Never before seen wonders - Elimination Thread

[luigilime]

I've edited the round so we can consider this over?

Round 1
1. Churches of Lalibela
2. Pyramid of the Sun
3. Cologne Cathedral
4. Sri Harmandir Sahib
5. Tōdai-ji
6. Leshan Giant Buddha
7. Empire State Building
8. Abu Simbel
9. Saksaq Waman
10. Karlštejn Castle
11. Monk's Mound
12. Great Mosque of Kairouan
13. Delta Works
14. El Capitolio
15. Brooklyn Bridge

Round 2
1. Santa Maria del fiore
2. Karnak temple
3. Palais des papes
4. Tomb of antiochus
5. Chrysler building
6. Gyeongbokgung Palace
7. St. Mark's Basilica
8. Cliff Palace
9. Cairo Citadel
10. Al-Qarawiyyin Mosque and University
11. Cothon of Carthage
12. Qorikancha
13. Smithsonian Institution
14. Teatro Amazonas
15. Caral Pyramids
16. Coney Island
17. Burj al Arab
18. (Set Maat)
19. Spring Temple Buddha
20. Parkes Observatory
21. Ostankino Tower
22. Humberstone and Santa Laura Saltpeter Works

 

[Kimiimaro]

Karnak Temples 22-3=19 - Great, but the option below is better.
Santa Maria del Fiore 34+1=35 - The best option.

My list is coming soon.

 

[luigilime]

Karnak Temples 19-3=16 let's end this
Santa Maria del Fiore 35+1=36

 

[Guandao]

Karnak Temples 16-3=13 Sorry Karnak, you're losing...
Santa Maria del Fiore 36+1=37 Might as well vote for the winning team....Italiamania has take over Ideas & Suggestions subforum

 

[Roman Citizen]

My suggestions are
Burj Khalifa
Tomb of Khai Dinh
Catherine Palace
Sagarada Famailia
Ishtar Gate
Cluny Abbey
Ely Cathedral
Lotus Temple
Roman Panthenon
Altare Della Patriia
Seattle space needle
Crazy Horse Memorial
Las Vegas Stratosphere
Akshardham temple
NORAD Cheyenne mountain complex
ST. Louis Gateway Arch
Las Lajas Sanctuary
Dresden Frauenkirche
Krakow Cloth hall
Hassan tower
Hassan II mosque

 

[God of Kings]

NORAD Cheyenne Mountain Complex would be an interesting wonder: increased range for air units, increased city defence, increased amenities, and increased faith; the last two pertains to its Santa-tracking.

There aren't many late-game military wonders that increase amenities or faith.

 

[Kimiimaro]

St. Barbara's Church (Kutná Hora, Czech Republic)
St. Vitus Cathedral (Prague, Czech Republic)
Pilgrimage Church of Saint John of Nepomuk (Czech Republic)
Ještěd Tower (Czech Republic)
Pont du Gard (France)
Grand Bazaar (Istanbul, Turkey)
Galata Tower (Istanbul, Turkey)
Arc de Triomphe (Paris, France)
Castel del Monte (Italy)
Milan Cathedral (Milan, Italy)
Lotus Temple (Delhi, India)
Etemenanki/Tower of Babel (Iraq)

 

[Xandinho]

Just one question, who will choose the suggestions for the next round? Since Siptah is not following the forum because he would be without connection and time lately

 

[Kimiimaro]

Just one question, who will choose the suggestions for the next round? Since Siptah is not following the forum because he would be without connection and time lately

We'll either have to wait or start another elimination thread on this topic, like "never before seen wonders elimination thread II".

 

[luigilime]

Just one question, who will choose the suggestions for the next round? Since Siptah is not following the forum because he would be without connection and time lately

Good question, Do you want to do it?

 

[Phrozen]

Two suggestions from my home area:

Chesapeake Bay Bridge-Tunnel: Very long bridge and tunnel system, 23 miles, across the mouth of the Chesapeake.
Newport News Shipbuilding & Drydocks: Only place in the world that makes non sloped deck aircraft carriers. If it is a famous carrier, it was probably built there.

 

[Xandinho]

We'll either have to wait or start another elimination thread on this topic, like "never before seen wonders elimination thread II".

Good question, Do you want to do it?

I could choose the suggestions, and we could start the third round in this thread. Or do you prefer that we create another thread? I think there is no problem to do here.
Twenty-two wonders would be a good amount?

 

[Kimiimaro]

I could choose the suggestions, and we could start the third round in this thread. Or do you prefer that we create another thread? I think there is no problem to do here.
Twenty-two wonders would be a good amount?

The rankings would be quite chaotic if they were posted on page 23. I'm for the new thread variant.

 

[God of Kings]

The rankings would be quite chaotic if they were posted on page 23. I'm for the new thread variant.

We can have a new thread. After all, there's two threads for elimination threads pertaining to new leaders for Civ VI.

 

[Zaarin]

Willis Tower

No one in America calls it that. Personally I'd rather see the Burj Khalifa; at least it's not a complete eyesore like Sears Tower.

 

[Manifold]

Karnak Temples 14 (13+1) construction time over 2000 years
Santa Maria del Fiore 34 (37-3) is this a ww? maybe, but another dome ? like Rome's Pantheon, St. Peter's Basilica, Hagia Sophia ...this is already in the game...and the dome as separate tile is not good. Karnak Temples would look great!

 

[Kimiimaro]

Karnak Temples 14 (13+1) construction time over 2000 years
Santa Maria del Fiore 34 (37-3) is this a ww? maybe, but another dome ? like Rome's Pantheon, St. Peter's Basilica, Hagia Sophia ...this is already in the game...and the dome as separate tile is not good. Karnak Temples would look great!

The second round already ended

 

[Manifold]

The second round already ended

why?

 

[Zaarin]

why?

Because you and I are the only ones voting for Karnak, which means the outcome is pretty inevitable.

 

[Xandinho]

The fall of the Karnak Temples is inevitable, can I create the other thread with third round tomorrow or do you prefer to wait for this round to be finalized before creating another round? However, we already know the winner