) to be only an island feature like in the original map.
5) added several hills titles in the borders with Guyanas and Venezuela to represent the Guiana Shield. It is in this region that lies the highest Brazilian peak, the Pico da Neblina. I took off, however, the isolated mountain tittle near Guyana/Suriname, as I didn't found reference for any relevant mountains/peaks there.

Resources:

Spoiler :

REN.JPG

RWN.JPG



Pre-colonial:
2 Spices (1S of Belém and another 1N of Manaus): represents vegetal extractivism of the drogas do sertão, which was the main economic activity during colonial times.
Cocoa (1S of Manaus): represents the cocoa production in Amazon region and was also important during colonial times

Post-Independence and modern:
4 Rubber (2E, 2W1N and 2W1S of Manaus, plus 1N of Rio Branco): they represent the major areas of rubber extraction. Brazil had a virtual monopoly of natural rubber extraction in late-19th century, which is why I decided to include such number of resources. Manaus was one of the richest cities in Brazil by then, where the rubber barons lived. Today you could visit several impressive art nouveau buildings built with Italian marble in the city. The rubber near Rio Branco represents its production in the Acre state. This area was originally Bolivian, but the Brazilians annexed in early 20th century in a similar manner that US annexed Texas. Perhaps we could also add another rubber near Porto Velho (or, alternativelly, switch one rubber from Manaus to there) to represent the production in the present-day Rondônia, northwest Mato Grosso and Bolivian Amazon. It didn't have the same importance than other areas, but it was relevant locally.
Iron (1W of Palmas): represents the large iron ore reserves in Carajás region in Southern Pará. Nowadays this is the largest and most productive mining area in Brazil. I included as post-independence resource because it wasn't explored unitl mid-20th century. There was also a quite large and infamous gold mine there, now exhausted, in Serra Pelada.
Aluminium: (1N of Palmas): the same Carajás region has substantial bauxite reserves, which are also explored alongside the iron ore mines.
 
Last edited:
Brazilian North, or the Amazon, with the original map bellow:

Eastern North:



Western North:



Amazon was claimed by the Spanish in the Tordesillas Treaty and explored in the 16th century, when they hoped to find the mythical city of El Dorado. It is interesting to note that we know nowadays that the region had some indigenous sophisticated urban settlements, although many of them were abandoned by the time of European exploration. After Orellana expedition, which sailed by the entire Amazon river, the Spanish decided to left the area unnocupied and focus their colonization efforts elsewhere where gold abundant. By early 17th century, Amazon delta was often visited by Portuguese, French, Dutch and English sailors and merchants and they built several trade posts and few forts; worried with that foreign presence, the Spanish crown (it was the time of the Iberian Union) sent Portuguese military expeditions that finally established a permant colonization by the 1620s under Portuguese supervision. The main economic activity was the so-called drogas do sertão (literally translated as "sertão drugs", basically nuts, spices and tropical fruits) and cocoa, but the region was not particularly wealthy and colonization was a slow process. The area was sparsely populated and quite poor until the first rubber boom by late-19th century, the most prosperous economic cycle in the region in history. The rubber boom, however, declined in 1910s when faced increasing competition of Dutch and British plantations in Southeast Asia, but there was a new and brief second boom during WW2, when rubber production there received considerable US investments. By late-20th century, the region experienced some industrialization process (especially in Manaus) and mining gained importance with the discovery of large mineral reserves in Pará.

The key to undestand the Amazon region is the river and its tributaries. As such, I tried to make the changes in the map based on them.



Thus, in addition to Amazon, the main rivers which guide the map proposal are:
North bank, from coast to inland: Trombetas, Negro (plus Branco), Japurá, Putomayo (Peruvian) and Tigre (Peru and Ecuador).
South bank, from coast to inland: Tocantins, Araguaia, Xingu, Tapajós (plus Juruena and Teles Pires), Madeira (plus Machado), Guaporé (plus Mamoré, including Bolivian tributaries Grande, Beni and Madre de Dios), Purus, Juruá, Ucayali and Marañón (both in Peru, the latter was the original Spanish name of Amazon river).

The result is this:

Eastern North Brazil:



Western North Brazil:



1) changed the course of many rivers. There is some distortions (like in the Xingu course) though, as is quite a nightmare to position all the important rivers properly without merging them.
2) changed plains titles to grasslands, which make sense since these areas are tropical jungles.
3) placed a lot of rainforest and jungle titles to represent the Amazon rainforest. I was suprised to see so little jungle/rainforest titles in Eastern Amazon region in the original map. Similar to what I did in the Central-West Brazil, I placed rainforest titles next to important rivers to allow movement in the major waterways and founding historically important cities.
4) added a land tittle, covered with jungle, 1N of Belém, to represent the Marajó island. It's a pure aesthetic addition, to make the coast look more accurate. Marajó is way too big (has a comparable size to Switzerland) to be only an island feature like in the original map.
5) added several hills titles in the borders with Guyanas and Venezuela to represent the Guiana Shield. It is in this region that lies the highest Brazilian peak, the Pico da Neblina. I took off, however, the isolated mountain tittle near Guyana/Suriname, as I didn't found reference for any relevant mountains/peaks there.

Resources:



Pre-colonial:
2 Spices (1S of Belém and another 1N of Manaus): represents vegetal extractivism of the drogas do sertão, which was the main economic activity during colonial times.
Cocoa (1S of Manaus): represents the cocoa production in Amazon region and was also important during colonial times

Post-Independence and modern:
4 Rubber (2E, 2W1N and 2W1S of Manaus, plus 1N of Rio Branco): they represent the major areas of rubber extraction. Brazil had a virtual monopoly of natural rubber extraction in late-19th century, which is why I decided to include such number of resources. Manaus was one of the richest cities in Brazil by then, where the rubber barons lived. Today you could visit several impressive art nouveau buildings built with Italian marble in the city. The rubber near Rio Branco represents its production in the Acre state. This area was originally Bolivian, but the Brazilians annexed in early 20th century in a similar manner that US annexed Texas. Perhaps we could also add another rubber near Porto Velho (or, alternativelly, switch one rubber from Manaus to there) to represent the production in the present-day Rondônia, northwest Mato Grosso and Bolivian Amazon. It didn't have the same importance than other areas, but it was relevant locally.
Iron (1W of Palmas): represents the large iron ore reserves in Carajás region in Southern Pará. Nowadays this is the largest and most productive mining area in Brazil. I included as post-independence resource because it wasn't explored unitl mid-20th century. There was also a quite large and infamous gold mine there, now exhausted, in Serra Pelada.
Aluminium: (1N of Palmas): the same Carajás region has substantial bauxite reserves, which are also explored alongside the iron ore mines.
Excellent! I never got around to the Amazon because it is quite a daunting task. Good work!
 
I took another look at the Philippine islands. I know it's already been revised once, but I was not really contented with it. I think since Mindanao is connected to Samar via the Surigao Strait, it would be better if they'd be connected diagonally instead. The current shape of Mindanao also looks a bit off to me, so I wanted to highlight the Caraga region in the northeast while not forsaking Davao, the main commercial hub of the superregion (as well as the bastion of the incumbent president... kidding).

With this, I reverted the general shape of the map to the one Bautos42 made in his original commit of the map. However, I studied the economic map (which was a bit hard to find online) and redid the resource spread in the archipelago.

Spoiler Philippine archipelago revisions :
Civ4ScreenShot0343.png

Civ4ScreenShot0342.png



At first, I imagined Manila would be on the Sugar tile there, and I wanted to move it, but while it could be either tile speaking from a relative shape perspective, I think it'd be more accurate if it would be on the no-resource tile marked above. I also made Luzon and Mindanao more hilly, based on the topographic maps. There are also a total of five Islands features in the central seas of the archipelago, to represent the thousands more islands here. (The photo only shows four; I think I forgot to put an Islands feature on the Pearl resource.)

I extended the river in Luzon by 1 tile north as this represents the Cagayan River, which is the second longest in the country and is also fairly branched. This is also to irrigate the Rice I placed north of the Sugar, which represents the Banaue Rice Terraces. (More accurate to see when improved, lol) I placed an additional Copper resource in Luzon and a Cotton resource to represent the copper mining industry in the Cagayan Valley Region and the abaca and textiles industry in the Bicol Region.

I'm not entirely sure about the Clam south of Mindanao, but the fish represents the lucrative fishing industry in the adjacent SOCCSKSARGEN Region. I kept the Banana because the same region and adjacent ones are big producers of various fruits. A Cacao resource should spawn in the 1700's to represent its spread to the archipelago. Also, Davao in the recent years is the biggest producer of cacao and chocolate products.

Leaving the Philippine region, I'm not very familiar with the geographies of other areas yet so I can just suggest a few.

I think we should place a Spice resource on the Malacca tile, 1NW of the Singapore tile. It wouldn't make sense for Malacca a.k.a. Spice Islands to not control a Spice resource in its territory, I guess? (See lower left corner of image in previous spoiler)

About eastern Siberia, I'm not sure if Finbros has already touched this area already in his proposal, but I propose that the marked tile below be changed from Marsh to Grassland. I think that should be the Yakutsk tile, not either of the two Grassland tiles south of it, so it should be settleable.

Spoiler Yakutsk tile :
Civ4ScreenShot0344.png


On the Iranian Plateau, I think the highlighted Peak should be moved 1E to better approximate the shape of the Zagros Mountains region. This would also be the spot for Ecbatana as well, a major city before the Islamic Conquest. (EDIT: This is from a slightly older commit, but the concerned tiles weren't touched by the latest commit series, so it should still be the same thing.)

Spoiler Zagros Mountains :
Civ4ScreenShot0335.png


EDIT: Also including this proposal to extend the Tagus River 1 tile south, and that should be the Lisbon tile. Imho, I don't really like the new land tile recently added there; it makes Iberia look too blocky. Also, the Tagus River would also look more accurate without the additional tile. If core tile coverage for Portugal would be a concern for moving Lisbon 1S, I think the 80-20 mechanic is strong enough for this.

Spoiler Before the additional tile in Iberia :
Civ4ScreenShot0337.png


Spoiler After the additional tile in Iberia :
Civ4ScreenShot0336.png
 
Last edited:
Also, is the placement of the Horse in the central Iranian Plateau historical? I'm considering adding a grain resource in the Esfahan and especially the Shiraz area (and move some resources around), so that cities in these areas can grow some more. Also thinking of putting a Rice resource in the Caspian areas, since it is currently a staple in Iranian cuisine, though I am yet to find reliable sources on the history of rice in the region.
 
Tried to make western balkans little more "green". It being filled with arid plains looks very unrealistic.
-added some hills to central Croatia and Slovenia (both are hillly, and Slovenia is Alpine country)
-changed Central Croatia and Northeast Bosnia to Grassland as they are both forrested lands with continental climate
-changed Vojvodina (oil) to steppe, as this region along with Slavonia (1 tile east) was breadbasket of Yugoslavia
-added hills to tile representing Dalmatia (rocky place with warm mediterranean climate) and Herzegovina (same but without sea) and moved island as all big ones are situated on Croatian coast
-changed hill in northwest bosnia to tundra to represent Lika region in Croatia and Bosnian Krajina which are both sparsley populated highlands
-coniferous forrests maybe better depict Dinaric Alps, as mountain range is not really as tall and massive as Alps and Carpathians with no peak as

Hope the hills offset few grasslands here as region is not densley populated but it is not due to ecological reasons.
Didnt want to touch the resources as food would give it too much pop and Copper and Alu represent ores in Bosnia and Kosovo well (I would argue for inclusion of wheat or pig to 2 ex-Yugoslavian Steppe regions (Slavonia and Vojvodina) that could help budapest little bit).
Hope the names of million tiny regions didnt confuse anyone too much.
 

Attachments

  • West Balkans1.jpg
    West Balkans1.jpg
    335.6 KB · Views: 355
Also, is the placement of the Horse in the central Iranian Plateau historical? I'm considering adding a grain resource in the Esfahan and especially the Shiraz area (and move some resources around), so that cities in these areas can grow some more. Also thinking of putting a Rice resource in the Caspian areas, since it is currently a staple in Iranian cuisine, though I am yet to find reliable sources on the history of rice in the region.
About horses, I don't think there is a specific reason for the current location except there being space. It's just that Persia needs access to horses somewhere. If you know a better location then go ahead.

About rice, I recall that it came to Persia later than 3000 BC, but I also do not know details about when and where it was cultivated traditionally.

Don't overthink food and possible city sizes too much. I am fairly certain this needs to be balanced again along the way anyways.
 
Thanks for the feedback everyone! I still think that there is still room for improvement in Amazon region, especially in the most eastern rivers.

Anyway, now I will take my look on Paraguay and Argentina. You guys made an excelent discussion and improved that part of the map considerably before, so most of the changes that I'm proposing are about terrain features and resources.

The original map:

Spoiler :
NA Original.JPG

SA Original.JPG



Paraguay and Argentina were peripheral areas in the Spanish colonial empire, even though these regions were colonized relatively early in the 16th century. Paraguay was an isolated colony, ruled by jesuitic missions and with subsistence economy (based mostly in corn, cassava and cattle), while Argentine colonization was closely related to Peruvian mining economy. Buenos Aires was founded as a port to the silver mining in present-day Bolivia, however soon the Spanish shifted the main shipping operations to the closer port of Callao in Peru. Buenos Aires then became an contraband center, with a thriving informal trade center, while the northern and central Argentine areas produced meat and grains to the mining areas in the Peruvian viceroyalty. By mid-18th century, worried with the Portuguese expansion in South America, Spanish authorities created the viceroyalty of Río de la Plata centered in Buenos Aires, which became capital of a large area that included present-day Argentina, Paraguay, Uruguay, Bolivia and parts of Chile. After the independence, Argentina was plaged with constant political turmoil, with a constant civil warfare between the provinces and Buenos Aires for hegemony, while they also hoped to reclaim many areas which were part of the old viceroyalty, which made Argentina fight several wars with her neighbours. Paraguay, on the other side, became one of the most isolate countries in the world following its independence; by mid-1850s, fueled with profits from yerba mate exports, dictator Francisco López tried to expand Paraguay and its influence and aimed to estabish a port in the Atlantic. As a result, Brazil, Argentina and Uruguay became allies and the following War of the Triple Alliance utterly destroyed the country. After that, it became a buffer state between Brazil and Argentina, suffering with constant political turmoil and economic underdevolpment. In the 1930s, Paraguay fought and won the bloody Chaco War against Bolivia, which asserted its control over large contest areas in that region. By late 20th century Paraguay experienced some economic growth (especially with soybeans plantations), but the country is still today quite poor. Argentina, on the other side, experienced extraordinary economic growth in late-19th century, with an economy based on meat industry and grains in partnership with British Empire (the relations between the countries were so close that Argentina was informally known as the 6th Dominion of the British Empire by early 20th century), fueled with massive European immigration and territorial expansion over Patagonia (made amist an armed competition with Chile). After WW1, Argentina was one of the richest countries in the world and a leader of Latin America (even competing with the US over hemispheric leadership in the 1930s), but after the Great Depression Argentina started a slow political and economic decline, with hyperinflation crisis and political turmoil that resulted in several dictadorships. Argentina regained some of its former political influence with Mercosur and the country is still one the major economies of the region, even though she often suffers with economic problems.

Bellow you can see my map proposal:

Spoiler :
NA.JPG

CA.JPG

SA.JPG



1) changed many terrain features. In Paraguay/North Argentina, Gran Chaco is made more drier and included some rainforests in the tropical areas near Paraná river. Included deserts and semi-deserts titles next to the Andes (Northwest Argentina), as that region is mostly arid. Additionally, we could also add the new salt flat terrain here, as this area has several large and important salares. Also, the lake present (Mar Chiquita) must be a saltwater lake.
2) also changed many terrain features in Pampas and Cuyo regions, mostly adding steppes and some hills to represent the Sierras Pampeanas.
3) made several terrain changes in Patagonia and south Argentina, adding steppe and semi-desert titles. By Köppen classification, most of the area is arid cold deserts; also, Argentine expansion here is historically known as Conquista del desierto. Also changed the terrain in Falklands/Malvinas to steppe. We could also remove its forest (as the archipelago's vegetation is mostly bushes and grasslands), but I personally find the tittle covered with the forest more aesthetically good.

Resources:

Spoiler :
RNA.JPG

RCA.JPG

RSA.JPG



Pre-colonial:
Potato (1N of Asunción): represents the cassava production since indigenous times.
Tea (2E of Corrientes): represents yerba mate cultivation and nowadays it is also the main area of farming.
Clam (2SE of Bahía Blanca): Argentine coast and continental shelf are extraordinarly fishing-rich. The clam here represents the squid fishing in the area. In the last years this activicty became surrounded by polemic, with several incidents between Chinese fishing vessels and Argentine Coast-Guard regarding these operations.
Fish (2E of Río Galegos): represents the fishing areas of the Argentine hake, which was the main fishing product of Argentina.
Whale (3E of Comodoro Rivadavia): Argentina had a significant whaling industry in the past. Also, the Falklands Islands, located near, were historically one important whaling station.

Colonial:
2 Corn (2W1N of Asunción and 1W of Corrientes): represents the grain production in the region that mainly supplied the mining operations in Peru.
4 Cattle (1N of Santa Fé, 1W of Rosario, 1S of La Plata, 1N of Bahía Blanca): represents the scale of the large cattle economy of Argentina. Perhaps we could also add another cattle to the Paraguayan Gran Chaco, however I think that it would leave Paraguay with too much food resources and overlylarge city (Paraguayan entire population nowadays are 7 million).
2 Wine (1S and 1N of Mendoza): represents the main wine-production region of Argentina and is one traditional export product
2 Wheat (1W and 2N of Buenos Aires): also represents the large and traditional wheat production in Argentina. Additionally, we could also add two millets near, with spawn in mid-to-late 20th century to represent the nowadays soybean production. Argentina is the 3rd world producer, behind only of the US and Brazil (Paraguay, as mentioned in the former discussion, is the 9th producer in the world). I didn't done for more or less the same reasons pointed when I discussed Central-West Brazil (too late spawn, given the time scale of the mod, to have any significant impact).
Salt (1NW of Córdoba): this region has numerous and large salt flats and lakes called salares (semi-permanent lakes with high salinity), where salt is explored.
Horses (1SW of Buenos Aires): Argentina has a long horse riding tradition and cattle husbandry with the gauchos. Argentine cavalry was the main force of its army during 19th century and one of the best cavalry corps from South America.

Post-independence:
Iron (1SW of Bahía Blanca): here was located the largest iron mine in Argentina, in Sierra Grande. It should spawn (along with some other resources mentioned bellow) only in the post-independence period because the Spanish didn't really colonized that region, even though they claimed as colony. The Patagonian colonization really began only in the 19th century.
Rare Earths (Salta title): represents the large litium reserves in Argentina and are an exemple of the immense mineral wealth of the Andes.
Cooper (1W of Neuquén): similar case to the above, but with bauxite ore.
Uranium (1W of Mendoza): although Argentina does not have very large uranium reserves, I decide to include it because Argentina developed a nuclear energy industry in late-20th century. In fact, there was some serious geopolitical tension in the 1970s because Argentina and Brazil almost entered in a nuclear race. The main Argentine uranium reserves are located close to there.
Oil (1N of Comodoro Rivadavia): represents where are located the largest oil reserves in Argentina. Alternativelly, you could put the oil near Bahía Blanca, as it is there that are located the major refineries and oil industry.
2 Sheep (1S of Rawson and 1N of Río Galegos): Patagonia has a large wool industry, developed with Argentine colonization of the area. As a fun fact, initially this production was mostly carried by Welsh immigrants and some British settlers that came there from the Falklands.
Coal (2N1W of Río Galegos): one of the main coal mining areas in Argentina, discovered during the competition with Chile for the control of Patagonia.
 
Last edited:
Do you have any idea why the old map (this goes back to Rhye's map) has marshes near Bahia Blanca?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom