Frontier Justice [Game Thread]

[Mat93]

Right, now that Golden has posted, this is my take.

Very much getting an impression of wanting to go with the majority feeling from this post. Vague gut feel of scumminess.

Yes, there is almost no reason for D1 votes. But when you post a reason and you flip flop when you are questioned on your reason...it is scummy. Not the same as what you are saying.
There is no town cred to earn by bussing your team mate on D1.
And, i havent played enough to know the meta on Spaceman or anyone else in this game. So i am just calling it as i see it.

I can agree this is legitimate reasoning for your actions. Not saying I believe it, but its relatively sound logic.

Takhisis is behaving weird. But when he is not? I will not vote for him. I will vote: Atheotes.

Really do not like this vote. Or post. At all.

Outlaws off the starboard bow, Jim.

I could lynch Bsmith today, although he could just as easily be town rather than Outlaw. Hard to tell.

Zym is another possibly candidate, so quiet in the shadows, well worth a noose.

I think it is a little premature for mutli quotes, FOS on the instigators for using wall of text as a umbrella.

Havin a runaway wagon is dangerous as any herder worth salt knows, therefore Vote:Zym

At the time of posting this, there was 3 people with 1 vote, why Xym over the other 2? Also, I dislike the suspicion of the high text posters, and then voting for a low poster. Anyone who doesn't fit in with the 'average' is suspicious?



As it stands I'd be happy with a KingMorgan, atheotes, Jarrema lynch right now. Probably in that order. I could be on board with a Xym lynch.

unvote; vote: KingMorgan

 

[Arakhor]

People lurk; mafia often lurk. Thus, people voting for lurkers is neither new nor unusual.

 

[Jarrema]

vote: BSmith

take it back, man

 

[Takhisis]

He's voting for edse, vote:Jarrema, so why are you defending edse?

 

[DuffKilligan]

Hm, continuing with this logic, vote: Xym, I'm curious what (if anything) you have to say. None of the other cases thus far today have convinced me, though I am getting the feeling that atheotes is flinching a bit hard right now.

The extent of my case goes beyond simply voting for inactivity. It focuses on BSmith's throwaway late in the day (I say late in the day because by that point most people if not all had voted) when there were 3 or so candidates to choose from. To me that seems like trying to avoid being involved in the lynch of a villager. It's classic wolf behavior.

 

[Xym]

I am going to vote: Jarrema.
There do not seem to be a lot of content to the posts, and most of the votes have been unexplained. Including today. Why are you voting for Atheotes?

Outlaws off the starboard bow, Jim.

I could lynch Bsmith today, although he could just as easily be town rather than Outlaw. Hard to tell.

Zym is another possibly candidate, so quiet in the shadows, well worth a noose.

I think it is a little premature for mutli quotes, FOS on the instigators for using wall of text as a umbrella.

Havin a runaway wagon is dangerous as any herder worth salt knows, therefore Vote:Zym

I have not even been in the shadows, and have only just now caught up. What made you believe I was lurking?

I have not seen this. Yes, there are multiquotes, but I do not really see that being used as an umbrella.

My name looks much better with an 'X' instead of the 'Z'.

Right, now that Golden has posted, this is my take.

BSSmith is still a dirty ex-mod. Nothing will change that. But I can buy dirty ex mods being busy. If he and mat both have the excuse of being busy, and xym does not, then logically xym must be the best option to lynch given no info, which I still think is the case.

Vote:xym

Why are your candidates between very low posters? There is more information than that at this stage, surely. And you could have looked at that before hearing from GK.

honestly I'm allright with either of the top two hanging. I've already discussed atheotes. Xym, post something to make me not allright with hanging you

Zack question: What happens if the vote ties 4/4 at EOD and the cat in the hat isn't voting to lynch anyone? (e.g. if I switch my vote to Xym and no one else votes what happens)

I have never been very good at that.

 

[Jarrema]

I am going to vote: Jarrema.
There do not seem to be a lot of content to the posts, and most of the votes have been unexplained. Including today. Why are you voting for Atheotes?

I'm not

 

[Kennigit]

DuffKilligan - thoughts on anyone besides BSmith? Like 99% of your thread content has been about him (everything except initial random vote). No idea what quicktopic content you might have if you're scum

Spoiler Duff's posts :

Vote Takhisis His hair needs to be covered with a hat.

Oops Vote Takhisis

Unvote; Vote KingMorgan

Interesting post by BSmith, a complete throwaway this late in the day with multiple candidates available to choose from (even excluding the tie). Will keep note of it later.

BSmith still is the one candidate who sticks out the most to me. He came on, posted a complete throwaway late in the day, and then disappeared. He's not involved in discussion and he is our best lynch.

Vote BSmith

The extent of my case goes beyond simply voting for inactivity. It focuses on BSmith's throwaway late in the day (I say late in the day because by that point most people if not all had voted) when there were 3 or so candidates to choose from. To me that seems like trying to avoid being involved in the lynch of a villager. It's classic wolf behavior.

I was operating under the premise that people who have made Western jokes are probably town, but now the number has grown larger (kingmorgan, takhisis, me, johannak [deceased], I'm sure others)

Duff and mat made hat jokes, also someone else probably about fashion. But it almost feels like you are posting on a quicktopic and forgot you haven't posted here enough duff


The only thing worse than an outlaw seeking to destroy justice is an unfunny outlaw

 

[Xym]

I'm not

Oh, oops.

vote: BSmith

take it back, man

But this does not make sense to me either.

 

[spaceman98]

I'm going to bed soon and have a busy day tomorrow, so this is the last post I'll make today:

First a tally, based on Zack's earlier work:

3 atheotes (Kennigit, Al Sipsclar, Jarrema)

3 Xym (SouthernKing, KingMorgan, Omega124)

3 BSmith1068 (DuffKilligan, Arakhor, Jarrema)

2 Jarrema (Takhisis, Xym)

1 Al Sipsclar (spaceman98)
1 edse (BSmith1068)
1 spaceman98 (atheotes)
1 SouthernKing (edse)
1 KingMorgan (Mat93)



Right now there is a 3-way tie for first due to mat unvoting Athetoes and moving onto King Morgan. If this tie stays this way Tak will decide, and Jarrema will hang.

Jarrema's unexplained vote on BSmith looks very sketch, so I'd rather the final lynch not be BSmith just because of that (unless Jarrema you care to explain). Beyond that though, I'm fine with Atheotes, Jarrema or Xym out of the leading candidates (in that order). I still want to hear more from Al Sipsclar, so I'll keep my vote where it is I think. He's made exactly one post today (a vote for atheotes). Atheotes for his part has retained a laser-like focus on me, stopping only to defend himself. Your opinions on anyone else? (my suspicion of Sipsclar is all that's stopping me from voting you)

I'll try to check the thread tomorrow morning and pick my top candidate out of the tie, but no guarantees

 

[edse]

I was operating under the premise that people who have made Western jokes are probably town, but now the number has grown larger (kingmorgan, takhisis, me, johannak [deceased], I'm sure others)

Duff and mat made hat jokes, also someone else probably about fashion. But it almost feels like you are posting on a quicktopic and forgot you haven't posted here enough duff


The only thing worse than an outlaw seeking to destroy justice is an unfunny outlaw

I did a Star Trek joke, where does that put me?

 

[Zack]

Time remaining: [TIMER=3/25/2016 2:00 PM CDT; Day 2 Over][/TIMER]


LYNCH:

Spoiler :

3 BSmith1068 (DuffKilligan, Arakhor, Jarrema)
3 Xym (SouthernKing, KingMorgan, Omega124)

2 atheotes (Kennigit, Al Sipsclar)
2 Jarrema (Takhisis, Xym)

1 Al Sipsclar (spaceman98)
1 edse (BSmith1068)
1 KingMorgan (Mat93)
1 SouthernKing (edse)
1 spaceman98 (atheotes)

---

Not Voting: none

Not Posting, Not Voting: none

 

[DuffKilligan]

DuffKilligan - thoughts on anyone besides BSmith? Like 99% of your thread content has been about him (everything except initial random vote). No idea what quicktopic content you might have if you're scum

I generally focus on the candidate who I think is the best lynch, and then later in the game I give my full thoughts as I gather more info. But I have some info so here. I'm confused why you think focusing on a nonexistent quicktopic thread is a good idea to build a case on why I'm a wolf.

Spaceman: His posts have been well thought out and clearly show effort, so I'm leaning villager on him.

Mat93: Also getting slight villager vibes from him. Nothing he has said has triggered my wolf radar.

Jamerra isn't really explaining his votes, so as of now he's slightly wolfish, though could be a lazy villager.

KingMorgan: Does he always put forth no effort? Mat93 makes a good point about him and I consider him to be fairly wolfish, though in the 2 other games I've played with him this seems to be normal behavior for him. Never the less I'd be fine with his lynching.

I also agree that atheos' posting has been suspect, and would be fine with his lynching. His voting hasn't made a whole lot of sense. I would bet a lot that there is at least 1 wolf between BSmith, Atheos, and KingMorgan.

What is the current case on xym? I haven't gotten any vibes villager or wolf from xym so far.

 

[atheotes]

I generally focus on the candidate who I think is the best lynch, and then later in the game I give my full thoughts as I gather more info. But I have some info so here. I'm confused why you think focusing on a nonexistent quicktopic thread is a good idea to build a case on why I'm a wolf.

Spaceman: His posts have been well thought out and clearly show effort, so I'm leaning villager on him.

Mat93: Also getting slight villager vibes from him. Nothing he has said has triggered my wolf radar.

Jamerra isn't really explaining his votes, so as of now he's slightly wolfish, though could be a lazy villager.

KingMorgan: Does he always put forth no effort? Mat93 makes a good point about him and I consider him to be fairly wolfish, though in the 2 other games I've played with him this seems to be normal behavior for him. Never the less I'd be fine with his lynching.

I also agree that atheos' posting has been suspect, and would be fine with his lynching. His voting hasn't made a whole lot of sense. I would bet a lot that there is at least 1 wolf between BSmith, Atheos, and KingMorgan.

What is the current case on xym? I haven't gotten any vibes villager or wolf from xym so far.

Whoa, am I the only one who feels this post reeks of conformity.
Unvote; vote Duff

 

[Mat93]

I'm not

Still not liking the lack of content. 2 word posts aren't exactly helpful.

LYNCH:2 atheotes (Mat93, Kennigit, Al Sipsclar, Jarrema)

Ummm. Is this correct?

 

[Zack]

fixed

 

[spaceman98]

unvote: vote: atheotes
sipsclar isn't getting lynched today. I'm fine with it being Jarrema or Xym. More iffy of BSmith.

If anyone wants to be bold and push a candidate on top of the pile now's the time. Otherwise Jarrema hangs which is fine

 

[DuffKilligan]

Whoa, am I the only one who feels this post reeks of conformity.
Unvote; vote Duff

How does it reek of conformity? Because I agree that you're a solid lynch?

 

[Al Sipsclar]

1. Jarrema – Not really providing much reasoning behind votes. Possibly scum
2. KingMorgan – Doesn’t actually have a lot of content for being one of the wagons. I would have expected more. Possible that team members “saved” him yesterday. Possibly scum.
3. Mat93 – No real read. I take him at his word that he is busy (hell I am too!). Possibly scum.
4. BSmith1068 – confirmed vanilla townie (to me anyway!)
5. DuffKilligan – Fine to call out my first post, especially since he doesn’t really know me yet. A bit disingenuous though to think it came late in the day (about 21 hours left in the day). Either town pushing good thoughts or scum building a case for future lynch. Possibly scum.
6. Atheotes – Active and working through ideas. Some controversy around said ideas, though. Not sure he warrants a runaway wagon today. Possibly scum.
7. Edse – 3 posts. No real content. Posted today. Possibly scum.
8. SouthernKing – Eager to jump on a wagon yesterday (3rd I think). Going the other direction today with a vote on someone less active than me. Possibly scum.
9. Takhisis – Typical unreadable self. Possibly scum
10. Omega124 – Reactionary, but not necessarily out of context with her personality and being new to the scene. She did have a bit of pressure right out of the gate. That said, possibly scum.
11. Al Sipsclar – Fairly active, putting forth opinions. Liked his post about me being desperate to survive N1. Possibly scum.
12. Kennigit – I like his style. Seems to be having a lot of fun with this game. Possibly Scum
13. Arakhor – Agree with him that the wagons on D1 all seemed to form out of nowhere and didn’t really have any reasoning behind them. That said an easy case to make especially if the wagons all end up being townies. Possibly scum.
14. spaceman98 – Lots of analysis and posts. I’ve seen this with both scum and town spaceman though. Do wish he would use multi quote or Word to write his posts with the proper quotes inserted. Possibly scum.
15. Xym – No read one way or the other – Possibly scum.

Bottom line – any one of you could be scum at this point. There isn’t enough information yet to clear anyone. I am going to vote: edse though. He is certainly present yet has been absent of any real content or contribution.

I don't believe you. Why am I not your top suspect? Vote: BSmith1068

 

[KingMorgan]

Sorry for any perceived lack of effort.

I am happy to be bold. unvote Vote:atheotes