I love the idea of the site and so far so good. I can already give a few tweaks:
- Right now theres an edit check that doesnt allow you to load up a turn unless the Civ game name matches the PBEMtracker name
exactly... this is a good feature, but I don't know that its 100% necessary. Maybe have it give a warning to alert the user that it
may be the wrong game, but allow them to load anyway if need be. My second iteration of this game didn't load because of this - although admittedly I should have been more careful and it wouldn't have been an issue if I had used it ever before!
- I don't know what happens when its a persons turn, but an email sent to the sign-up address would be ideal to alert them that the turn is on them. This may happen already, i wouldnt know yet since I haven't gotten my second turn
But definitely don't worry about it - I love the site already and appreciate the efforts as I'm sure many others do. Its a great concept, my props to you. I may be able to organize a game like this, but if you asked me to design a website I would be as blind as a bat!